Marrakech Intense (Eau de Toilette) by Aēsop

Marrakech Intense 2014 Eau de Toilette

FvSpee
02/07/2018 - 06:20 AM
22
Top Review
6Scent 5Longevity 6Sillage 8Bottle

Fabulous Cardamom Sketch, Clumsily Finished

The Kingdom of Morocco has only about 35 million inhabitants, roughly the same as Poland or Spain. Nevertheless, and although it is quite far from Germany and belongs to a culturally rather foreign region, the Moroccan cities, many of them, have achieved considerable fame here. Casablanca (known among other things from the film of the same name), Rabat (the capital), and Agadir (as a tourist destination or because of the "Panther Jump") are probably "known" by everyone. But also Tangier (with its highly interesting recent past as an international zone), Fes, possibly Meknes and Essaouira, and definitely Marrakech should at least be "somehow" familiar to most. It's actually exciting because, although Poland borders Germany, most people would probably not be able to name many more Polish cities spontaneously.

The other question is whether we "in the West" associate something very specific with these Moroccan cities, or whether their names represent rather interchangeable symbols for us, each conjuring an image of a magnificent Almoravid royal palace with a garden, a souk filled with bags of spices, and a coffee in a copper pot (or a heavily sweetened tea with lots of fresh mint in a glass) in our mind's eye. I suspect that the folks at Aesop (to whom I have already written a few unflattering lines in my comment on "Hwyl") were more inclined towards the second alternative when naming this fragrance, aiming to set a clearly recognizable sign of "oriental scent" rather than connecting to specific Marrakechiensia. As for the name addition "Intense" (which I find aesthetically inappropriate alongside the term "Marrakech," and which I actually consider more of a joke, I will elaborate on that), it reminds us that the fragrance apparently originated as a flanker to "Marrakech" from the same house but has now been left standing alone, as "Marrakech" has disappeared from the market. If the "Marrakech" of blessed memory was even less "intense" than "Marrakech Intense," then its disappearance is more than justified.

Despite the flashy oriental name, "MI" is not a typical, and certainly not a boring or even ordinary oriental fragrance. Above all, it is neither heavy nor overly sweet. I actually know no other scent of this kind. The core of this fragrance, the "falcon" so to speak, is the cardamom-citrus motif in the top note. The clove mentioned in previous comments and statements is, in my perception, not dominant at all; in fact, I hardly notice it separately, as it really just rounds off the experience. In contrast, the cardamom with its very special ethereal-oily spicy freshness is unmistakable. At the beginning, one really thinks they are smelling freshly ground cardamom pods, almost tasting them just before they are added as a spice to an Arabic coffee. This cardamom scent is framed and softened by citrus notes that seemed orangey to me, but very light and airy (bergamot and neroli in the ingredient list are plausible). Thus, it does not become too heavy-spiced but retains a playful, sprightly, and cheerful freshness. This motif is highly interesting and could have made a wonderful top note for a thrillingly composed fantastic fragrance. But unfortunately, after that, there is not much left for my nose, except for a few lackluster single notes. After about an hour, I perceive a distinct (by no means unpleasant) rose scent, and after about 4 hours, everything diffuses into a vague sweet-woody (not sweet-licorice) base.

The whole thing reminds me of the unfinished score of a great composer, which was then "completed" by a third-rate student after his death and then brought to market. As it stands now, it is not inspiring.

In conclusion, this is my second Aesop test and my second disappointment regarding sillage and especially longevity. I know, a good fragrance does not necessarily have to be long-lasting, nor does it have to be a good and expensive fragrance. But with a fragrance that is rather pricey in the "Oriental" genre with wood, jasmine, and rose in the ingredient list, I do expect it to accompany me throughout the day. This is not the case here.

Conclusion: Great and quite fitting cardamom-citrus motif for Morocco, but disappointing as a perfume in overall impression.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
11 Comments
ChizzaChizza 5 years ago
Yes, I can understand you. I don't think it's bad, but it doesn't blow me away.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GlobomanniGlobomanni 7 years ago
The beginning is SUPER - unfortunately, the end is disappointing.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 8 years ago
Very informative write-up. Thank you for that. I really love the smell of cardamom. When I crush the green pods in the mortar and then add kaffir leaves, the mix smells amazing. It's a shame that not much thought seems to have gone into the surrounding aspects.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParmaParma 8 years ago
Super informative comment! The Hwyl that I was able to test thanks to you, I found surprisingly low in longevity for such a deep scent. There must be some truth to that.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FvSpeeFvSpee 8 years ago
I would be cautious for now about excusing the weaknesses with the line 'it's just eco.' While the brand does maintain a nature-friendly image, I don't think it has any reliable certifications.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeeroseSeerose 8 years ago
From the previous answer, I gather that it's basically an eco-fragrance. Well, you can't expect too much in terms of complexity, longevity, or sillage, which can only be very good at the beginning with these scents. The openings are often promising. But without the fixatives, stabilizers, Firmenich & Co - fragrance materials we're used to, it's at least a bit of an adjustment for us.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 8 years ago
Very nuanced presentation. I really like it! I have Aesop Mystra in my collection, which I'm quite satisfied with - at least when it comes to the scent itself. I can't say anything about longevity and sillage off the top of my head.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DasguteLebenDasguteLeben 8 years ago
It's a shame, but given the brand's 100% natural AND cosmetics/wellness background, I'm not surprised by the weakness. Specifically, "naturalists" like Dubrana and Neuffer, who specialize in perfume, are usually more convincing when it comes to good structure and longevity.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TtfortwoTtfortwo 8 years ago
The top note you described brings back memories of Andalusia for me. Does that fit?


Otherwise, I can totally understand your disappointment. Not all fragrances need to be long-lasting powerhouses (sometimes that can even be off-putting; at some point, you want to refresh your scent), but fragrances that seem to rely solely on their top note are, well, how else can I put it, incomplete? Wouldn't you agree?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FrauLohseFrauLohse 8 years ago
For me, they would probably be interchangeable **chiffres**, although it’s also quite astonishing how these once opulent cities have somewhat turned into a **moloch** over time. It's interesting to read again and described plausibly for those unfamiliar with the scent.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
OhdeberlinOhdeberlin 8 years ago
A great comment, well articulated and very close to the scent. And the early death of the fragrance magic due to the lack of talent of the third-rate student ;-) ... Exactly how I feel....
Translated · Show originalShow translation