Geste Humięcki & Graef 2008
19
Top Review
We couldn't come together
I have been circling around this scent for a long time. But I could never bring myself to add it to my collection. In my search for my musk fragrance, dear Aura kindly sent me a sample of it back in January 2014 - thanks again, dear! By now, I have completely squeezed out the sample! And recently, I had the opportunity to fish out a leftover bottle and was able to let it work on me in peace once again.
My relationship with this scent is very ambivalent. On one hand, I like it. On the other hand, it annoys me. I find it extraordinarily difficult to describe how it smells now. Fortunately, I have never perceived anything resinous, otherwise it would have been out right away. Geste is fresh, spicy, somewhat musky, simultaneously warm and cool, soft, and has the potential to be a signature scent - and yet all of that is also not true at the same time.
Geste only seems pleasing at first sniff. Hardly have you settled in comfortably, something irritating comes along, almost a bit experimental. Edges and corners, indeed. Because there is an undertone, a very synthetic one, that unfortunately gets on my nerves when I wear the scent for more than a day. And one day is long, as the longevity of Geste is fantastic. And then I felt like wearing Geste again, and it annoyed me once more, and so on…
I tried. But nothing came of us. That's a pity, but unfortunately, it can't be changed. Therefore, it now delights someone else.
My relationship with this scent is very ambivalent. On one hand, I like it. On the other hand, it annoys me. I find it extraordinarily difficult to describe how it smells now. Fortunately, I have never perceived anything resinous, otherwise it would have been out right away. Geste is fresh, spicy, somewhat musky, simultaneously warm and cool, soft, and has the potential to be a signature scent - and yet all of that is also not true at the same time.
Geste only seems pleasing at first sniff. Hardly have you settled in comfortably, something irritating comes along, almost a bit experimental. Edges and corners, indeed. Because there is an undertone, a very synthetic one, that unfortunately gets on my nerves when I wear the scent for more than a day. And one day is long, as the longevity of Geste is fantastic. And then I felt like wearing Geste again, and it annoyed me once more, and so on…
I tried. But nothing came of us. That's a pity, but unfortunately, it can't be changed. Therefore, it now delights someone else.
Translated · Show original
16 Comments
TasteExplore 10 years ago
I felt the same way about it... bought it - wore it - loved it - got annoyed - parted ways... it's a great scent, but we just don't match...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Pluto 10 years ago
Hmm, I have it on my watchlist. Maybe it will cross my path soon.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Ergoproxy 10 years ago
It left me cold.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParfumAholic 10 years ago
I love the top note, especially the violet combined with the musk. Unfortunately, it’s very "fleeting" for me. I’ll test it again when the temperatures are above 20 degrees, because I actually think it’s great... or maybe not? I get you.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Mandelmaus 10 years ago
What a shame, it sounds beautiful. The right wrong one, I guess XD better things will come ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Ormeli 10 years ago
Maybe the resin is subtly annoying. That stuff can be quite thick sometimes :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Yatagan 10 years ago
I really like the brand, but it won't be joining my collection either.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
JoT 10 years ago
Ahhh! So you snatched it right out from under my nose :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Almira 10 years ago
I fell in love with it right away; since then, it’s been my signature scent. I don’t know of any comparable fragrance, but you’re right, it’s definitely polarizing.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Cravache 10 years ago
Strange fragrance line. Skarb and especially Bosque (the scent of Zurich/Zurich's forests) appealed to me. Nice comment.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Zora 10 years ago
I feel like I've already tested it, but it clearly didn't leave a lasting impression on me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Milou 10 years ago
You put it into words exactly how I feel about Geste! In the end, it’s more of a scent than a perfume for me; kind of nice but still too peculiar...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Gaukeleya 10 years ago
I found it quite good, although not as good as Bosque. Unfortunately, I wore my sample during a stressful time, so it’s forever associated with that for me...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Meggi 10 years ago
I couldn't with that one either.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Seerose 10 years ago
Humieckie & Graefe are quite unique; I found this one tolerable, but others, on the contrary, didn't impress me at all.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Sinioerkel 10 years ago
I know exactly what you mean. I can't live with it, but I can't live without it either. On one hand, it repels me, and on the other, it attracts me. Strange scent. Ambivalence trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation

