Van-Île Jacques Zolty 2014
17
Top Review
To be let off the leash
A brief, sugary-floral flurry, vanilla of the floral kind, heliotrope from the Oetker nursery; then… oh? A hint of dirt in it. The acidity also briefly reminds me of the greasiness of Mona-Vanilla.
The interpretation of this is obvious: the patchouli, although not the main actor, gives its all character-wise. This will not be a charmer. I smell sweet orange (well, more like mandarin…) and, if you like, almond, along with soft-creamy floral notes with just a slight heliotrope touch - and yet everything is seriously tempered by a sour-greasy note on the threshold of smoke.
This mentioned contrast accompanies me throughout the morning. With such a strong counterpart, the vanilla alongside its companions can bravely venture into prickly heliotrope, even putting a toe into - in and of itself - cloying florality.
And the boundaries are thoroughly tested. On its own, I would find this quite unbearable, certainly a vanilla brat, but in combination, it is exciting. The (admittedly somewhat over-the-top) Mona-Vanilla comes to mind again. Not a scent twin(!), just another vanilla with extremely prickly opponents.
Around noon, the patchouli unfolds ambitions to approach leather. That the vanilla, so to speak, in anticipatory obedience, has become darker and less floral fits perfectly. Apparently, the squabbles have come to an end. This somewhat more harmonious, yet still striking part of today’s candidate pleases me the most.
“However” and “Unfortunately”…
To the “However”: However, the contrary appearance only works if the patchouli is indeed let off the leash with a sufficiently bold application. Those who proceed too timidly will instead quickly arrive at…
…“Unfortunately”: Unfortunately, Van-Île leaves the high plateau again. In the progressing afternoon and evening, a plastic note bothers me, which both ruins the vanilla and also tumbles around a kind of sweet-caramel “Werther’s Original” aroma at the H-cream cliff. I find the scent particularly musky at no time. Even less animalistic, unless perhaps a rubber duck is meant.
Conclusion: It’s a shame that the ending becomes so unpleasant. I quite liked the front part.
I thank Ergoproxy for the sample.
The interpretation of this is obvious: the patchouli, although not the main actor, gives its all character-wise. This will not be a charmer. I smell sweet orange (well, more like mandarin…) and, if you like, almond, along with soft-creamy floral notes with just a slight heliotrope touch - and yet everything is seriously tempered by a sour-greasy note on the threshold of smoke.
This mentioned contrast accompanies me throughout the morning. With such a strong counterpart, the vanilla alongside its companions can bravely venture into prickly heliotrope, even putting a toe into - in and of itself - cloying florality.
And the boundaries are thoroughly tested. On its own, I would find this quite unbearable, certainly a vanilla brat, but in combination, it is exciting. The (admittedly somewhat over-the-top) Mona-Vanilla comes to mind again. Not a scent twin(!), just another vanilla with extremely prickly opponents.
Around noon, the patchouli unfolds ambitions to approach leather. That the vanilla, so to speak, in anticipatory obedience, has become darker and less floral fits perfectly. Apparently, the squabbles have come to an end. This somewhat more harmonious, yet still striking part of today’s candidate pleases me the most.
“However” and “Unfortunately”…
To the “However”: However, the contrary appearance only works if the patchouli is indeed let off the leash with a sufficiently bold application. Those who proceed too timidly will instead quickly arrive at…
…“Unfortunately”: Unfortunately, Van-Île leaves the high plateau again. In the progressing afternoon and evening, a plastic note bothers me, which both ruins the vanilla and also tumbles around a kind of sweet-caramel “Werther’s Original” aroma at the H-cream cliff. I find the scent particularly musky at no time. Even less animalistic, unless perhaps a rubber duck is meant.
Conclusion: It’s a shame that the ending becomes so unpleasant. I quite liked the front part.
I thank Ergoproxy for the sample.
Translated · Show original
14 Comments
Sweetsmell75 8 years ago
ich fand den ganz toll ... aber so richtig gepasst hatte er dann doch nicht zu mir
Jumi 8 years ago
Ende gut, alles gut - träfe hier wohl auch zu, wenn bloss die Ente nicht wäre :)
Azahar 8 years ago
Ich habe gestern an meiner in der Sonne stehenden Gummiente geschnüffelt (denn ich habe die blöde Angewohnheit an so ziemlich allem zu schnüffeln) und fand das Ding riecht irgendwie lecker....
Inger 8 years ago
Für einen Kauf hat's bei mir nicht gereicht!
Pluto 8 years ago
Ich lass dir eine Gummiente zu Wasser Herr Müller-Lüdenscheid :o)
Can777 8 years ago
Alsooo! Ich nehme die Ente. Aber heute ohne Duft. Das ist nicht mein Schema.
MisterE 8 years ago
1
Naja. Was bringt der tolle Anfang mit einwm miesen Ente ?
Ergoproxy 8 years ago
Ich fand die animalische Gummiente recht charmant, aber kein Kaufkandidat für mich.
Palonera 8 years ago
Ich hab' mir die Vanille im März aus Bozen mitgebracht, bisher aber noch kein Näschen genommen - mal sehen, wie weit unsere Eindrücke diesmal übereinstimmen.
Gschpusi 8 years ago
Treffend beschrieben, für mich ist das "Ende" auch nicht so schön.
MarWic 8 years ago
Von mir bekam diese Zitronen-Würz-Vanille volle Punktzahl-selten einen so spannenden Vanille-Duft getestet-von Gummi-Ente keine Spur.....
Yatagan 8 years ago
Klingt nicht so ganz nach Merkliste...
Gelis 8 years ago
Bin sowas von überhaupt nicht neugierig auf diesen Duft... Schließe mich Seerose an, Eichenmoos klingt unpassend, aber Du scheinst ihn auch nicht bemerkt zu haben.
Seerose 8 years ago
Da steht: Eichenmoos, stelle ich mir unharmonisch vor in diesem Duft, oder ist es nur so als Vorschlag gelistet, oder vielleicht als Gummiente getarnt?

