9
Less helpful Review
The Faint Whiff of a Women's Fragrance
After already owning two real highlights from Parfums de Marly (Layton and the simply magnificent Oajan), I made a blind purchase of Herod. I should have left it alone; however, a sample was included with the fragrance itself. Thus, in the end, I was relieved to be able to return the original packaged bottle.
After the first test, I initially perceived very little to nothing at all. The two other Marlys mentioned above hit you almost immediately and then embark on a wonderful journey of development. Herod, on the other hand, remains quiet, very quiet, with a hint of tobacco, a bit of smoke. None of the listed notes can I directly perceive here, except for later a feminine cherry note, paired with floral accords. Almost like roses, lily of the valley.
In anticipation of hopefully a more masculine development soon, I waited in vain. On the contrary. The fragrance remains linearly feminine and disappears again after just an hour! Additionally, my nose was in direct (!) contact with my arm. Hello? Where are you, please!?
IS THIS REALLY IT FOR SUCH AN EXPENSIVE FRAGRANCE? Unbelievable…
Where are the guarantees for masculine notes like tobacco and incense? Not present, not even remotely recognizable.
The tester was applied again after a week. Sometimes you just have a bad day. Unfortunately, the cited experience repeated itself.
No guys, this is not acceptable, return initiated.
100 of my other conventional fragrances have a significantly stronger character and presence than this one. For me, it's a fake-both in price and content.
After the first test, I initially perceived very little to nothing at all. The two other Marlys mentioned above hit you almost immediately and then embark on a wonderful journey of development. Herod, on the other hand, remains quiet, very quiet, with a hint of tobacco, a bit of smoke. None of the listed notes can I directly perceive here, except for later a feminine cherry note, paired with floral accords. Almost like roses, lily of the valley.
In anticipation of hopefully a more masculine development soon, I waited in vain. On the contrary. The fragrance remains linearly feminine and disappears again after just an hour! Additionally, my nose was in direct (!) contact with my arm. Hello? Where are you, please!?
IS THIS REALLY IT FOR SUCH AN EXPENSIVE FRAGRANCE? Unbelievable…
Where are the guarantees for masculine notes like tobacco and incense? Not present, not even remotely recognizable.
The tester was applied again after a week. Sometimes you just have a bad day. Unfortunately, the cited experience repeated itself.
No guys, this is not acceptable, return initiated.
100 of my other conventional fragrances have a significantly stronger character and presence than this one. For me, it's a fake-both in price and content.
Translated · Show original
10 Comments
PatrickSchi 3 years ago
I feel the same way. For over 200 euros, I expected better performance. Especially since the other PdM fragrances I tried had much more to offer.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BeatriceA 3 years ago
The cherry you smelled IS tobacco: tobacco isn't such a masculine note; I mostly perceive it as fruity. I sold my Oajan back then because it was too sweet for me; I found Herod a bit more robust. It lasted well, the sillage was expansive, one spray was enough. My sharing participants could also perceive the scent well. That was quite a few years ago.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Musikus70 3 years ago
I feel the same way. I can't understand the hype. It's just a cinnamon-cherry scent.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Marth 3 years ago
2
One of my absolute top 3 fragrances! Love at first spray!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Robi8700 3 years ago
Maybe you have a fake - Herod is really strong and everyone "notices" it positively - maybe it's like with BR540 for you - I can't smell that one at all.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
RockabillyD 3 years ago
1
I don't smell br540 either... but I do smell Herod. I find it very spicy and smoky at the beginning.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Einfalt 3 years ago
Not fake, but old, weak batches; the really old ones and the new ones are supposed to be much stronger.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Bibogat 3 years ago
I don't think Douglas sends out fakes.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Mirko1909 3 years ago
1
And so we are all different... luckily not everyone drives a Skoda 🙃
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Terra 3 years ago
1
Basically the Layton of cars :D
Translated · Show originalShow translation

