Sweet Tooth Lemon Pie Sabrina Carpenter 2025

oh my god i've never thought i'd like a lemon perfume! normally i hate them sm because they either smell like dish/floor cleaners or are just super synthetic/ often mixed w spicy notes (i absolutely despise them) BUT- i randomly went to rossmann the other day, sniffed it, and damn... went back the next day and immediately bough it, i think it says enough ;3 mind you- i consider myself a huge devotion hater bc to me it smells like headache-inducing spicy rum with extremely synthetic citrus, this one isn't even REMINISCENT of that abomination!! i am a slavic girlie who was growing up from early 2010s and we have a tradition of eating a lemon poundcake (babka cytrynowa!!) on Easter- this is exactly that :DD
like literally, opens like an EXTREMELY photorealistic lemon poundcake, then dries down to this absolutely scrumptious biscuit crust (i love this part the most!!!)
brina pleasee give us a white chocolate smores frag with this particular biscuit accord, bc i'm literally obsessed!!!

I really thought I hated lemon gourmands or any citrusy gourmands until I smelled that one... That's just so good, and honestly that's probably one of her best ones after my favorite of all time Sweet Tooth Eau de Parfum . This opens up with a sweet lemony scent, it's quickly followed by a super gourmand/ crusty cookie note, it's super good and the lemon doesn't smell off putting, it's very sugary and easy to love. it fades into a creamy vanilla - soft meringue and this is where I can agree with the "lemon pie" name.
I'm the most fan of the cookie part of this perfume, absolutely SO realistic. Incredible !

The mixed reviews left me wondering how this might be. Whenever there's controversy surrounding any fragrance, it naturally makes me want to try it even more than things that are universally liked.

This is a simplistic, vanillic, lemon with a certain cookie/bready/wafer-y accord. It smells almost exactly like lemon wafers! Which...are a frequently despised dessert...so I suppose a certain amount of hate is understandable. I like them though.

I tried to figure out what was so "off" about it, and maybe my nose is unsophisticated, but it quite simply smells like lemon wafers...and it smells good. Period.

I dunno guys, that's my take on it.

this might be my new favorite Sweet Tooth flanker! sweet lemon atop a graham cracker base. it smells exactly like the store-bought cookies with lemon glaze, less so lemon pie per se. very comforting but fleeting; it almost totally disappears on me after 3 or 4 hours. for this reason, I don't understand the increase in price ($34.99 USD vs. $29.99 USD for a 30mL bottle) - nothing seems to be improved or more potent, let alone different at all. regardless, it's something I'll continue to wear and enjoy, especially when I really want to smell edible and delicious.

Opens very strongly with candied lemon peel, very much a baked and sugared lemon so it's still citrus and bright but not that bright, and you can also very much smell the graham cracker, tonka bean, and vanilla base right away. I've smelled some lemon fragrances that smell like that artificial lemon cleaning supplies smell, there is absolutely none of that which I was delighted with.
As it begins to settle some of the brightness from the lemon fades first, and I could start picking up on the white floral notes, and at this point the graham base the the strongest. As it continues to wear the graham actually goes next, leaning you with a vanilla-marshmellow white floral. I sprayed it on before noon both yesterday and today, and both yesterday and now (5 pm) I can still smell it in the evening
For a citrus scent it's not super bright because of all the gourmand notes, but it still feels distinctly springy (although not summery), I'm very pleased with it, like 4/5