Is it redundant to get these fragrances if I have YSL y edp?

Hi everyone, Ive been into the fragrance game for a month or so and the only blue scent I have right now is YSl y edp. My question is, would you say that it would be redundant to get fragrances like Blue de chanel, dior savage, versace dylan blue if I already have Y edp?

It all comes down to personal preference. In my opinion Y Eau de Parfum can't really be compared to Bleu de Chanel Eau de Parfum as they're two completely different scents.