I'm new to Parfumo and need honest opinions. Is it Really redundant to own both Noir Extreme and the Parfum. People say it's redundant to own both Givenchy Gentleman EDP and the Reserve Prive but my nose can pick up a difference between them and use them on different occasions. I love Noir Extreme and with the addition of leather added to the Parfum it looks like something I'd love to.
The only opinion that matters is yours. If you feel they smell different, go for it.
I personnally own different versions or concentration of some "same" perfumes (Coco and n°5 for example) and it's ok, they're different.
HI and welcome 🙂 if you like the differences, and both are within your budget, why not? As an example, Room 1015's Cherry Punk also has an Extrait, and the two are noticeably different as is the silage/longevity.
The only opinion that matters is yours. If you feel they smell different, go for it.
I personnally own different versions or concentration of some "same" perfumes (Coco and n°5 for example) and it's ok, they're different.
Totally agree! I think I will one day have several concentrations of Habit Rouge.
And wow an extrait of 
Cherry Punk Eau de Parfum 🤩
If your nose and wallet are ok, go for it ! (Sampling first is always a good idea by the way, a great way to find an agreement between Nose&Wallet)
