Carlisle or Oajan?

I'm torn between these two popular PDM fragrances.
Carlisle Parfums de Marly
Oajan Parfums de Marly
I've read and been told that both smell or have an apple pie vibe but which is more dark and seductive? Like if Christian Bale's Bruce Wayne wore one of these two which he wear? 

Bruce Wayne would wear Oajan, Batman would wear Carlisle

They are both quite different.

Oajan is very sweet, with apple and cinnamon. It's a more casual, fun, but still seductive scent profile.

Carlisle can be harsh and challenging, especially in the opening, but it dries down into pure class. Carlisle is much more serious and dark, while still maintaining a golden sweetness.