...The best imo that's not a clone would be neroli oranger by matiere premier.

...Masculine Leaning RoseI would go with these five options ranked from top to bottom, which I feel are the most masculine:1 The Moon2 Promise3 Tabac Rose4 Garanat5 Lyric ManPortrait of a lady, Rose D'Arabie and Les Sables Roses are unisex, with the last one slightly leaning femme to me.Of the abovementioned options, I would not go for Aramis Rose Calligraphy and Lyric Woman. Both are powdery roses that strongly lean towards feminine tastes.

...Tabac Rose and Velvet Tonka by BDKLayton, Pegasus, Layton Exclsuif, Oajan and Carlisle by Parfums de MarlyThe moon and promise by Frederic MallePure Bloom by St Dupont (leans fem)Perfect Tobacco St Dupont1899 by Histoires de ParfumsRemember Me by JovoyTyl and Kirke by Tiziana TerenziOverture by AmouageOud Bouquet by LancomeSorriso by Profumum RomaMajalis by Spirit of Dubai (Expensive)Flamenco and Ole by Ramon MonegalPardon by NasomattoStercus by Orto ParisiOnyx by Aaron Terence HughesShalimar by GuerlainI think testing those should be helpful enough to find something suitable. Tabac Rose and Promise I think are good options because they perform really well. I got Tabac Rose for around $100 USD a BNIB tester bottle. So if you shop around obviously you can get most of these below retail or maybe partial bottles.