John Galliano John Galliano 2010 Eau de Toilette

I have rarely experienced two fragrances with the same name that should only differ in concentration being perceived so differently. The "dark" Galliano (EdP) is one of my few rose fragrances, as it is so mystically rosy that I find it quite appealing. The EdT version, which is the focus here, is completely different. The mystical quality is entirely absent, patchouli and incense are undetectable; it is simply another creamy-soapy rose scent. Hardly sweet, not as expected, pleasantly soft, and a bit powdery, but rather unremarkable compared to the EdP. At times, I sense a resemblance to various other rose fragrances; the flankers from Paris (YSL) come quite close, as does the rose scent from Villoresi, but that one is significantly more boisterous in its rose character, while JG is rather delicate and reserved. The longer it lingers on the skin, the silkier it becomes, and that is quite lovely again. For romantic rose lovers.