Log in

Create Account Forgot your Password?
Shiyaaka for Men / Shiyaaka Silver by Khadlaj

Shiyaaka for Men
Shiyaaka Silver
2019

LeSmelleur
01/24/2025 - 03:15 PM
6
Less helpful Review
7Scent

8.3 - is this a joke?

I find this heavy-handed, as Arabian perfumes often are. It's too oily, and the performance is weak. The current rating of 8.3 is ridiculous, if you compare it with very good perfumes like Armani AdG Profumo and Diore Homme Cologne, both at 8.2. If you want something cheap and decent, this is OK, but let's be honest, it's mid-tier at best.
3 Comments
SilisomSilisom 5 months ago
Yikes... the type of person who takes review scores too seriously. They're subjective. 8+ ratings just mean a lot of people like the fragrance and some people don't. So maybe try leaving helpful reviews about what they smell like, instead of worrying about what everyone else thinks or how they stack up to other completely unrelated fragrances.
sll322sll322 1 year ago
1
Are you seriously comparing this to Armani and Dior (please spell it correctly.) The 8.3 seems about right to me, but comparing it to those designer fragrances is like comparing a grapefruit to a Buick. They're not at all comparable.
VmasterVmaster 1 year ago
Or comparing a Jaguar to a Range Rover.