Log in

Meggi
10/18/2016 - 01:37 PM
16
Top Review
8Scent 8Longevity 8Sillage 7Bottle

Pea Soup Instead of Oud

Oudh Noir is available as EdT and EdP. The fact that my sample reveals nothing but the name might be due to the fact that only the concentration varies. In the Angela Flanders shop on Columbia Road in London, the friendly salesperson also gave me no hint of deeper differences, and the information online points in the same direction. So let’s assume we are dealing with identical ingredients. Judging by its behavior, I suspect my sample is the EdT.

Oud is only mentioned for the top note. Aha...? It seems to me that it’s more of an idea than anything else. This might be intentional, as the accompanying text states that Oud “haunts the top notes...”. Is it perhaps haunting a little less? A clear commitment to the use of Oud in the top note sounds different. It sounds more like the HSV board expressing confidence in the coach.

Oudh Noir undoubtedly contains a lot of woodiness, but I am waiting in vain for the other common Oud aspects. In return, I had the impression that there was briefly more than just the promised “hint of tobacco” upfront. This is quickly brushed aside by - pea soup. Along with something fresh but bitter. Juniper fits. The tree has just been freshly cut here. After ten minutes, the ethereal notes have largely faded, but the aroma lingers significantly longer.

Regarding pea soup: This likely has to do with violets from the throat lozenge-leather corner. I remember Hystera by Gabriele Chieffo, which had a similar edible twist. The leather aspect would even fit, as it is explicitly mentioned by the manufacturer. Juniper may also be involved, possibly with the associative chain “juniper - bacon - pea soup”. While I’m at it: lovage? It smells a bit like Maggi. Hmm, “A desert camp at night…” is written. Well, there’s no cowboy-style bean stew, but rather pea soup.

A pot of hearty pea soup with bacon and spices bubbles lazily over a fire made of spicy wood. Fire? Campfire! My favorite colleague dryly remarked: “The forest is burning...”.

Soon I find myself in a skillfully mild-sweetened... Yes, what? It’s hard to categorize “Oudh” Noir. For a long time, I wait for the pea soup on wood smoke to take the path towards Interlude Man Opoponax (as it does in Hystera), but the shift doesn’t happen. Instead, it just becomes a bit milder, sweeter, and woodier. Only around midday can I shake off the thought of pea soup.

Gradually, the scent darkens, becoming bitter-resinous-dark-woody and somewhat tarry in the sixth and seventh hour. The sweetness has receded. However, it returns in a - well, I’m not exactly sure - amber-vanilla-labdanum-creamy-dark-wood-concentrate-soft-smoky second base around the eighth or ninth hour.

Conclusion: Somewhat Noir (at least over long stretches), just without Oud. I quite like it; others may call it unbalanced. Those who find Interlude Man fundamentally interesting but too strenuous might want to try this candidate. Unfortunately, it is very hard to come by. Off to London!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
13 Comments
PaloneraPalonera 9 years ago
Oh dear, pea soup again. You could practically chase me away with it. And whenever Maggi is mentioned in the context of a fragrance, I always think something's off. But I guess it's supposed to be like that this time, right?!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PlutoPluto 9 years ago
Tasty, such a pea soup, but in the scent?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
JumiJumi 9 years ago
The appetizer and dessert already appeal to me. If it weren't for the main course...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MisterEMisterE 9 years ago
Only water and soap can help. I'm curious to see when the first sprayable Wiener Schnitzel will come out...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MokkaMokka 9 years ago
3. Test. It’s been resting on my wrist for an hour now. Not pea soup, but gentle smoke. I’m staying on the ball... uh, on the scent! By the way, it’s amazing how different perceptions can be. Tests in the morning are vastly different from those in the afternoon/evening.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 9 years ago
Hmm, do you really want to smell like pea soup? *doubtful*
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GelisGelis 9 years ago
That sounds pretty awful to me :(. Pea soup trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeejungfrauSeejungfrau 9 years ago
Hi there, nicely written!
What does pea soup have in common with violet throat lozenges? Okay, I'll ignore that :-))
I can relate more to Interlude in its gentle form :-))
Boccanera was also compared to pea soup today... it's the day of stews! Well, I had potato soup instead ;-)))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CravacheCravache 9 years ago
Well, that sounds kind of interesting - and: I have to support Werder :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 9 years ago
Funny review: You 8.0 - Taake 2.0: Since I value both of your opinions: What do I do now???
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 9 years ago
I just had bean soup today (see statement on Parco Palladiano V).
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TaurusTaurus 9 years ago
Another one to spoon... ;-)
But the one with the HSV board was good :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Sweetsmell75Sweetsmell75 9 years ago
I'll take over from the 9th hour then ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation