I honestly do not understand how people like this scent. To me, it does not smell like marshmallow at all. To my nose, this smells like smoke and that is all I get from it. Maybe I had a faulty bottle? I'm not sure. I'm most likely in the minority on the opinion of it smelly smoky.
This review is mostly going from memory, but I do remember how much I hated this fragrance. If they ever were to rerelease it, I would give it another try to see if it was my bottle that was faulty, or if it's my nose.