A learning experience, but one I wish I hadn't had
There are some notes in perfumery that, due to sharing molecules with others, are prone to unflattering associations. Lilies and jasmines, for example, draw fecal comparisons, while oud reminds many people of manure. Blackcurrant absolute has an unfortunate tendency to smell like 'cat pee', and I don't think I ever fully understood that comparison until I sprayed Anais Anais.
If I try very hard to think of lily of the valley and 90s-style white floral soap, I can just about wrench my mind away from the thought. And indeed, as the scent dries down, it feels less astringent, more floral— and then I catch an edge of greenery and my mind goes back to it. I think I even understand now why people dislike my beloved jasmine, because in this context it's wholly unappealing. The whole design and marketing campaign of this fragrance is, I believe, meant to put one in mind of a porcelain bathtub filled with attractive young ladies. Unfortunately, it reminds me of a significantly less enticing bathroom fixture.
Perhaps the original version (the real original, not 'L'Original' orignal) of this was better, perhaps this was a victim of reformulation. I don't know, but I don't like it.
At first, your review made me smile, because I also don't like heavy blackcurrant (even though it's used in some really great perfumes). Then your comment about the bathroom fixture. LOL that made my day.
Is it selfish of me to say I'm kind of glad you had this experience? Because if you hadn't, you couldn't have written this hilarious review! 🫠
@Ezroni I powered through this one! I feel bound to experience the full wear at least twice of anything I'm writing a review on. So this was my second time and I was prepared at least lol.
Aww, thank you! I really appreciate that, because I always feel a bit bad when I dislike something everyone else does. Like, I swear I'm not just trying to be a contrarian, and I always try to see what other people like about it... but at the end of the day, we smell what we smell lol
And I like that you're never afraid to admit disliking a popular fragrance like Cool Water (or vice versa), even if a lot of others feel the opposite. Kind of like an "I'm not here to make friends, my nose is!" attitude. 😂🙂
(sorry, resent this due to typo)
Lol no it's not selfish! I'm glad it made you laugh, makes the experience worth it if it can be funny!
I'm also honestly kind of glad like... at least now I understand what people mean when they talk about these things! (And I always kind of appreciate when I dislike a fragrance, weirdly enough. It's like a reminder that "oh, I DO have opinions and don't just blindly enjoy everything I try")
Is it selfish of me to say I'm kind of glad you had this experience? Because if you hadn't, you couldn't have written this hilarious review! 🫠
(sorry, resent this due to typo)
I'm also honestly kind of glad like... at least now I understand what people mean when they talk about these things! (And I always kind of appreciate when I dislike a fragrance, weirdly enough. It's like a reminder that "oh, I DO have opinions and don't just blindly enjoy everything I try")