Misia (Eau de Toilette) by Chanel

Misia 2015 Eau de Toilette

ParfumAholic
03/20/2015 - 07:03 AM
40
Top Review
7Scent 5Longevity 2.5Sillage 10Bottle 8Pricing

The Magic of a Moment or the Brief 100%-Moment

Shortly after registering here at Parfumo, I became aware of the “Les Exclusif - Fragrances” from the house of Chanel. Many tests and numerous moments of confusion followed before the proverbial knot was eventually untied.

Since then, “Coromandel” has definitely become one of my absolute favorite fragrances. With other representatives from the series (“28 La Pausa”, “Bois des Îles”, “Eau de Cologne”, “Sycomore”), I have something like on-off relationships, as I generally like them quite a bit, but they still don’t warrant full bottles.

What they all have in common, in my view, is an extraordinarily high quality, a very distinct recognizability, and the wonderful bottles with the great magnetic closures. In terms of price, they are still in the affordable range compared to other Chanel products (and in comparison to the competitor Dior).

In this regard, the announcement of the new fragrance “Misia” [named after Misia Sert, who was known in the first half of the 20th century as a muse, friend, and patron of numerous artists in Paris (Source: Wikipedia)] naturally made me extremely curious.

Needless to say, the sample didn’t have to wait long to be put to use ;-)

Right after spraying, I perceive one of the most beautiful top notes I have ever encountered: iris and the powdery notes. A truly dreamy duo that instantly transports me to the wardrobe of an old revue theater. The room is dark and only illuminated by the lamps at the makeup tables and mirrors. The revue dancers sit in front of them, preparing for the show. It smells very distinctly of lipstick and makeup. The powder puffs are tirelessly at work, distributing their fine powder with that typical scent throughout the room. And yet, the smell is not dry-dusty, but rather pleasantly “moist” dusty. The olfactory impression is very hard to put into words; anyone who tests the fragrance will understand what I mean.

This moment is, for me, the magical 100%-moment, because just as “Misia” is now, it would be worth the highest rating to me, and I would immediately run out to get a large bottle.

And of course, this grand opening now awakens great hope and expectation in me that there must be an enhancement, as the fragrance is still at the very beginning of its development.

But hardly have these thoughts crossed my mind when this magic simply disappears. Gone. Without a word. Without explanation. Just gone.

I have the impression that the scented skin area smells of nothing anymore. But that can't be, mustn't be, or can it?

Then, rather unexpectedly, “Misia” timidly and quietly returns. A very close mix of violet, benzoin, and tonka bean begins to support or even carry the remnants of the top notes.
But that seems to be a hopeless endeavor. The show has been canceled, and the dancers have long since removed their makeup. At best, a hint of “iris powder” lingers in the air.

Please don’t misunderstand; the base is not bad despite everything, but I am probably just getting in my own way with my expectations, fueled by these gigantic top notes, to appreciate and value it accordingly.

However, even the next attempts leave me with this one realization: “Misia” is a fragrance whose top notes are worth 100% to me, whereas I struggle significantly with the rest of the fragrance development.

“Misia” is certainly an elegant fragrance, feminine in the positive sense (still wearable by men), which starts grandly and promisingly but then falls significantly short of its potential.
I have the impression that a lot of thought was put into the top notes, but the work was then somewhat carelessly completed or the famous red thread was lost. What a pity.

I also find the longevity personally too short. After a generous 4 hours, “Misia” has completely vanished on me. And I expect much more from a Les Exclusif fragrance.

What remains? The realization that light (top notes) and shadow (the rest of “Misia”) are closely intertwined at Chanel, and unfortunately, “Misia” will not find a place in my fragrance cabinet.

Pardon!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
18 Comments
MandelmausMandelmaus 11 years ago
1
Wonderfully described and fair, understandable arguments. Sounds interesting :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KatnissKatniss 11 years ago
1
I missed your comment... but luckily I found it... Your description is fantastic... and now I have to test it ASAP... For fragrances that don't last long, I wear a scarf made of 100% cotton. That way, the scent lasts forever.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IngerInger 11 years ago
I'm eagerly waiting for my sample now!!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0815abc0815abc 11 years ago
Hey, Moulin Rouge just popped up in front of me. Would that be something for you?
Nice comment, and yes, the drift into a skin-close ordinariness is what characterizes this line. And at that price... well! Powder trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CallasCallas 11 years ago
However, it lasts longer on me too ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CallasCallas 11 years ago
That's exactly how I felt too. Applause at the beginning on stage, and then the curtain falls.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
OrmeliOrmeli 11 years ago
Such a shame, it started off so promising... Great review! :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PlutoPluto 11 years ago
What a shame. I expected more from the "new" one in this line, as I really appreciate Jersey, Beige, and 1932-they're lovely scents.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
LilauLilau 11 years ago
There's no room for Misia in my fragrance cabinet either, even though the longevity was good for me. ;-) And I have to agree with Part-Time God, Dior Homme is better...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GaukeleyaGaukeleya 11 years ago
1
The beginning feels almost like John Galliano, which gave me similar associations, and in the end, I was left with 70% of a decant ^^ Don’t be sad, you saved some money this way *comforting* :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DobbsDobbs 11 years ago
The scent wouldn't be for me because of the powdery makeup opening, but I can totally understand your disappointment. A dreamy top note and then a rather lackluster finish - what a shame!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PaloneraPalonera 11 years ago
1
Seems like it's all in the head - but you and Chypienne still pushed it way up my wishlist, the scent, :-).
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TivellonTivellon 11 years ago
Did I just smell the fragrance on my skin or "only" read a (your!) comment?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 11 years ago
Definitely not a scent for me, but some of the fragrances from the line are truly among the greats.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KleopatraKleopatra 11 years ago
1
In your description of the top note, I drooled a bit at first, but I've managed to dry off now... ;) Thanks for the informative comment, you definitely deserve a consolation prize. At least you saved some money!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MoniEMoniE 11 years ago
described....! As always, great comment, it speaks to my soul!!! LightAndShadowTrophy!!!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MoniEMoniE 11 years ago
Yep, I felt the same way about Misia - the scent left me a bit puzzled. The opening was great, but then it unfortunately went downhill. I recently read a biography of Coco Chanel, where Misia Sert is described as a very ambivalent person.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChypienneChypienne 11 years ago
1
Ah, I’m so glad to see your comment! :-) Yes, you describe the lovely top note beautifully. I’m lucky that Misia lasts longer on me and ends with a particularly enchanting violet-iris finale. A little comfort bottle for you.
Translated · Show originalShow translation