Synthetic Nature / Synthetic Jungle by Editions de Parfums Frédéric Malle

Synthetic Nature
Synthetic Jungle
2021

Gold
06/08/2022 - 08:58 AM
52
Top Review
8.5Scent 10Longevity 10Sillage 4Bottle 3Pricing

A genuinely honest, green edition perfume!

"Interesting perfumery really started at the end of the 19th century, because there were some synthetics available. Perfumery as we know it today has big doses of synthetic, and furthermore, if you want to recreate nature, you need synthetic.
I love nature, it really needs to be preserved, don't get me wrong, but this idea that everything from nature is great and everything from man is awful is a kind of new fascism."
Frédéric Malle, Interview with The Perfume Society, 14.10.2021

"Synthetic Jungle" is a genuinely honest perfume - it does not pretend that no aroma chemicals were used to create it in all its beauty and freshness.

Who doesn't know this... almost every perfume sales associate recites the little mantra:
"Here are almost (!!!) only natural substances in it, that's why the scent is much higher quality, of course, it has its price."
A promotional flyer is pulled out and the customer sees the sacred pyramid before her:
"Lemon from Sicily, mandarin from Corsica, sandalwood from India, lily of the valley from Georgia..." - everything supposedly soooo natural and very expensive.
Almost none of these advertising claims are true.
Anyone who REALLY wants something 100% natural must look into the alternative sector, which occupies a very broad space here on Parfumo, as more and more users are testing and really enjoying these "artisanal scents". (Good for them!!!) These are real niche products from non-industrial production that have nothing to do with the mainstream we encounter at Douglas, etc.
What I find cool and brave about Malle is the fact that he does not promote his expensive edition scents with the trendy natural narrative, but clearly admits that modern, industrially produced perfumes cannot do without the often negatively portrayed synthetics. Even "Jicky" contained the artificial vanillin that made Guerlain seem so innovative at the time. It really depends on HOW synthetics are used and what effect is to be achieved.
"Synthetic Jungle" starts with a huge dose of galbanum "in your face".
I love this material and suspect that it was collected somewhere in the Alborz Mountains near Karaj in Iran. But perhaps the chemistry experts among us know more about galbanum here... can it be synthetically replicated?
After the galbanum blast, a sweeter accord of jasmine and lily of the valley immediately sets in, playing with all facets of the two materials: green-fresh, wet, green-dark-steamy, jasmine-animalic, white-radiant, white-clean-synthetic.
In terms of impression, the scent now reminds me of classic models like "Alliage".
After a while, a slight patchouli note joins in, grounding the scent beautifully and making it an unpretentious companion for hours.
No fluff, no sweetness, no unnecessary ballast. A very clear formula, a path through the jungle of modern perfumery, which personally does not excite me as much as it did 15, 20 years ago... -
No, this is not a "everything was better in the past" lament, but rather a hymn to Anne Flipo and Monsieur Malle, who dared to compose and market a consistently green, fresh scent without caring about current trends.
This is how I envision a true "edition scent" - and that's why it ticks "all the right boxes" for me.
Perhaps "Synthetic Jungle" will appeal even more to perfume lovers
- I wish it that!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
39 Comments
MairuwaMairuwa 6 months ago
1
It's great that someone is standing up for good synthetics, which don't always have to be mainstream. I find Frédéric Malle fascinating anyway. I wasn't familiar with that quote, but it really hits the mark. And the fragrance description is well done too. Awesome!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 2 years ago
1
Very entertaining and informative. Great to see that there are still such brave and consistent people out there.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Greenfan1701Greenfan1701 2 years ago
1
Sounds very exciting, I’ve added it to my wishlist right away! 👍😉
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AxiomaticAxiomatic 3 years ago
2
The initial quote from Mr. Malle alone is worth diving deeper into the scent.
Galbanum in the opening, I'm hooked!
Thank you for this honest and splendid review!
🏆
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SetaSeta 3 years ago
1
Enlightening, very good comment! I do like green scents, but not with basil. Still, I definitely have to try it!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 3 years ago
3
That sounds appealing...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParmaParma 3 years ago
3
I really like it too. A very accurate review from you. I think it's great that Malle continues to operate as it does, even after being integrated into the Lauder group. For me, the scent also evokes slight Chypre associations due to its intensely green and bitter character.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PhilianphiloPhilianphilo 3 years ago
2
Finally, someone says it! (besides Malle itself) Great review. Thank you very much for that :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IrisNobileIrisNobile 3 years ago
2
…… You could really enrich the perfume section of a lifestyle magazine with your interesting, informative, and brilliantly written articles! :)) …. That was great to read again! - And now you've got me wanting to try it! 😉 Galbanum is also my thing - and I love that you know right away what to expect - same here.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ViolettViolett 4 years ago
2
I love to happily explore scents, whether synthetic, all-natural, or anything in between, just as I like it. There's so much worth smelling, like this fresh, green fragrance from Mallorca. :-))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 4 years ago
2
Nice comment, thanks! And what would all the classic fans, myself included, do if there was no 'evil' synthetic stuff - a lot would be irretrievably lost. I like the scent!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
2
Exactly! That's it. Without the scornfully made synthetics, there would be no Shalimar or Diorella, no Chanel No. 5 or Bandit. As commendable and eco-friendly as I find 100% natural fragrances, there's not a single one that excites me as much as the great classics.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BastianBastian 4 years ago
1
Great, informative, and authentically written review..
Even though it wasn't my scent, I really enjoyed reading your review...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777Can777 4 years ago
1
True to the saying, "honesty is the best policy!" I've been interested in this scent for a long time. Now, after your great review, I'm even more intrigued. Awesome!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MadameLegrasMadameLegras 4 years ago
1
A wonderful scent and a great comment! I also have a weakness for galbanum, and Synthetic Jungle has won me over too :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ToppineToppine 4 years ago
1
Very nice comment - I agree with you regarding the synthetic aspect. I'll test the fragrance soon.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchatzSucherSchatzSucher 4 years ago
1
I always have a bit of a love-hate relationship with Malle, even though I do like a good handful of their fragrances. When it comes to synthetics (which I often complain about), it really depends on how they're crafted. This scent should actually appeal to me, as I love a generous dose of galbanum. And your comment is, once again, a real pleasure.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MonsieurTestMonsieurTest 4 years ago
1
Yes, yes, and yes.
Sounds like a lovely scent.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
I can imagine you would really like it... it’s definitely your style.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
HasiHasi 4 years ago
1
Mmmhh, it has everything I like; the notes really appeal to me, but a scent from Mallorca has never managed to win my heart.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
This is one of the most beautiful Malles for me... it already has fantastic scents in the edition...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 4 years ago
1
A great comment on a scent that I find really nice.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PonticusPonticus 4 years ago
1
I wouldn't go for a consistently green, fresh scent since it doesn't match my fragrance preferences at all! However, I have a positive attitude towards synthetic or partially synthetic scents and would even prefer them over natural fragrances! So, I won't venture into the jungle, but I'm happy to go into the lab! Great review!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
LicoriceLicorice 4 years ago
1
I wholeheartedly agree with your wonderfully expressed thoughts and I'm excited to explore this fragrance. Off into the jungle! :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Medusa00Medusa00 4 years ago
1
Oh wow, now I'm really curious! I'm good with galbanum. But even in those fragrances that are marketed as so natural, there are chemical components as scent carriers; otherwise, the stuff wouldn't last.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
1
There are 100% natural fragrances out there. But most of the time, synthetic substances are needed for fixation... - for me, those things don't belong in the "organic/ecological" category, etc.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
RivegaucheRivegauche 4 years ago
1
At first, this "in the face" was a bit too loud for me, but now I really love it. The aura of the fragrance is definitely not cozy... just like most Malle scents. That's probably why I like the brand so much. It's very well done.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
1
I feel the same way. "Cozy" is pretty foreign to me... I just don't like those kinds of scents. That's why I find a lot of interesting options in Malle that suit my taste.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
JonasP1JonasP1 4 years ago
Very nice comment, and I completely agree with you! I admit that the name initially put me off a bit, but the part about Galbanum being "in your face" really catches my attention :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
1
The name is just the cool part about it. There's no denying that modern perfumery can't do without synthetics, unless it's strictly "organic," which I think is fair.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TurandotTurandot 4 years ago
1
I love Aliage and was looking forward to Synthetic Jungle. Unfortunately, the galbanum here is a bit too harsh for my nose. I completely agree with your thoughts on natural vs. synthetic. A good perfumer knows how to play all the notes of the fragrance keyboard.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
1
After 10 minutes, the galbanum is really nice... - I think... 😜
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 4 years ago
Oh yes, you hear that kind of talk about nature all the time. And then it smells like tons of Ambroxan 😉 I really like the Malle brand too.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
1
Nature sells better, after all... that's why I think the name "Synthetic Jungle" is really spot on...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchalkerinSchalkerin 4 years ago
Really well described. However, Aliage isn't really my thing. I'll still be happy to test it if I come across it.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FloydFloyd 4 years ago
1
Exceptionally good thoughts on nature and synthetics in the usual gold standard. I enjoyed reading it again!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GandixGandix 4 years ago
1
An excellent review. Nature and synthetic can wonderfully coexist, both within a fragrance and on their own. It's the variety that makes our passion so exciting. And sometimes, synthetic actually smells more natural, or rather more beautiful, than reality does.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
1
Thank you so much, dear Gabi. I see it the same way you do.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AndrulaAndrula 4 years ago
1
.. very interesting informative text .. I might also like the scent, and the concept behind it is appealing to me ..
Translated · Show originalShow translation