Musc Sicile by El Nabil

Musc Sicile

SchatzSucher
11/22/2020 - 06:14 AM
42
Top Review
5Scent 8Longevity 7Sillage 7Bottle

Copy in Oil

Recently, I received a rather extensive package with 16 perfume oils from El Nabil.
The brand was completely unknown to me until now. The name suggests a manufacturer of Arab origin.
However, after some research on the website and in the WWW, this does not seem to be the case. Here at Parfumo, it is stated that the company comes from France, but on their web presence, the headquarters is listed as Birmingham/UK.
Whether there are indeed Arab hands and noses behind it could not be determined.
El Nabil is very reserved with information and names.
They advertise with the motto "Luxury for Everyone." After reviewing the entire range, I could identify a wide variety of products, from perfumes and cosmetics to room fragrances, offering a fairly broad spectrum.
And all this at very moderate to cheap prices.

However, after extensive testing of the perfume oils, I found that El Nabil leans quite heavily on well-known and popular scents or even copies them.
This is, of course, nothing new. When a fragrance is successful and sells well, others are quick to jump on the bandwagon.

I was able to identify one or two fragrance twins and also found that they have indeed done a good job of copying.
The perfume oils smell, despite the really low prices, not cheap or inferior. And in some cases, they even last longer than the originals.

I got a bit stuck on Musc Sicile. I quickly found out that this is a well-made copy of the quite popular Black Opium Eau de Parfum.
I do not like Black Opium, and I do not like Musc Sicile either.

The opening of both fragrances is the same, fruity sweetness, followed by white flowers, vanilla, and at most a hint of spice. All of this is also very sugary sweet.
Coffee is supposed to be present as well, but I cannot find it. Even in Black Opium, there is not much coffee, rather it is more of a little coffee.
Not a big deal, I prefer to drink coffee rather than spray it on myself.

As the scent develops, Musc Sicile and Black Opium part ways.
In Musc Sicile, an additional quite pronounced musk note develops, which makes the already not-so-pleasant scent even less enjoyable for me. This musk note becomes unpleasantly dirty and grimy for me, somewhat greasy. Sugary sweetness and flowers do not help anymore.
I have nothing against musk in moderate doses, but here it has really been overdone.
Therefore, Black Opium received one more point than this scent.

In terms of longevity, El Nabil is superior to YSL. While Black Opium dissipates after just a few hours, Musc Sicile lasts a solid 9-10 hours. The oily base contributes to the longer longevity. Musc Sicile remains overall closer to the skin, which is a significant advantage for some fragrances.

I am not a fan of perfume oils; I find the consistency and the film on the skin bothersome. And I do not like this scent direction. However, I do not consider myself the target audience, even though I do not shy away from the women's department otherwise.
None of the oils will find their way to me, cheap price or not, even if some are really good.
But I find all of this very interesting for testing.
And I will not elaborate further on the topic of copying; much has already been said about that.

I would like to thank Mr. and Mrs. A. from B. for the testing opportunities!

And now I will make myself another coffee, a real one, hand-filtered, without sugary sweetness.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
39 Comments
Medusa00Medusa00 5 years ago
1
I have my issues with oils too, lol.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KovexKovex 5 years ago
I used to think that orientals were for me. But I was mistaken; the oils are definitely not my thing. I can probably skip this one too.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PlutoPluto 5 years ago
I think I can skip the test :o) and I'm definitely more of a sprayer than a dabber.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Camey5000Camey5000 5 years ago
These little bottles are packed with goodness. I love them. Most of them. Thanks for your comment. Very worth reading.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GelisGelis 5 years ago
I quite like coffee in fragrances, and I also enjoyed Black Opium. I even have it in my collection, but I haven't sprayed it in so long that it might be too sweet for me now. I'm not really into oils either; you have to be careful not to stain your clothes... Informative comment, I've heard of the brand before.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 5 years ago
Thanks, I got the message... this isn't for me... Black Opium and oil are a no-go. If I use oil, it’s only organic for the body and only in winter... :) But it was definitely an interesting testing experience, and you saved me from having to sniff it. I've seen these products online before and wondered what they smell like.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SiebenkäsSiebenkäs 5 years ago
Interesting report, which I really enjoyed reading! You truly have a great nose! I don't think these oils are quite my thing, but thanks anyway for breaking it down, and here's a bio coffee trophy for you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MariellaMmmhMariellaMmmh 5 years ago
Cheers. :) Thank you for the wonderful post.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GaukeleyaGaukeleya 5 years ago
1
I'm not a fan of oils either. And definitely not a fan of Black Opium. It's nice to not feel the urge to test something for a change ^^ Thanks for bravely testing and for the fair comment! Commenting on the "mediocre" ones is usually not that easy. *Sets down trophy filled with FairKaffee*
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Brelles530Brelles530 5 years ago
Well-crafted comment.
Very informative, thanks for that!
I'll definitely send a trophy up north ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GandixGandix 5 years ago
Nice informative comment. I've generally moved away from musk.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PonticusPonticus 5 years ago
You've touched on an interesting topic with the fragrance oils. There aren't many knowledgeable comments and opinions available on this yet. Personally, I'm not a big fan of these oils either and prefer to spray. I've also tried two perfume oils from El Nabil and completely agree with you on the scent. A clear and straightforward top-notch contribution!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FvSpeeFvSpee 5 years ago
Coffee? But only a little outside!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Medianus76Medianus76 5 years ago
I haven't had any experience with oils so far, so I can't share my own impressions. However, your descriptions are very informative and insightful regarding oils and the scent. Therefore, I think I'll steer clear of them...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SonnenwendeSonnenwende 5 years ago
I'm usually not opposed to sweet scents, but I found BLACK OPIUM painfully sugary. Your comparison to MUSC SICILE is very interesting. Enjoying your comment with a fresh filter coffee was a delight :-)).
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FioreMarinaFioreMarina 5 years ago
Straightforward and to the point, fair in tone and incredibly clear in substance. I’m happy to make a detour for that ;)
One small critique: Coffee should be brewed in a cafetière! Filter, brrr...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FloydFloyd 5 years ago
I really like oils: they get better over time, nourish the skin more than perfumes (they absorb into my skin in about a minute), and aren't as loud... I don't need to test Musc Sicile after your always excellent comment ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KleopatraKleopatra 5 years ago
With musk, I always get really sensitive. But musk with sugar just doesn’t work for me. And Black Opium doesn’t work for me either. So I’d rather come over for a coffee with you. No sugar, but please with lots of milk foam! ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AndrulaAndrula 5 years ago
I had to smile a few times while reading .. You write briefly and concisely, "I don't like it .... I don't think much of it"! I've only tried Black Opium and was glad when it finally faded away .. so this oil version isn't for me either .. (by the way, several fragrances from Profumum Roma are also a bit oily, but that doesn't bother me at all.) Thank you for the informative comment and the "I don't like it" point. That's clear :))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GschpusiGschpusi 5 years ago
I agree with Can an... oils... well, then it must be top quality!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777Can777 5 years ago
1
Basically, I have nothing against oils. But I have to admit, there are some truly dreadful ones out there. And those fruity-floral musk oils are the worst. That’s when I start to run!.. ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Melisse2Melisse2 5 years ago
1
When it comes to the dislike for Black Opium, we completely agree. You think it's not for men? I don't think it's for women either.
And definitely not with more musk. Unlike you, I'm really against that.
I generally prefer to stick with the originals. I might be a bit snobbish about that.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0815abc0815abc 5 years ago
I once had Musc Sultan from them and liked it for a little while. Sure, it's synthetic and affordable. But it's also enjoyable and cozy. Oils aren't really my cup of tea in the long run.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SalvaSalva 5 years ago
Very beautifully and detailed written! I totally agree with you, I don't necessarily need perfume oils either, for the reasons you mentioned. I've owned a few from various brands, but I quickly passed them on...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MadameLegrasMadameLegras 5 years ago
A lovely, insightful comment that I enjoyed reading! I'm out when it comes to Black Opium...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChizzaChizza 5 years ago
I'm out on the oil too, but nice comment! I'd love to join in on the coffee conversation ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParfumAholicParfumAholic 5 years ago
I'm generally not a fan of oils. I don't like that specific consistency, and I usually end up with the oil where I really don't want it (not to mention the stains on shirts). I find Black Opium to be just mediocre, so I definitely don't need a dupe of it. I do like musk, but not when it has a dirty or animalistic vibe. Thanks for your very informative comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 5 years ago
1
Oil belongs in the kitchen for me. I think I’ve tried something from that brand before. *Löschpapierdalass*
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DerDefconDerDefcon 5 years ago
Excellent writing. I also skip excessive fruity sweetness and weird coffee mishaps in fragrances. The Kilian brand has already shown me that things can go seriously wrong. But especially with fruits in scents, the line between beautiful, authentic, and horrifically synthetic is very, very thin.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ToppineToppine 5 years ago
1
It's great that you wrote such a nice and interesting comment about a fragrance you don't like; I really enjoyed reading it. Black Opium doesn't work for me at all, and I'm not into oils either. Let's both enjoy our coffee now...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
RenataRenata 5 years ago
This is another really nice, exciting, and very informative comment. I've never tried fragrance oils, but the oily consistency makes me hesitant. Black Opium isn't my thing either; I prefer a cup of hand-filtered coffee instead...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParmaParma 5 years ago
1
Super informative and fair as always. Thank you for introducing the brand!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 5 years ago
Wow, Black Opium isn't my thing either. I’m not a fan of oily textures. I'm glad that the new Profumum Romas are a bit less oily than the very first batches. They may not last 24 hours anymore (my Meringa lasts maybe 8-9 hours), but I think that's perfectly fine. This way, my clothes stay clean :)
As always, a well-researched comment from you.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MoniEMoniE 5 years ago
I also find oils tricky, as they can be greasy :-). However, I once had a sample of the wonderful "Tayyiba" by Amouage, and the texture didn't bother me at all since the oil absorbed quickly, yet I could still enjoy the lovely scent for hours. I love musk, but I will definitely steer clear of Musc Sicile. Coffee in fragrances doesn't appeal to me at all, and the rest doesn't sound good either. Thank you for this fine and nuanced comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 5 years ago
1
Either way, it's not really for me. I think I've had something from them before, and just the oil consistency put me off.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Fresh21Fresh21 5 years ago
I'll keep it short, my dear, and send you an oiled trophy for your efforts :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CravacheCravache 5 years ago
2
Interesting scent analysis. Unfortunately, Black Opium is the worst perfume I've ever tested - and this dupe doesn't seem much more appealing either. *shudder*
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeejungfrauSeejungfrau 5 years ago
I haven't had anything from El Nabil yet. I do like perfume oils, though. However, I really don't like Black Opium at all. We're on the same page there. Nothing beats hand-filtered coffee. Without sugar!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TaurusTaurus 5 years ago
1
In my opinion, they are often sold at flea markets as well. It's just not really my thing because of the consistency...
Translated · Show originalShow translation