August Erik Kormann 2008
21
Top Review
No Comfort
When August doesn't know what is appropriate for an August (a glance out the window showed this all too often), perhaps Mr. Kormann does. That's what I thought. The reading of the pyramid made me briefly doubt this (lily of the valley?), but whatever - let's go for it!
First impression: Fits. A somewhat bushy Petitgrain, with good greenery and even a few twigs included. The so-called mandarin has a distinct lemony, ungainly sting. But otherwise, the lady feels pleasantly fragrant - no surprise, the chemical environment suits her particularly well. And accordingly, she soon gives up the stubbornness of the beginning. It's all very fresh; I imagine that some other essential oils are helpfully swirling around. Yesss, a bit like Fanta, that's true. However, the Petitgrain adds a shrub-like spiciness that the real Fanta could only dream of. The floral heaviness of lily of the valley holds back quite a bit; without any announcement, I wouldn't have guessed it at all. No wonder - in August?
However, the progression dampens my mood more and more. During the morning, a hint of stale soda gradually creeps into my thoughts. Of course, it's still quite fresh for a while and outwardly impeccable - but unfortunately, from late morning onwards, a creaminess gradually substitutes in, which I find disturbing in this context. Initially, it primarily makes me think of sandalwood, then mainly of a rather straightforward musk that accompanies me well into the evening. Only directly on the skin does a light bitter-citrusy hint, like from citrus fruit peel, linger at least until the afternoon.
All of this feels too offensively chemical to me. Such things are simply made for other noses and therefore cannot comfort me over miserable pretend-summer weather.
Since it is not known whether my sample (many thanks to Gerdi!) is the older or the newer version of the fragrance, I am posting the comment where it has (illustrious and partly enthusiastic!) company; that seems fair to me considering my rather unenthusiastic rating.
First impression: Fits. A somewhat bushy Petitgrain, with good greenery and even a few twigs included. The so-called mandarin has a distinct lemony, ungainly sting. But otherwise, the lady feels pleasantly fragrant - no surprise, the chemical environment suits her particularly well. And accordingly, she soon gives up the stubbornness of the beginning. It's all very fresh; I imagine that some other essential oils are helpfully swirling around. Yesss, a bit like Fanta, that's true. However, the Petitgrain adds a shrub-like spiciness that the real Fanta could only dream of. The floral heaviness of lily of the valley holds back quite a bit; without any announcement, I wouldn't have guessed it at all. No wonder - in August?
However, the progression dampens my mood more and more. During the morning, a hint of stale soda gradually creeps into my thoughts. Of course, it's still quite fresh for a while and outwardly impeccable - but unfortunately, from late morning onwards, a creaminess gradually substitutes in, which I find disturbing in this context. Initially, it primarily makes me think of sandalwood, then mainly of a rather straightforward musk that accompanies me well into the evening. Only directly on the skin does a light bitter-citrusy hint, like from citrus fruit peel, linger at least until the afternoon.
All of this feels too offensively chemical to me. Such things are simply made for other noses and therefore cannot comfort me over miserable pretend-summer weather.
Since it is not known whether my sample (many thanks to Gerdi!) is the older or the newer version of the fragrance, I am posting the comment where it has (illustrious and partly enthusiastic!) company; that seems fair to me considering my rather unenthusiastic rating.
Translated · Show original
15 Comments
Fittleworth 5 years ago
I felt the same way. It doesn't smell fresh enough to me; there's some nasty little note that ruins the scent for me. Thanks for the very informative comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
First 8 years ago
If the musk bothers you already, how must it be for me? Thanks for the warning!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Palonera 8 years ago
Too bad. When I tested the scent, I found it very nice, but unfortunately, it didn't last long on me. Since Erik Kormann largely avoids preservatives and other stabilizers in his first fragrances, it's possible that you got an older sample that's not in the best condition anymore.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Pluto 8 years ago
I found it a bit dull and not very fresh either. So, for August and such... :o)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Kleopatra 8 years ago
This summer is already over anyway. Maybe I'll give it a try next year...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Holly66 8 years ago
Exactly, it's a bit stale, not as fresh and zesty as I expected-I would have given it a 7...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
RobGordon 8 years ago
I'm just thinking about how many times Fanta has been reformulated. It used to be drinkable! :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MisterE 8 years ago
What all comes out of the lab...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Jumi 8 years ago
Fanta... I don't even need it as a drink... let alone as a scent. I found our August to be extremely successful :) Comfort trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Yatagan 8 years ago
Cup!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Gerdi 8 years ago
Unfortunately, it's true about the stale Fanta! Maybe it's too old, or maybe it's just not a good scent? Oh, I really like Mr. Kormann's blog, so I would have preferred to give a positive review... but it just didn't work out!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Gelis 8 years ago
Doesn't sound convincing at all. I've been comforting myself with "Mandarine Basilic" by Guerlain these past few days, and that's working pretty well. Comfort trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Ergoproxy 8 years ago
You're quite strict, aren't you? :))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Cravache 8 years ago
Strange scent. But December fits really well in August :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Taurus 8 years ago
August isn't what it used to be anymore...
Translated · Show originalShow translation

