Profumo
03/15/2023 - 09:03 AM
36
Top Review
10Scent 8Longevity

A Octopus Slurps Cocoa

Antoine Lie is not one of my favorite perfumers, but what he has created with his ambregris triptych, “Mxxx.”, “Escale en Indonésie”, and “Ambre Suprême” - hats off!

We owe the experience of one of the most legendary and myth-laden fragrance materials in an unprecedented intensity and glory to his acquaintance with Rémi Pulvérail, founder and owner of “L’Atelier Français Des Matières”. His company develops tinctures of the highest purity and quality using special processes, aiming to set a counterpoint against the ever-advancing leveling of the market through increasingly interchangeable ingredients.
Pulvérail's wife, Valérie, is the founder and owner of the much-acclaimed label “Les Indémodables”, whose fragrances wonderfully illustrate the benefits of having experienced perfumers access truly top-notch ingredients. In addition, these works naturally serve - a classic win-win situation - as perfect advertising vehicles for her husband's company.

Rémi Pulvérail now has a special ambregris tincture in the catalog that convinced Antoine Lie due to its balance of creaminess, saltiness, and animalic character. But he did not only choose this for “Mxxx.” from AFDM's portfolio, as Barbara Herman from Eris Parfums reports, but also a particularly rich, spicy, almost animalic cocoa from Trinidad, which has never been used in perfumery before, as well as a special “green” vanilla from Madagascar, which only achieves its extraordinary qualities through elaborate freezing and extraction techniques.

All of this flowed into the formula of “Mxxx.”, and I find you can smell it: a quantum leap compared to the already quite successful predecessor scent “Mx.”!
Do the two additional “x” stand for that?
No idea. “Mx.” wants to be the gender-neutral variant of “Mr.” and “Ms.”, as the scent understands itself - rightly so; without me wanting to delve further into the difference between “unisex” and “gender-neutral”, which would exceed the scope here.

“Mxxx.” starts spicy, dry, and with a slight sharpness. At the same time, the cocoa notes begin to bloom, almost without sweetness in tow, but rather unfolding a whole kaleidoscope of rather bitter, buttery, almost nutty aromas, flanked by bright, polished wood. After just a few minutes, however, the real player of this fragrance begins to stretch its tentacles in all directions like a many-armed octopus: the amber.

We all know well enough its synthetic, indispensable substitute from modern perfumery, which ultimately can only represent a fraction of the scent profile of the natural starting product.
Here, however, it unfolds in full regalia, multifaceted, amorphous, and hard to grasp: salty, smelling of warm, pulsating skin, the vastness of the ocean, old books, driftwood, slightly mineral, intoxicatingly animalic, and, and, and...
Hardly any fragrance component boasts (and confuses!) with such a diffuse profile, but the main task of amber was, in the past, when it was still abundantly available due to industrial whaling, rather different: it served to make a fragrance radiate, to widen, to intensify. It was allowed to act in the background, as a puppeteer offstage, so to speak. The same fragrance concept once with, once without amber, and all test subjects reliably choose the version with amber - so perfumers report from their work.
Fortunately, the protection of sperm whales came just in time before the last slaughtered specimens could have their amber directly extracted. From then on, one had to rely on searching beaches worldwide for oxidized whale vomit (or however the sperm whale excretes the indigestible remains of its food - no one knows for sure...) or to resort to a synthetically developed substitute that is whale-friendly, the so-called ambrein, which could already be isolated from natural amber in the 1950s and with whose help the ambroxan (along with countless successors) was later developed, which is now used as if there were no tomorrow.

But here, dear friends of olfaction, true gray amber is at play - real!
And you can smell it.

The image of the octopus fits perfectly for me with the effect of amber: with its tentacles, it encompasses all other fragrance components, draws them in, holds them close, but at the same time, like a chameleon, adopts their coloration. It does not overshadow everything; it has a much too unclear scent contour for that, but it permeates everything, lets it emulsify, shine, and only upon closer sniffing do you catch a glimpse of its outlines: the saltiness reveals it, the faint animalic hint that Antoine Lie extends into the base with a subtle pinch of hyrax, the hint of oceanic minerality, the warmth.

The much-praised predecessor scent “Mx.” was based on a comparable concept: a woody-spicy semi-gourmand, to which Venezuelan cocoa and leathery-animalic castoreum gave its special character. Although the term “semi-gourmand” is not entirely accurate, as both fragrances only brush the gourmand terrain with their respective cocoa nuances. These nuances are so bitter and herbaceous that they require a balsamic addition like benzoin to give the fragrances a certain roundness towards the base, which is completed in both cases with pronounced patchouli and a hint less prominent vetiver.

THE distinguishing feature between the two fragrances is, however, the use of amber, especially in such intensity (7% in the perfume oil content, which is a lot!). It transforms the already extremely sensual “Mx.” into a true sensuality bomb, whose heightened sensuality might be too much for some over time. But then again, the version without amber is ready.
For my part, I like “Mx.”. But I am truly excited about “Mxxx.”.

With its opulence and amber bliss, the fragrance almost has something of a vintage extrait, which speaks of long-gone golden times when fragrant ingredients were not yet scrutinized for consumer protection purposes and ethical questions regarding their extraction were disregarded.
Fortunately, such times are past!
But the fact that we can shamelessly sniff real gray amber with Antoine Lie's ambregris triptych (interestingly, it smells most intense in “Escale en Indonésie”, although only 5% is used, in an otherwise quite sparse environment) almost conveys a certain decadence to me, which today, due to all the balance and awareness, almost gives me a slight guilty conscience.
A very slight one.
No, actually none at all.

Translated · Show originalShow translation
32 Comments
FloydFloyd 3 years ago
Very interesting to read your take on this, informative as always. I perceived it quite differently. But that’s what makes this world so exciting.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
NuiWhakakoreNuiWhakakore 3 years ago
Octopuses are really intelligent creatures, and there's a great analogy here with the scent, which sounds really strong, even though I usually have issues with half, quarter, or even tenth gourmands. Still definitely worth a try.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
I don't find it that gourmand anyway. For me, it leans more towards oriental/animalic...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IntersportIntersport 3 years ago
Great review of a fragrance that seems to deserve nothing less. Hats off! Lie seems to have reinvented itself after its experimental-pop years. Ambergris, vanilla, and cocoa of the highest quality make me think of the moment years ago when 'Gran Crus' entered the chocolatier scene and how widespread that term has become since. I'm curious to see where this leads, this kind of specialization and focus on provenance as a trend alongside the 'Captives' of the big fragrance manufacturers?!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
In line with the chocolate Grand Crus, Les Indémodables offers a selection of fragrances with the same names, naturally made by AFDM. Givaudan & Co definitely need to create a bit more buzz around their 'captive scents'...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AxiomaticAxiomatic 3 years ago
This is not a successful review, no, for me it's the private seminar of my dreams de luxe!!!
Hats off, brilliantly told and educationally described!
I can already sense that I will love the scent even more after reading it.
Ambra-Pokal
🏆
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
Oh, thanks for the trophy! I'll gladly pass it on to Monsieur Lie, he really deserves it ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MonsieurTestMonsieurTest 3 years ago
That sounds like pure olfactory bliss captured in a bottle :-)). Your comment radiates with unexpected percentages of information and enthusiasm.
Thanks for your presentation of the fragrance and the fabulous contributors!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
"Bliss captured in a bottle" - what a lovely image!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 3 years ago
That sounds extremely tempting again...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
Oh yes, I find it very appealing. But I think I'm quite the amber maniac...🤪
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KovexKovex 3 years ago
No one triggers blind-buy impulses in me like you do. Wow, now I'm curious! Great description!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
Oh, please no, no blind buys!
Doubt my words and trust your nose instead! Some see something blue that still looks green to me...😉
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 3 years ago
Oh, that sounds very vintage. Personally, it's definitely a bit too much of the animal notes for me, but I would love to sniff a fragrance like that.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
M3000M3000 3 years ago
I have to disagree: Not vintage at all! Ambre Suprême yes, but the two Mx(xx) not, I think too.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
Oh, the little creatures are actually quite well-behaved. Nothing compared to hyraxes and the like.
Ma Bête, from the same line, is a whole different ballgame...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777Can777 3 years ago
My compliments…great presentation! I would love it. That’s for sure..!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
1
Thanks! You really have to be okay with amber, and then also combined with cocoa, which is a bit daring, but in my opinion, it works wonderfully...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SebastianMSebastianM 3 years ago
Vibrant and informative! Thank you for this review. I've always wanted to try Mxxx, but the fact that it contains cocoa and vanilla has held me back from looking for a sample. After this discussion, I can definitely put my concerns to rest. (By the way, I know Ambre Supreme, and I was also thrilled with that one.)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
1
I'm not really into cocoa and vanilla, but combined with the salty amber, mmmh....
It's a bit like dark chocolate with Fleur de Sel - I like it, probably due to my age, much more than the good old milk chocolate now...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
M3000M3000 3 years ago
A wonderful scent meets a fantastic reviewer. It doesn't get better than this. Or??
Thanks!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
You're welcome.... 😊🙏
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BertelBertel 3 years ago
Incredible, this wealth of information, insight, and expertise combined with wonderfully relatable personal impressions and assessments - masterful, thank you!
I just pulled out my two samples of Mx. and Mxxx. again, and now I really have to get one of them ;-) Plus, I definitely want to get to know Eris, L’Atelier Français Des Matières, and Les Indémodables better!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
Well, I don't like everything from Eris. My favorites are Mxxx & Mx, with some reservations for Ma Bête, Green Spell, and Scorpio Rising. However, Les Indémodables is almost universally convincing, and many of them even more than that!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FriesinFriesin 3 years ago
1
What an interesting and delightful review. I had to wipe the drool from the corner of my mouth for a moment...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
Oh, let me hand you a virtual napkin...😉
Translated · Show originalShow translation
UntermWertUntermWert 3 years ago
I need to dive deeper into this. A wonderful scent that unfortunately didn’t last on me at all… but I haven’t given up on it just yet…
Translated · Show originalShow translation
UntermWertUntermWert 3 years ago
Unfortunately, it fades away after a few hours for me. Even though I really like that it has a strong animalic note yet smells very close and personal. It's just beautiful.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
The longevity is actually quite good for me, definitely sufficient.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
UntermWertUntermWert 3 years ago
Thank you very much for this insightful review!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 3 years ago
1
With this comment, you've truly outdone yourself! There's not a facet missing.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
..............thank you 🙏
Translated · Show originalShow translation