34
Top Review
Could I Grow Such Trees!
In Tolkien's "The Lord of the Rings," the Hobbits encounter a group of Elves in their homeland of the Shire, where they are cared for and treated to a delightful evening. The Hobbit Samwise Gamgee remarks about the fruit served: "Yes, sir, if I could grow such apples, I would call myself a gardener." Now, good Sam is undoubtedly a gardener by profession, so it should be clear what he means. Similarly, he might say today: "If I could grow trees that smell like this, I would open a nursery."
However, 'Between Two Trees' - and this starts with the expectations based on the (meager) descriptions - initially does not give the impression of being anything special. On the contrary, thoughts of 'Bleu de Chanel' or 'Encre Noire Sport' cast looming shadows. But that is far from the truth. While the descriptions are not misleading, there is quite a bit of fun in the details today, and the experience is rounded off by some things that, fortunately, do not happen.
Grapefruit, if you will.... I find the overall impression at least equally orange-substantial as it is sour-prickly. "Bitter orange" was the spontaneous remark of my favorite colleague. The sharp part could be attributed to the corresponding qualities of peony. As it progresses, I stubbornly stick to the "orange area," as on the skin it becomes almost sweet at times. This leans, certainly due to a desire for longevity, towards "nimm2" neroli, without ever crossing that line.
I am not familiar with mate tea. If a foundation that is both earthy and airy is supposed to refer to it, that fits, and I remain relaxed. However, if the coal-like smoky nuance that appears after about two hours, which actually reminds me of myrrh, has something to do with it (helpful hints are, of course, welcome), then the calm is over. I would then need to quickly procure this tea. The smoke is more present on some days than others; for me, if I had to highlight one aspect, it is the most extravagant touch here.
The vetiver may - among other things - be responsible for the wood department, which (another "not") is certainly not one found in a hardware store. On the other hand, it acts as a freshness extender throughout the day, but it never becomes a true substitute in terms of character. Rather, it gently stands on its own and can join in the afternoon.
The scent remains stable into the evening. While it does become comparatively sweet towards the end, it certainly comes across as a sparkling fruit candy, a lovely mix of orange and, if you ask me, grapefruit. That the citrus note likely requires such endurance from the chemistry does not bother me; it is excellent. Alongside this, traces of resin and smoke can sometimes be detected until the evening.
Regarding the conclusion, I was for a long time Between Two opinions. The scent provides certain arguments for being described as distinguished-stable-fresh and a bit boring. But upon closer inspection, it reveals finely detailed nuances that bring me much joy and constantly make me want to sniff again. Moreover, despite all its apparent adaptability, it always jumps out in a charming way. These last two facts simply had to tip the scales for a good rating.
I thank Verbena for the sample.
However, 'Between Two Trees' - and this starts with the expectations based on the (meager) descriptions - initially does not give the impression of being anything special. On the contrary, thoughts of 'Bleu de Chanel' or 'Encre Noire Sport' cast looming shadows. But that is far from the truth. While the descriptions are not misleading, there is quite a bit of fun in the details today, and the experience is rounded off by some things that, fortunately, do not happen.
Grapefruit, if you will.... I find the overall impression at least equally orange-substantial as it is sour-prickly. "Bitter orange" was the spontaneous remark of my favorite colleague. The sharp part could be attributed to the corresponding qualities of peony. As it progresses, I stubbornly stick to the "orange area," as on the skin it becomes almost sweet at times. This leans, certainly due to a desire for longevity, towards "nimm2" neroli, without ever crossing that line.
I am not familiar with mate tea. If a foundation that is both earthy and airy is supposed to refer to it, that fits, and I remain relaxed. However, if the coal-like smoky nuance that appears after about two hours, which actually reminds me of myrrh, has something to do with it (helpful hints are, of course, welcome), then the calm is over. I would then need to quickly procure this tea. The smoke is more present on some days than others; for me, if I had to highlight one aspect, it is the most extravagant touch here.
The vetiver may - among other things - be responsible for the wood department, which (another "not") is certainly not one found in a hardware store. On the other hand, it acts as a freshness extender throughout the day, but it never becomes a true substitute in terms of character. Rather, it gently stands on its own and can join in the afternoon.
The scent remains stable into the evening. While it does become comparatively sweet towards the end, it certainly comes across as a sparkling fruit candy, a lovely mix of orange and, if you ask me, grapefruit. That the citrus note likely requires such endurance from the chemistry does not bother me; it is excellent. Alongside this, traces of resin and smoke can sometimes be detected until the evening.
Regarding the conclusion, I was for a long time Between Two opinions. The scent provides certain arguments for being described as distinguished-stable-fresh and a bit boring. But upon closer inspection, it reveals finely detailed nuances that bring me much joy and constantly make me want to sniff again. Moreover, despite all its apparent adaptability, it always jumps out in a charming way. These last two facts simply had to tip the scales for a good rating.
I thank Verbena for the sample.
Translated · Show original
16 Comments


However, after your wonderful and "nose-tickling" description, I find myself neither "Between two Trees" nor opinions, but rather between two stools: should I or shouldn't I?
(Should I dare to try this scent... advise me, but don't discourage me.)