Log in

Create Account Forgot your Password?
Derby (2005) by Guerlain

Derby 2005

Version from 2005
DaveGahan101
11/15/2014 - 10:45 AM
13
Top Review
7Scent 10Longevity 7.5Sillage 7.5Bottle

D A S Alpha Animal!

Thanks to dear Kiengira, I got to enjoy the vintage edition... and I was already super excited about this top classic! I'll keep it short, Derby is a fragrance from the category "You shall have no other gods before me"... no, I'm not well-versed in the Bible... but that sentence is, for me, the essence of this scent. Derby demands, Derby absorbs, Derby challenges, Derby has edges and corners... Derby flattens, Derby scratches, Derby is a statement, Derby is appealing. I took three weeks to comment because I wanted to let it fully affect me... I wanted to give my nose development a bit more time than usual... and in the meantime, I compared it with the current version.
Derby intrigues me, lures me in - pushes me away... Derby delights - Derby confuses... and Derby makes me age.
I simply can't find access to this tough nut, at least not in a way that I would want to wear it... but I somehow enjoy sniffing it on my wrist... strange... I had the same effect with Tobacco Vanille (but that's a totally different alpha animal). I really like the orange-bergamot start in Derby... but that's just a second-long opening before the dominant "Clove" appears... exactly this note ruins this fragrance for me... and a few others as well... in moderation, I actually like this scent note quite a bit... I even love it in Dries van Noten. The beautifully embedded patchouli is well-measured... leather in a tolerable dose for me... but the spicy carpet is so concentrated and opaque that it's just too much for me... even if it's too much of a good thing;-). The newer version is a bit brighter and finer... but still remains an alpha animal. What I really like (as is often the case with Guerlain) is the wonderful development that lasts for hours... and keeps taking new directions... a great scent without a doubt... superb quality... but just too masculine for me... too classic "men's fragrance... I'm already over 40... still, with every spray, I feel like I'm aging... sounds like a perfect employee perfume (before you know it, you're retired;-))... but it doesn't make me happy... and I don't feel comfortable (which is a minimum requirement for a perfume) with it either... it simply evokes the wrong images for me... but I can totally imagine Kiengira wearing it.
Longevity of over 10 hours is excellent and the sillage with 2-3 sprays is room-filling... so you get something for your money... if you like such fragrances... the search for a true classic in my collection continues...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
10 Comments
AugustoAugusto 5 years ago
You probably already have a handful to a dozen classics in your collection. Looking back.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PlutoPluto 11 years ago
Retirement is all well and good, but aging that fast, no thanks!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
OrmeliOrmeli 11 years ago
Seems like a real gem. I completely missed it until now. :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Mustang69Mustang69 11 years ago
It's an eternal struggle with fragrances... great comment!!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MrWhiteMrWhite 11 years ago
I had a good laugh at the joke about the retiree and the spray nozzle, hahaha :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DaveGahan101DaveGahan101 11 years ago
Kiengira+0815: Lol... right on time at 6 PM, the food on wheels... that's how I like it;-)!!! You just have to cut the food into smaller pieces, C;-)))!!!! Sounds a bit like the movie "50 First Dates"...;-)))!!!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0815abc0815abc 11 years ago
Very nice. I'm currently at the senior center visiting Kiengira. He'll be so happy. It's like it's the first time! Trophy.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KiengiraKiengira 11 years ago
You're making me feel like an old man???????? Just be glad I'll forget this in 10 minutes (you know... dementia)... Still, trophy.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DaveGahan101DaveGahan101 11 years ago
..I almost thought so;-)!!!!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 11 years ago
Good and right, but for me it's a 90s scent... ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation