Parma
03/12/2021 - 05:49 AM
44
Top Review
8.5Scent 7Longevity 5Sillage 8Bottle

Ellena's Art

A hallmark of many Jean-Claude Ellena fragrances is their simplicity, achieved through a conscious focus on a straightforward core idea and a manageable number of components. Everything seemingly superfluous is cut away. He prefers to create scents with a clear, concise statement that, despite their simplicity, leave a memorable, distinctive, and lasting impression, while also offering something new to familiar fragrance profiles. He primarily does this in the realm of fresh scents.

**Fragrance:**
As with his work for Hermès (Eau de Mandarine Ambrée), he again takes the mandarin as the main theme here. While the Hermès fragrance emphasizes the soft, gentle side of the fruit, the creation for the Italian brand Laboratorio Olfattivo focuses on the virile freshness. Remarkably realistic and reminiscent of his Malle fragrance "Bigarade Concentrèe" (where the orange is featured), it starts off zesty, sour-fruity, intense, and invigorating. Over time, it develops a slightly increasing base sweetness that enhances the fruity impression. It feels rich and rounded but never (too) sweet. The mandarin remains very naturalistic.

Alongside the dominant fruity note, another olfactory impression stands out: a subtle, slightly spicy soapy tone. This effect, likely stemming from white musk, brings a restrained, diffuse-synthetic nuance. Almost like ISO-E-Super. Not intrusive (as I often find with noticeable artificiality), but it adds a slight sharpness. This gives this perfume cologne - i.e., an Eau de Parfum with a Cologne character - a certain transparency and, above all, a clean, well-groomed quality. In terms of structure, it is quite comparable to Dior's "Dior Homme Cologne" from 2013 (citrus note and diffuse musk, just as clean, similar consistency, same freshness effect, also nearly linear). On the skin, the musk develops a very slight creaminess over time, without softening the fruity character. It is one of those few fragrances that I still enjoy just as much at the end of the wearing time as I did at the beginning.

In overall impression, I would describe it as a fruity mandarin scent with a slightly spicy soapy touch. This combination is so well blended that it creates a very distinct fragrance profile. Despite its simplicity, it feels refined. It is not a pure representation of nature - as Ellena never aims to create - but rather a slightly altered version through soap and a diffuse synthetic vibe (without feeling artificial!). Even in times of not wearing it, I can fully recall it. It imprints itself so deeply into the olfactory memory. To evoke this effect, in my view, is a particularly special ability of Ellena's. It is probably the reduction to the absolutely essential. The art and beauty of the radically simple. With appropriate skill and quality.

Somewhat hidden within it is also that classic French elegance, which Ellena interprets in his very typical, timeless, and slender, almost clinical modernity, and which I attribute to the slight synthetic undertone. For him, it often feels somewhat masculine - at least that’s how I perceive it - if one wants to think in usual categories. Thus, I see the mandarin here, despite all the playful liveliness of the fruity note, as rather mature and quite elegant.

It develops very quickly close to the skin but is surprisingly long-lasting and slightly perceptible on the skin, so that I can still detect it the next day. Often an effect of high-quality musk molecules. According to local classifications, however, an effortless perception of 4-5 hours seems to be a realistic benchmark.

**Conclusion:**
A very beautifully blended, well-groomed, and full-bodied fruity mandarin scent with the special Ellena undertone. For me, the most appealing pure mandarin scent so far.

**Side Notes:**
I have only had a similarly realistic impression of a mandarin with "Owari" by Odin New York (later with a soft creamy wood underpinning) and Guerlain's very pure "Aqua Allegoria Mandarin Basilic." With some reservations, also with Hermès "Eau de Mandarine Ambrée" (slightly muted mandarin, herb-woody and warm-creamy undertone). Acca Kappa's "Green Mandarin" also starts off quite authentically but remains in a rather immature stage and increasingly feels artificial.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
18 Comments
DOCBEDOCBE 1 year ago
Always a pleasure to read your informative comments.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParmaParma 1 year ago
Thank you so much 😊🙏 That makes me really happy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
NidaNida 4 years ago
Wonderful analysis of a fragrance.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MonsieurTestMonsieurTest 5 years ago
Very beautiful, high-resolution film of a mandarin review with a great Ellena spotlight.
Great comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FvSpeeFvSpee 5 years ago
1
Thanks for the encyclopedic description, the interpretation, and the highly interesting comparisons. Clinically sleek goblet, but without musk.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
NikEyNikEy 5 years ago
Great description. I still have a sample of it here, so I guess I should test it out soon...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Medianus76Medianus76 5 years ago
1
Another very intricately and multilayeredly described review from you. Truly successful and very, very enjoyable to read...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BeatriceABeatriceA 5 years ago
2
I found the top note wonderful, but then it became too powdery for me - and it faded quickly. I'll stick with "Green Mandarin."
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Melisse2Melisse2 5 years ago
1
I also like this fresh green mandarin with a soapy touch. Well described.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AugustoAugusto 5 years ago
1
Very nice, detailed presentation of the fragrance. And we're definitely fans of Ellena anyway.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SiebenkäsSiebenkäs 5 years ago
Very detailed and analytical, but also vivid and sensual comment..., no, review. I find your thoughts on the memorability of scents (also as a special quality criterion) particularly fascinating. A mandarin scent that I also need to try! Big tropical fruit designer trophy for you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Fresh21Fresh21 5 years ago
1
Very nicely and detailed described, and the mandarin scent comparison is helpful too!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ToppineToppine 5 years ago
What a brilliant comment! The break has really done you good. The quality of your descriptions has - if that's even possible - improved even more. I wasn't a big fan of the scent (black currant!), but I could practically smell it again. I agree with everything about Ellena, but he actually wanted to be a writer... Otherwise, see Gold and Schatzi.
Parfumo Grandmaster Trophy for you..:-))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FlirtyFlowerFlirtyFlower 5 years ago
1
I was just thinking of Jean-Claude Van Damme ;) Well written - trophy for you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FlohFloh 5 years ago
2
Great to hear from you. Thanks for this description. I suspect I would like the scent. Hopefully, I can test it out soon. Thanks!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 5 years ago
It sounds really nice, but it might come off too masculine for me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchatzSucherSchatzSucher 5 years ago
1
I'll sit down with my highly esteemed colleague Gold and nod in agreement.
A comment that has everything it needs. I usually get along well with Mr. Ellena's creations, and this fragrance from a brand I really like has been on my wishlist for quite some time. You've just reinforced that.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 5 years ago
Everything about the mandarin is covered... looked at from all angles, other mandarin scents included, Ellena perfectly portrayed. Great writing. I feel thoroughly informed and on-topic (!) Thank you so much. I really like your style.
Translated · Show originalShow translation