Escale en Indonésie by Les Indémodables

Escale en Indonésie 2020

Profumo
04/16/2023 - 11:49 AM
31
Top Review
10Scent 7Longevity

The Twist: an Amber that arches over everything

Few labels have captivated me in recent years regarding high-quality materials and perfume artistry as much as the small company "Les Indémodables" from the French Alpine town of Annecy.
How often do we witness the boasting about oh-so-noble ingredients that ultimately, due to a lack of skill - or will - only results in mediocrity? Here, however, one can, and above all: one wants to.

That Antoine Lie masters his craft is beyond question, and this also applies to the second house perfumer: Florence Fouillet. Her "Fougère Emeraude," her "Cuir de Chine," and "Chypre Azural" are all-around successful, stylish, and characterful contributions that a small label could only wish for.
From Antoine Lie's contributions to the portfolio, two creations stand out particularly: "Ambre Suprême" and this one: "Escale en Indonésie."
Both focus on a particular fragrance ingredient that enjoys an almost mythical reputation: Ambergris, or Ambre gris, or Gray Amber. A fragrance material with an exceedingly complex scent profile, distinguished by a peculiar characteristic: it makes a perfume, no matter how many notes may be involved, truly shine and imparts a creatureliness where there may have previously been a template-like flatness. These almost magical abilities, combined with the legendary origin from dark whale stomachs, establish the mysterious myth of "Gray Amber," which one rarely - oh, what am I saying, actually never! - experiences so prominently staged as here, with these two amber-centered fragrances (a third, "Mxxx" from Eris, is also by Lie). Typically, when amber is advertised as an ingredient, it does not refer to the natural product but rather one of its now numerous synthetic substitutes, all of which at best offer a glimpse of the kaleidoscopic natural scent profile, but never capture its full richness of facets.

To compensate for this shortcoming, Antoine Lie does not need to create an Ambergris accord like many other colleagues, which supplements the missing facets with additional notes; instead, he can showcase the natural product in all its chameleon-like transformative ability, as he is practically at the source thanks to his professional connection with Rémi Pulvérail, the owner of "L’Atelier Français Des Matières" and husband of Valérie Pulvérail, who is herself the owner of "Les Indémodables."

Here, he does not stage the amber in a gourmand-tinged oriental fragrance concept ("Mxxx," Eris), nor is it embedded in an aldehydic-spicy-floral Chypre construct ("Ambre Suprême"), but rather lets it shine in a classic, slender Cologne framework of bergamot, fresh citrus, a hint of jasmine and neroli, as well as a stabilizing base of subtle sandalwood and oakmoss.

Perhaps this classic Cologne structure is indeed the ideal setting for the complex scent cosmos of amber, because unlike the two other mentioned fragrances, I do not have to try to filter out certain scent components that obscure crucial areas of the amber canon (cocoa here, aldehydes there), but can enjoy the amber unfiltered and in full regalia, like an open book. The fresh and delicate Cologne components dance around it lightly, as if carrying it on their hands, forming a light-colored, watercolor-like scent background against which the amber seems to lounge comfortably like a many-armed octopus while simultaneously lifting off olfactorily.
Of course, the other two Ambergris fragrances by Antoine Lie pack more punch, are orchestrated more richly, and unfold a greater volume, but those who have sniffed around the perfume world for a while and have delighted in the densest extraits will come to appreciate the quieter, smaller format again - it doesn’t always have to be the symphonic orchestra at Mahler strength; sometimes, the more intimate chamber music performance can even overwhelm even more.

So it is here.

The few participants are perfectly coordinated and flawlessly balanced. Juicy, zesty, and wonderfully natural are the citrus notes, soft and friendly, without the slightest hint of indolic, the delicate floral heart, and in the base, a slender and elegant Chypre structure that gives the fragrance support and rounds it off.
The twist: an amber that arches over everything with its salty, mineral, ozonic, animalic, and warm nuances, which seem to emulsify seamlessly with the Cologne facets while simultaneously standing out distinctly. A play of contrasts that could not be more exciting and sets the entire richness of the amber scent cosmos into vibrations.

People, if you think Ambroxan, Orcanox, Ambrinol, or whatever the attempt at amber synthesis may be called, is a sufficient equivalent, then please smell this fragrance, or alternatively the other two: the difference is immense! Not that I want to speak ill of Ambroxan & Co., no, they absolutely have their right to exist (I believe that the Ambroxan devil we always like to paint on the wall is more of a Woody Amber devil, or at least one that reliably beds down with those damned synthetic ambers....), but once you have sniffed real Gray Amber, horizons open up that you could previously only vaguely sense: olfactory resonance spaces that you could have already stuck your nose into before, but which remained voids, olfactory black holes, so to speak, now filled to the brim.

But enough of the flattery - I am thrilled!

One small but not insignificant note: since the amber also possesses excellent fixative properties, it makes this Cologne, which also goes by 'Cologne Absolue' (the bottom of the box even states 'Eau de Parfum'), quite a lasting affair. Although the scent retreats to the skin fairly quickly in typical Cologne fashion, 'Escale en Indonésie' remains there for many hours as a complex and warm fragrance, enveloping the body of the wearer more like an aura than a scent armor.

That's how I like it.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
27 Comments
GinTonique70GinTonique70 8 months ago
Thanks for this great review, I'm thrilled! I'm a huge fan of Ambre Supreme, it's been on my wish list forever, and now I'm also tempted by the Cologne... oh... this is never going to help with reducing my collection...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GinTonique70GinTonique70 8 months ago
Just had it under my nose. Thank goodness, my wallet is safe. It feels too flat and one-dimensional to me, and a bit too sharp and masculine as well. Okay, maybe that's a bit unfair; a cologne is a cologne and less complex. I'm definitely still saving up for the **Ambre Supreme**.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SetaSeta 2 years ago
A highly interesting review! I already liked 'Iris Perle' from this brand a lot. Now I definitely want to smell this fragrance as well, since I haven't been able to grasp 'gray amber' scent-wise either - although the real thing is hardly found in a perfume anyway. And I prefer scents that are 'smaller in format' - sometimes too much density overwhelms me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
JonasP1JonasP1 3 years ago
You've made me very curious about the scent. Great, informative comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GandixGandix 3 years ago
I love that, you the scent, and I your review... It's absolutely wonderful.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AxiomaticAxiomatic 3 years ago
Hats off, my dear!
Ambergris really does smell light-years better than the cursed woody amber chemical disasters of recent years.
I can't wait to smell it!
Mahler Opulence Trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FloydFloyd 3 years ago
Great review again! Informative and entertaining. Thank you for that!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchatzSucherSchatzSucher 3 years ago
Oh wow, that sounds wonderful. I haven't come across anything from this house yet, but it seems to have some treasures.
I also consider myself one of the Ambrox critics, but I know there are differences.
Your description is once again a true delight.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MonsieurTestMonsieurTest 3 years ago
Wonderfully praised and made the nose curious,
very curious :-)).
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Rieke2021Rieke2021 3 years ago
I really like the brand; and the Ambre Suprême is already fantastic. I haven't tested this one yet, but I have no doubt it's a worthwhile fragrance experience.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MarieposaMarieposa 3 years ago
You've piqued my interest. Both in the scent and the brand. And I don't think I'm one of the lucky ones who has ever smelled real ambergris. At least not consciously. I'm even more curious now :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
1
For me, ambergris has always been a kind of phantom that I couldn't grasp. Even though I immersed myself in a fragrance that supposedly contained grey amber, I just couldn't isolate its scent. I think that's where its myth lies: it's there, but somehow also not. Its hidden presence doesn't go unnoticed, as it makes everything glow and take shape, which would have remained pale and shapeless without it. However, here, used in overdose (5% of the perfume oil, which is said to be quite a lot), it's practically dragged into the spotlight and garnished with just a few ingredients.
Even though 10% was used in Ambre Suprême and 7% in Mxxx, I find it most tangible here in Escale.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IntersportIntersport 3 years ago
1
It's great that you're completing your real Ambergris trilogy here; who knows, maybe there will be more to come. And about the Ambrox bashing, yeah… I almost suspect that it's just such a memorable name for a fragrance ingredient that makes it seem 'tangible' and iconic, thus more resilient… The Escale sounds fantastic from your description!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
1
Miguel Matos has expressed something similar, that very few people probably know what Ambroxan actually smells like and would likely be surprised that it smells quite different from how it's always described, and that the name is more of a cipher for the discomfort with the synthetic nature itself. I think he’s not entirely wrong.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TurandotTurandot 3 years ago
Actually, my curiosity about testing completely unknown brands has significantly faded over time. But your comment reminds me why I’m here in the first place. Thank you for that!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
You're welcome! But I feel pretty much the same: the constant and ever-increasing influx of new brands is making my curiosity wane. Here, I think it's worth taking a closer sniff after all.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KovexKovex 3 years ago
This brand creates beautiful fragrances, and this one seems to fit in nicely. Your comment makes me want to dive deeper into the amber theme.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
I find it an exciting topic, for sure! And it smells damn good! 😀👌
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777Can777 3 years ago
Sounds really appealing and quite well done. Now I'm curious..!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 3 years ago
The brand is great, and this scent really piques your curiosity!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
I'm done with the Ambra trilogy by Monsieur Lie now, and I have to say, I'm more than impressed!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FlirtyFlowerFlirtyFlower 3 years ago
That must be a great scent! Trophy for you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ScentwolfScentwolf 3 years ago
I’m not familiar with this brand, but your description is really intriguing.
There might be experiences here that I’ve been missing, and discovering them could really broaden my horizons.
Very nice review that gets me excited.
Thank you for that!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
Really an exciting brand, and anyone who wants to dive into the topic of amber vs. ambroxan will definitely have to check out Antoine Lie's Amber Trilogy in the future.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 3 years ago
Reads very pleasantly...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BertelBertel 3 years ago
Wow, that sounds fascinating - thank you! I wasn't familiar with the brand until now, but I definitely want to change that right away ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ProfumoProfumo 3 years ago
I find this brand really noteworthy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation