Log in

IrisMann
07/19/2011 - 05:23 PM
3
Helpful Review
4Scent 7.5Longevity

What on earth did the poor rose do?!

Why did a rose have to suffer so? It was brutally murdered from behind and then disposed of quite mundanely in the shredder!

That is the impression this delicately rose-tinted fragrance left on my skin.

First, I have to cough violently, then truly green notes come towards me. They practically leap at me. As if hundreds of roses are being sent through the shredder and I am standing beneath the output. I smell shredded rose petals and stems. The plant sap is spraying everywhere. I find this green smell very unpleasant.

Then the petals timidly make their presence known. A light scent of rose spreads. If it weren't for the crazy top note, I could really like this rose. But unfortunately, this unclouded impression fades quickly, as a slight musty tone emerges beneath the scent of the softly wilting rose petals. That's the end! The compost heap is approaching!

But I don't want to smell any of that on my skin!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
4 Comments
HyazintheHyazinthe 10 years ago
As a rose fan, I'm also disappointed. It was butchered; Jack the Ripper really took out his anger on this one.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SensualSensual 12 years ago
Have you tried Rose d'Homme? In my opinion, it's much softer and prettier. Twill Rose also irritates me, even though I actually like green scents.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IrisMannIrisMann 14 years ago
Thank you very much! I was also very disappointed. I had something completely different in mind.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FlorblancaFlorblanca 14 years ago
That's a shame for you, but it smells really nice on me, this rose. A little consolation.
Translated · Show originalShow translation