12
Very helpful Review
I had a completely different expectation
During my last visit to the LV Store, I was finally able to test City of Stars and took a sample with me. Los Angeles and the associated vibe are actually right up my alley. Therefore, City of Stars had been on my radar for a long time, but unfortunately, it did not meet my taste and missed the mark by a wide margin. In hindsight, I can't even say what I was actually expecting, other than the perfect summer fragrance. For me personally, this scent definitely does not have the summer character I envision.
To me, the fragrance smells quite linear, which may simply be due to my aversion. At first, I don't find City of Stars that bad. As expected from Louis Vuitton, the highest quality raw materials greet you. Very nice and high-quality citrus notes emerge in the first 5 minutes of the opening, with a sweet blood orange in the foreground for me. Lemon and bergamot remain rather subdued and are not dominant.
Once the opening is over, the horror begins for me. Sandalwood, musk, and tiare. In other words: powdery, creamy, and sweetly floral. Just in extremes.
I really don't want to smell this combination at 30 degrees in the shade; the fragrance is far too sweet for me. Yes, the citrus notes are still present, but they are extremely dominated by the powderiness and are only close to the skin.
From here on, not much else happens. The fragrance remains just powdery, creamy, and floral until the bitter end.
Unfortunately, for me, City of Stars is a huge disappointment. The bottle and the feeling that the scent visually radiates unfortunately do not match the content. I would never sell it as unisex. For me, it is a 100% women's fragrance and rather unsuitable for men. Longevity and sillage are rather average.
To me, the fragrance smells quite linear, which may simply be due to my aversion. At first, I don't find City of Stars that bad. As expected from Louis Vuitton, the highest quality raw materials greet you. Very nice and high-quality citrus notes emerge in the first 5 minutes of the opening, with a sweet blood orange in the foreground for me. Lemon and bergamot remain rather subdued and are not dominant.
Once the opening is over, the horror begins for me. Sandalwood, musk, and tiare. In other words: powdery, creamy, and sweetly floral. Just in extremes.
I really don't want to smell this combination at 30 degrees in the shade; the fragrance is far too sweet for me. Yes, the citrus notes are still present, but they are extremely dominated by the powderiness and are only close to the skin.
From here on, not much else happens. The fragrance remains just powdery, creamy, and floral until the bitter end.
Unfortunately, for me, City of Stars is a huge disappointment. The bottle and the feeling that the scent visually radiates unfortunately do not match the content. I would never sell it as unisex. For me, it is a 100% women's fragrance and rather unsuitable for men. Longevity and sillage are rather average.
Translated · Show original
5 Comments
Gyokuro2021 3 years ago
It's undeniable that people can have very different opinions about a fragrance. However, I find it outdated to assign a modern perfume to a specific gender. In my opinion, City of Stars is gender-neutral; I don't associate this scent with any specific gender.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Gyokuro2021 3 years ago
That's fine, but it doesn't make anything better. Seeing something as a man on a woman is a clear categorization/definition. I'm all about breaking free from outdated, stereotypical thinking.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Sebkunz 3 years ago
1
Can't categorize it, but I definitely favor it for a specific gender. To me, it's clearly for women.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Valerie7 3 years ago
3
I find the drydown incredibly addictive. When the creamy musk-tiare combo "takes the wheel"…🌝. But I agree with you, for me, the scent is definitely feminine.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Zimtröllchen 3 years ago
2
I think it’s great on a woman, but really not pleasant for a man...
Translated · Show originalShow translation

