Lucky Liquid by Maddox and Mills

Lucky Liquid 2019

SchatzSucher
08/04/2019 - 05:02 AM
50
Top Review
8Scent 6Longevity 6Sillage 7Bottle

Discovery in the Drugstore Shelf

While shopping for some mundane items recently at DM, I once again took a look at the fragrance shelf. The selection of scents there is rather limited, but now and then I allow myself a sniff or two.
From strange to remarkable, there’s always something in between. However, I do not belong to those who mock and reject the budget fragrances from the drugstore right off the bat. Some beautiful classic scents have indeed been unfairly relegated to the bottom shelf.
I noticed two fragrances from the new brand Maddox and Mills, Tough Tonic and Lucky Liquid.
In the end, I took home Lucky Liquid, and I do not regret the purchase, especially since it didn’t make a huge dent in my wallet.

One shouldn’t expect a revolutionary, exciting new fragrance creation here. No new and mysterious scent essences are being brewed into an extravagant or avant-garde whole.
But what comes out of the sprayer smells very pleasant.

After a slightly alcoholic start, Lucky Liquid appears spicy with a certain sweetness.
A light lavender note and some bergamot emerge, but I also immediately smell the sweetness of tonka, which holds up well throughout the entire scent progression. Cardamom and coriander add a slight spiciness.
After a while, the fragrance feels quite creamy to me, with a hint of floral notes also coming into play. I can clearly detect the orange blossom (which I often encounter in scents I like, even if I should be repeating myself).
I also perceive a hint of cinnamon, but not too strong.
Later, it becomes a bit woodier and warmer. This sweet creaminess remains throughout the entire progression.
Overall, the scent is not heavy or overpowering.
The bottle is quite appealingly designed, a bit vintage in style, fits well in the hand, and the sprayer is excellent.
Similarities to Gaultier2 are mentioned here. I can neither confirm nor deny that, as I am not familiar with Gaultier2.

The longevity is not breathtaking; after a maximum of 5 hours, it’s over, and Lucky Liquid does not project too strongly. I didn’t expect a longevity and sillage monster here.
By the way, I don’t find the scent to be exclusively for men; women can also confidently reach for it. I believe that one shouldn’t be too strict about categorization. Some men’s fragrances work very well on women anyway. The reverse can also be true.

Whether I will buy Lucky Liquid a second time, I don’t know yet. For now, I like it well.
Perhaps the brand will release more nice scents.

As an eager perfume tester, I don’t only look at the top, especially not in terms of price. A glance to the left and right, as well as downwards, can never hurt. Especially since I am hardly willing to shell out huge sums for fragrances. Adding a net cold rent for a fragrance, only to have to eat toast with mayonnaise for weeks, does not align with my realistic thinking, and I do not have a cash cow sitting in my basement. And perhaps this scent isn’t even truly suitable for everyday wear. By the way, “everyday suitable” is in no way negatively connoted for me.
Some see it differently and believe that only the niche of niches is truly worthwhile, and the more expensive a fragrance is and the more outlandish it smells, the better and more exclusive it is. But that’s up to each individual.
I have always felt comfortable in the mass market and will continue to do so. Even if there are indeed some extraordinary and exciting scents to be found in the niche.
Snobbery and box-thinking have always been suspicious and foreign to me.

Yes, the often-discussed topic of niche... This scent is also a niche for me. How? What? Huh?
Yaaa, I took it from a niche in the sales shelf!
Everyone can shape their own niche ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
26 Comments
GoldGold 6 years ago
Huge anti-snob trophy for you! You can find treasures on the bottom shelf too. The most important thing is the scent, not the price tag. It's sad that some people have it the other way around. They want to buy expensive! And think they’re special for it. What a great target for the industry. No, expensive doesn’t mean better. I'm a big fan of blind tests. They're so revealing...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChanelleChanelle 6 years ago
I wanted to test it today, but there was no tester. I guess I'll have to buy it soon... Here's to you, the enabler trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
RosalieRosalie 6 years ago
YEP, it keeps getting confirmed: "Good doesn't have to be expensive." This applies not only to fragrances. Honestly, I love eating too much to settle for just toast and mayonnaise. That's why I'm grateful for tips like these. And if you ever splurge too much, just message me, and I'll send you a "care package" ;o)))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PaloneraPalonera 6 years ago
Oh, great! I really need to go to dm again, and now you’ve given me the last reason I needed to get going! :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Sweetsmell75Sweetsmell75 6 years ago
Haha ... exactly niche ... I also found my signature scent of many years (25 years in total) (Bogner Woman No. 1) in the very back corner at Müller back then!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MeggiMeggi 6 years ago
I thought it was quite decent too.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KleopatraKleopatra 6 years ago
I totally agree with you! The main thing is that it smells good. Although, how that’s possible with O-Blüte... :))) Seriously though, the most expensive ones aren’t always the best, and the cheap ones aren’t always the worst. I don’t know that brand at all. Do they have women’s stuff too? ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TtfortwoTtfortwo 6 years ago
I'm not a fragrance snob either, and I sniff through every new release at DM. The fact that I end up liking very few has to do with my scent preferences (not sweet, classic signature). For example, I really love the original from S.Oliver (the women's version); I enjoy that mineral-earthy sandstone note, and the 4711s, all from the lowest drugstore tier. A big trophy for you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FloydFloyd 6 years ago
Funny, I had that one in my hands last week too. I didn't think it was bad either. Well written! **Treasure hunter in the drugstore trophy!**
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 6 years ago
You can't complain for the price.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParmaParma 6 years ago
Even at discount stores, you can find real gems. You tend to appreciate them more than those in specialty shops, where you expect it more. I'm happy for you :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
StanzeStanze 6 years ago
Everyone has to decide for themselves where and what to test or buy. The price of perfume doesn’t determine a person's character, and in the end, that's really the only thing that matters. Mass appeal.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777Can777 6 years ago
I've smelled some really expensive perfumes that were awful, and some beautiful, affordable ones that deserve a prize. I'll put a trophy in the missing niche at DM. Although it could get bigger after your comment!... ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SonnenwendeSonnenwende 6 years ago
Looking in all directions is always sensible and helpful. Your page is definitely worth a look. You've made a very interesting new discovery here that I will definitely check out, as your comment was already a pleasure to read :-).
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SiebenkäsSiebenkäs 6 years ago
Very nice and friendly comment. I'm totally with you on that and will definitely give it a try! Thanks for the niche tip! :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 6 years ago
Very nice! :) I'm checking this one out because if you recommend it, it must be good. By the way, I'm a fan of classic drugstore scents (Tabac, Old Spice, the Mühlhens stuff for sure, and even some newer ones). Often better than 90% of the designer stuff out there and better than almost everything from Parfums de Marly. *duck* ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
16paws16paws 6 years ago
I completely agree with you - good doesn't have to be expensive, and expensive doesn't automatically mean good. I'll definitely test the scent on my next visit to DM.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0815abc0815abc 6 years ago
Haha, that's true. Everyone can create their own niche. What's beautiful is what brings joy. Horizon trophy.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MicscentMicscent 6 years ago
Great informative comments. And it's nice that not only the high-end fragrances are described. Thank you for that. And of course, a "niche trophy" :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 6 years ago
I usually don't find anything. Quality and longevity are often poor. It usually comes with a price, and you say it yourself. Poor sillage and doubts about whether you'd buy it again.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Helena1411Helena1411 6 years ago
I completely agree with you! I feel the same way; the view should be open in every direction, it's all a matter of perspective. And I’ll repeat myself when I say that there would be many surprises if all fragrances were put into uniform bottles without labels and judged solely by scent, as I believe some perfumes labeled as drugstore scents would perform quite well.
So: thumbs up - great comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FabistinktFabistinkt 6 years ago
Great comment! You're absolutely right, in drugstore shelves you can find everything from junk to treasure.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GelisGelis 6 years ago
The scent sounds good. And yes, one should always let their eyes wander in all directions.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TaurusTaurus 6 years ago
That's true - you shouldn't dismiss drugstore fragrances right away... sometimes there can be nice little surprises... even with orange blossom ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CandyScentCandyScent 6 years ago
Well written! I see it the same way: A good fragrance doesn't have to cost a fortune! So why only browse the top shelf when there might be a gem waiting a little lower down? ;)
I've noticed that some people here almost feel the need to justify or apologize when they've bought a scent from the so-called "mainstream" category. Reviews are all about subjective impressions, especially regarding scent and longevity. Brand and price should really be secondary.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FvSpeeFvSpee 6 years ago
Sounds great. I've found a lot of junk in drugstore shelves, but also some really nice surprises. Just like spending 500 euros on a bottle doesn't guarantee you'll get something worthwhile.
Translated · Show originalShow translation