Tabac Original Craftsman (Eau de Toilette) by Mäurer & Wirtz

Tabac Original Craftsman 2019 Eau de Toilette

Stulle
11/09/2019 - 06:31 AM
30
Top Review
7Scent 7Longevity 7Sillage

The Sauvage Trap

I think the comparison with Sauvage leads us somewhat astray, as CRAFTSMAN is actually aiming for something quite different. For me, it is a fresh and green-herbaceous scent, by no means old-fashioned, but it certainly remains true to the brand's tradition. Before testing, one might simply think of the now somewhat aged Tabac Man, which hopefully prevents disappointment.

Upon spraying, citrus and peppery notes are predominant, and these are also the obvious parallels to Sauvage. However, the actual core consists more of geranium and lavender - at this point, I no longer want to compare the two fragrances too closely. In the base note, there is a moderate sweetness that likely comes from tonka bean.

CRAFTSMAN is indeed oriented towards the top notes of modern mainstream perfumes like the aforementioned, and thus it initially presents itself as very contemporary in a quick test, but unfolds its relaxed herbaceousness over time, revealing a masculine character that is not really classical, yet quite serious and somehow well-aged. Highly noticeable and overly loud appearances are not possible with this men’s fragrance. But there are other options for that.

At least this green framework ensures that it avoids the dreaded D-classification (D for shower gel) - you know, that's currently the highest penalty on Parfumo! A paper strip test, in my opinion, falls short here because it doesn't go far beyond the top note.

The potential wearer of CRAFTSMAN could be, for example, a well-groomed gentleman of middle age, not careless or old-fashioned, but also not dressed like a vain peacock, who has always used aftershave after his daily electric shave and only enters a perfumery when he wants to gift something to a nice person. The own fragrance should smell good but not beg for attention.

Recently, I discovered in a large supermarket the complete care series of the four currently available TABAC fragrances lined up next to and on top of each other: Tabac Original, Gentle Men’s Care, Tabac Man & Fire Power.
Actually very nice and somehow sympathetic. Obviously, Mäurer & Wirtz considers quite carefully whom/how/where the products are offered.

I liked this so much that I bought the deodorant stick from CRAFTSMAN. By the way, it maintains this sauvage-like note and I like it quite well for this purpose, just like the counterpart from TABAC MAN. Mrs. Stulle also notes for the umpteenth time that it smells quite good. And THAT should mean something!

In short:
a typical fragrance of the TABAC line, but fresher and more modern right from the start. If you are looking for an exact copy of Sauvage, you will miss the mark here. If you want a modern, green-spicy, and subtly sweet men’s fragrance at a budget price: go for it!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
13 Comments
AxiomaticAxiomatic 4 years ago
1
I tested Craftsman and Sauvage side by side and was surprised to find that Craftsman comes across as much more natural. Luckily, they skipped the Ambroxan here.
Kudos for your great description!
🏆
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FadeToGreyFadeToGrey 4 years ago
Very calm, informative comment. That helps!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DOCBEDOCBE 5 years ago
I have to try this one too. By the way, relaxed casual comment.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Craftsman19Craftsman19 6 years ago
Tabac Craftsman is my only fragrance, and I wanted it mainly because everyone says it smells like Sauvage but is much cheaper (I'm still a student). I was lucky enough to smell both fragrances, and Craftsman was more of a blind buy for me (it smelled completely different than I initially thought after I sprayed it on the tester strip). I really have to say, you hit the nail on the head; I can only confirm everything. Wow, great review!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MörfiMörfi 6 years ago
I use the aftershave and I'm really impressed.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
StanzeStanze 6 years ago
1
The sauvage opening would definitely put me off. I hate the Sauvage pepper, and unfortunately, it doesn't just stay in the top notes for me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 6 years ago
1
And I overlooked this comment as well. Very interesting approach you've taken here. By the way, I find it better than the rest of the shower gel crowd, but I was still disappointed by the old traitors.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
RndNameRndName 6 years ago
1
Strangely, with the deodorant (spray deodorant), I feel like the top note is missing and it’s directly floral. I had the deodorant long before the EdT and was really surprised that it’s supposed to be the same scent when I tried it on a test strip.
I also find the 50ml bottle very practical for on-the-go; no need for decanting.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SanktVithSanktVith 6 years ago
Fair comment. If you add the aftershave, it really boosts the sillage - just like with Tabac Man.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AjlenAjlen 6 years ago
Great comment, thanks!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParmaParma 6 years ago
Nice and informative comment. Sauvage is moderately dosed and a good scent on the right skin. The deodorant is great too. However, I don't need that cheap shower gel vibe in perfumes - that's what shower gel is for. I'll stick with the excellent original Tabac.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SiebenkäsSiebenkäs 6 years ago
Very useful, fair, and beautifully written comment - of course, there's a well-deserved trophy for the very popular A classification (A for Awesome).
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChevalierChevalier 6 years ago
A very good comment that really excites me. Especially the thoughts on where and for which segment Mäurer & Wirtz is positioned, I can definitely agree with. They also don’t see Tabac as competing with Dior, Givenchy, and other mainstream brands in the higher segment, which is a good thing. I’d love to give you two trophies....
Translated · Show originalShow translation