Log in

Create Account Forgot your Password?
Putting Green by Omerta

Putting Green

FabianO
10/18/2017 - 04:29 AM
17
Top Review
8.5Scent 6Longevity 6Sillage 5Bottle

The Dupe-Dude - Wild Water Approach for Under 10 Euros

Yes, sometimes the cheapies really do surprise you. "Putting Green" is - I really have to keep this comment short - a 90% successful copy of "Eau Sauvage".
I have always loved the old 1966 version with its gentlemanly, wonderfully balanced, slightly candy-like, subtly herbal lemon.

I’m not really a fan of copies; I don’t like to support idea theft. With perfumes, the general perception seems to be different than with books or music. Artists are often accused of lacking innovation and, in the end, almost always rightly so. Scents are (unfortunately?) freer in their deceptive disguise - one pretends to wear Dior while only having paid 9.95 euros for the bottle.

Do "Eau Sauvage" and "Putting Green" even differ at any point? I mean, you really need a very, very trained nose, but I would perhaps attribute my above-mentioned 10% difference to the slightly creamier aura that envelops the real "Eau Sauvage".

In the opening, it is overwhelmingly lemony, spiced green with rosemary and basil, gradually unfolding the typical Dior feeling. Patchouli and coriander in the heart, slightly earthy grounding. Here I notice a small difference from "Eau Sauvage". After all, they differ according to the ingredient list with the absence of "fruity notes" and "lavender" here. Perhaps that’s where the unrecognizable candy-like creaminess lies, with the absence of lavender lending a touch less complexity.

This is undoubtedly complaining at a high level - anyone who buys "Putting Green" acquires a rounded, classic, closely aligned dupe-dude, whose longevity could use some improvement. I use the EdT as an aftershave, and it fits perfectly.
Updated on 10/18/2017
Translated · Show originalShow translation
5 Comments
FittleworthFittleworth 8 years ago
Very informative comment. Kudos!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FeliniFelini 8 years ago
Yep, it came, saw, and conquered with Mr. Felini, and I still have something to sniff in the evenings; longevity is great.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 8 years ago
1
It's truly impressively close to the original. Can't complain.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FabianOFabianO 8 years ago
Yes, currently Dior has tinkered with it a bit too much.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TerraTerra 8 years ago
I find Putting Green to be much creamier, mossier, and above all... much more long-lasting than the now thin Dior water.
Translated · Show originalShow translation