Bloodxclat
11/28/2022 - 05:29 PM
33
Top Review
8Scent 8Longevity 7Sillage

Comments on Vanilla

Fragrance pyramids help us, in most cases, to categorize a perfume; to classify it. This can be very useful when, for example, searching for new, suitable perfumes. So you can already start sorting!

I would have actually passed on Provanilla based on the pyramid - coconut, melon, rose, vanilla? This can't be Charna's serious intention! However, I remembered reading a blog about the perfume a few years ago. So there must be something to it.

For the "uninitiated"; Charna Ethier runs a brand called Providence Perfumes, which uses only natural ingredients. A lot is also made in-house regarding tinctures and absolutes.

Back to Provanilla. Or generally, vanilla. What do we think of when we hear vanilla? Sweet creams, vanilla rolls, pudding, fluffy pancakes. Sweet, hearty, gourmands. This is the image we have of vanilla in our minds. I also think of overly sweet designer clangers, vanillin bombs, migraine-inducing chemtrail niche brands with vanilla butter.

Provanilla is NONE of that. It is so different, so fundamentally distinct from other vanilla scents that it is truly astonishing what we classify and categorize as 'vanilla scent' in our perception.

Provanilla is "real." And in "real," vanilla is bitter. Dark, bitter, woody, and spicy. And light. Fine. Rather to be classified as a middle and base note, more of a background filler that wants other notes to take the forefront.

For these "real" vanilla tones, which are derived from handmade tinctures and CO2 extracts, Charna has chosen a bold top note; melon isolates. The melon isolate is usually derived from the natural oil of Litsea Cubeba.

Fresh, high-pitched, light, shimmering, floating; like a natural aldehyde, lightly fruity-watery mists swirl around my ears, beneath which is a very fine nutty creaminess, completely unsweet, the coconut.

Then it becomes slightly bitter, dark, with clear vanilla tones, brown, black, sometimes a bit creamy, sometimes a bit sweeter, but mostly rather bitter, woody, aromatic, and simply real. Sometimes a bit earthy, sometimes slightly smoky, sometimes it even smells like cocoa. But it definitely feels correct; this is how vanilla should smell. Real vanilla. Derived from genuine natural raw materials and processed into a perfume.

Provanilla is an aura scent, one that constantly changes and feels slightly different with each wear / season / body temperature / activity. The myrrh and benzoin blend perfectly into the background and create a pleasant, resinous frame for the coveted exotic pods.

Due to 100% natural ingredients, Provanilla is extremely dark and staining.

I admire the persistence and the idea behind this perfume. Charna has reportedly worked on this perfume for over a year. Whether it will appeal to the vanilla fans among you, I cannot guarantee.

The fact is, however: It is real and genuine, and no synthetic substances have been used to deceive us into thinking what vanilla should smell like. Rather, it smells just as it should. I won’t put my hand in the fire for it, but it may well be that Provanilla is the perfume with the highest natural vanilla content on the market.

Many thanks to Dorabella for the rare sample!

Translated · Show originalShow translation
38 Comments
MairuwaMairuwa 1 year ago
I was one of the clueless ones. I probably wouldn't have looked at the pyramid a second time either. But now I'm really curious about a perfume called Provanilla! I never would have imagined that. Thanks for that!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MrczrbMrczrb 3 years ago
Super fine authentic scent experience. Thanks for your detailed description.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 3 years ago
My test was a long time ago, but I found it authentic and good as well.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DelightfulDelightful 3 years ago
Very nicely written and described, my dear :D..
I really love the true scent of vanilla in perfumes, that dark, bitter, and aromatic quality.
Sure, I have quite a few fragrances where the vanilla is artificially created, but still within a pleasant range.
However, I really enjoy a scent where it’s bitter and genuine, as my nose truly appreciates the real fragrance notes. ;)
So this one sounds very interesting to me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SmoetnSmoetn 3 years ago
That sounds so great, and I learned a lot in the process!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FriesinFriesin 3 years ago
Just wiped away the drool, you described it so impressively, great!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AxiomaticAxiomatic 3 years ago
Wonderful review, informative and well-researched.
I've smelled vanilla in nature just like you describe. A huge difference from the artificial vanillin in sweet.
I'm curious about the scent.
🏆
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchalkerinSchalkerin 3 years ago
Sounds very interesting and good.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MonsieurTestMonsieurTest 3 years ago
Interesting journey through the vanilla and melon hinterland, the natural...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
LilianDarkLilianDark 3 years ago
According to the fragrance pyramid, the scent wouldn't interest me, but your description of "real vanilla" brings it back into my radar. I recently got #Perris Monte Carlo Vanille de Tahiti, and your description of true, unadulterated vanilla fits it perfectly.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GandixGandix 3 years ago
The vanilla sounds nice, but I'm still passing on the melon and coconut.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Medianus76Medianus76 3 years ago
That all sounds very exciting, and I can really see myself enjoying this one. A great presentation for a fragrance that will surely captivate many!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
NuiWhakakoreNuiWhakakore 3 years ago
It's always frustrating when prejudices aren't confirmed! This one would also challenge many of my assumptions; it sounds really interesting. I hardly ever liked a vanilla scent until now...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChizzaChizza 3 years ago
Doesn't sound like the vanilla my wife prefers ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FliolineFlioline 3 years ago
That sounds wow, exciting. Yes, I would have never considered that after the pyramid. But after Bloodxclat, definitely! Real unsweetened vanilla can be wonderful. The other ingredients... (melon and coconut, brrr) pretty wild. But now I want to know! :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GschpusiGschpusi 3 years ago
Sounds great. Too bad it's hard to find.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SebastianMSebastianM 3 years ago
1
I'm a self-proclaimed vanilla hater. From the militant faction, you could say I'm part of the Vanilla RAF. The only vanilla scent I like so far is Vanilla Havane, and even that is very dark, almost bitter. But after your description, I would love to try this one! Also because I know three other perfumes from Providence Perfumes and really liked their natural vibe. (For example, in Vientiane: a dreamy rice note!) What surprised me even more than your description of the vanilla was your portrayal of the melon. "High-pitched," "shimmering" - so not juicy, more like melon crystals. It all sounds so, so good...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BloodxclatBloodxclat 3 years ago
You make me laugh again :-D instead of Provanilla, Antivanilla forever!
Funny enough, it’s kind of an Antivanilla too, since it’s so different from the typical vanilla profile. You're right, the rice note in Vientiane was sensational.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
VrabecVrabec 3 years ago
Sounds great, real vanilla has nothing to do with those overly sweet vanilla scents.
Overall, it seems like an interesting brand, thanks for the introduction!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BloodxclatBloodxclat 3 years ago
Sure! Thanks for reading. Providence always has some nice things!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DorabellaDorabella 3 years ago
I enjoyed reading it. Unfortunately, the scent was too complicated for further production.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DorabellaDorabella 3 years ago
Yes, it got too expensive for her. I think she even mentioned that in the newsletter.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BloodxclatBloodxclat 3 years ago
1
Thank you! I believe it - definitely extremely expensive... 1kg of CO2 vanilla is around 10,000 EUR.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AtanarjuatAtanarjuat 3 years ago
That sounds great!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
M3000M3000 3 years ago
I wouldn't have thought that a fragrance with these notes could intrigue me before reading your review!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BloodxclatBloodxclat 3 years ago
I felt the same way. Super exciting!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 3 years ago
Wow. That makes me even more curious. Great review 👍🏼
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BloodxclatBloodxclat 3 years ago
Thank you! Something different!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 3 years ago
That definitely sounds very exciting. Thank you for sharing!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Helena1411Helena1411 3 years ago
I might actually like vanilla in the scent after all.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BloodxclatBloodxclat 3 years ago
I thought the exact same thing :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IntersportIntersport 3 years ago
Sounds great, the combination and your text! As someone who doesn't know much about Providence, I'll just say that pure vanillin can also be wonderfully spicy, dark, and bitter, as long as the dosage is right.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BloodxclatBloodxclat 3 years ago
That's interesting! I haven't come across that before.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeejungfrauSeejungfrau 3 years ago
Dark, bitter, woody, and spicy. THAT would be my vanilla.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeejungfrauSeejungfrau 3 years ago
Smoky vanilla would be nearly perfect.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BloodxclatBloodxclat 3 years ago
1
I think so too :-) a bit of smoke would be nice, right? ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FrauKirscheFrauKirsche 3 years ago
That sounds really exciting...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FloydFloyd 3 years ago
That sounds really good. You wouldn't expect anything less from Charna ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation