I do not know any of the other Replays, and I only have this one. I have had it for some time and the time and place to try it out never happened - until today.
First impression is sweet fruity. The registered notes are Gaia Apple and Mirabelle Plum, which both make sense. There is, nevertheless, a synthetic vibe hidden here, which comes out too soon and stays there all the way. It does not make the fragrance really bad, especially for those who prefer bathtub-ish scents. But to my nose, this smells a bit like a cheap shampoo., sorry to say. The Tonka Bean and Sandalwood make it softer and more agreeable after fifteen minutes. It does not, however, become great or anywhere near it.
For me, this is not a keeper.
Year 2, 166/365
