Woods in Love In the Wood for Love Roos & Roos 2018
30
Top Review
In Love with Woods
After testing Oud for Love last, it was of course time for Woods for Love from the sample box. However, this time I won't play with words, but simply note that I find it nice that "in the woods for love" has slipped into the subtitle and the stuff is now called "Woods in Love." Not only because the "in the hoods for love" gag will eventually be exhausted, but also because "In Love with Woods" fits the scent much better than "Into the Underbrush to Make Love."
This is, and I was totally surprised after spraying, a wonderfully lovely fine cheerful-in-love scent and by the way, not particularly woody. The creator has managed to conjure something very playful (but still absolutely suitable for men) from actually quite well-known ingredients: citrus, violet, and woods, above all something very unusual, new, and yet classically beautiful, and nothing that makes you think, okay, great experiment, but do I want to smell like that?
What I must point out, however, is that the In Love with Woods does move into a territory where one might want to have the folks from "VroniPlag" check whether the scientific citation guidelines have been properly followed or if the fragrance needs to have its doctorate revoked. Because I wore my "Bal d'Afrique" by Byredo again the day before yesterday (my wife was once again completely smitten, and there were compliments not only from my favorite colleague but even from my boss) and when I tested this one today, I thought: This smells just as beautiful as on Friday...
A quick look at the fragrance pyramid also shows massive similarities. If you were to use jasmine instead of orange blossom, the descriptions would be almost identical. Well, if you copy (or replicate, or coincidentally come up with the same idea without knowing the original), a dreamy scent well, you end up with a dreamy scent, but the Swedes from Byredo were just there ten years earlier.
So I give an unrestricted recommendation for testing, but you "need," if one can talk about such a thing, only one of the two scents. The "Ball d'Afrique" is the original, while this one has the prettier bottle. The price is similar for both. The Byredo is even more delicate, airy, and lighter, while the Double-Roos is somewhat clearer and more contoured, and its initial citrus is noticeably stronger; this one still has a bit of "töröööö, here comes the Mandarin Express," which is somehow funny, but the Byredo doesn't need that. It is more consistent and dreams of flowers and butterflies in love from the very first second.
That was a bit sketchy, but I'm already a bit drained from the Thailand blogs today. I can't manage more now. Sleep well. And dream of violets.
This is, and I was totally surprised after spraying, a wonderfully lovely fine cheerful-in-love scent and by the way, not particularly woody. The creator has managed to conjure something very playful (but still absolutely suitable for men) from actually quite well-known ingredients: citrus, violet, and woods, above all something very unusual, new, and yet classically beautiful, and nothing that makes you think, okay, great experiment, but do I want to smell like that?
What I must point out, however, is that the In Love with Woods does move into a territory where one might want to have the folks from "VroniPlag" check whether the scientific citation guidelines have been properly followed or if the fragrance needs to have its doctorate revoked. Because I wore my "Bal d'Afrique" by Byredo again the day before yesterday (my wife was once again completely smitten, and there were compliments not only from my favorite colleague but even from my boss) and when I tested this one today, I thought: This smells just as beautiful as on Friday...
A quick look at the fragrance pyramid also shows massive similarities. If you were to use jasmine instead of orange blossom, the descriptions would be almost identical. Well, if you copy (or replicate, or coincidentally come up with the same idea without knowing the original), a dreamy scent well, you end up with a dreamy scent, but the Swedes from Byredo were just there ten years earlier.
So I give an unrestricted recommendation for testing, but you "need," if one can talk about such a thing, only one of the two scents. The "Ball d'Afrique" is the original, while this one has the prettier bottle. The price is similar for both. The Byredo is even more delicate, airy, and lighter, while the Double-Roos is somewhat clearer and more contoured, and its initial citrus is noticeably stronger; this one still has a bit of "töröööö, here comes the Mandarin Express," which is somehow funny, but the Byredo doesn't need that. It is more consistent and dreams of flowers and butterflies in love from the very first second.
That was a bit sketchy, but I'm already a bit drained from the Thailand blogs today. I can't manage more now. Sleep well. And dream of violets.
Translated · Show original
18 Comments
Stanze 6 years ago
Sounds good, but if it already exists...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Finchen1976 6 years ago
Benjamin Blümchen trophy! :-D as always, beautifully and helpfully written.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Gelis 6 years ago
Sounds like I definitely need to try it, and the Byredo should go on the wishlist too.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Kovex 6 years ago
2
And I don't even know the African ball. Clearly, I've missed out on something.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Konsalik 6 years ago
I quite enjoy taking a ride on the Mandarin Express. So maybe this one is the better choice? Benjamin Veilch..., uh, Flower Cup. Törööö!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FlirtyFlower 6 years ago
Again, very beautifully written! 🏆
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Augusto 6 years ago
I really couldn't connect with it, even though I had imagined it so beautifully. About like your description.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Siebenkäs 6 years ago
You've described it very nicely! Since I like Bal d'Afrique, appreciate mandarins, and find the bottle really beautiful, I should probably give it a try... Thanks for opening up an alternative!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Pollita 6 years ago
1
OK, this is one I could check out too, in case my Bal d'Afrique starts running low. Ugh, I only got a "Not bad" for that one, no compliments. Typical Swabians...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Yatagan 6 years ago
I have a positive memory of the brand, and the reference to the African ball is great anyway. Exciting.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Meggi 6 years ago
You were really diligent!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Parma 6 years ago
Thanks for the comparison with Bal d'Afrique, it helps me gauge it well. Witty as always, a pleasure to read :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Cafenoir 6 years ago
I agree with Can, this sounds really interesting, I’d like to try it. I really like Bal d'Afrique; it’s just one of the few scents that I stop noticing too quickly. Thanks for the tip!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777 6 years ago
If it smells similar to Bal d'Afrique and is even a bit stronger in projection, I would like this one even more. I'm all for more "törööö"! ... ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Floyd 6 years ago
I wonder what it feels like for a piece of wood to be in love and no longer smell like wood?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Seerose 6 years ago
I would have feared from the pyramid that it smells like leather perfume. You don't mention anything about that. Especially since the bottle design is similar to Irish Leather, just with birds here and horses in Irish Leather. But hey, the birds in the subtitle make sense, of course;-D - I know, I'm being silly like a teenager now.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUser 6 years ago
Got it, boss! I can already see the violets. Töröööö! I really liked the scent too. :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchatzSucher 6 years ago
You've conjured up something beautiful to dream about! I really liked Bal d'Afrique, and I'm sure I would enjoy this scent as well. And soon I'll be heading towards Heia with the Mandarin Express...
Translated · Show originalShow translation

