4
Do I need both?
This will be a fragrance comparison "Cuir Béluga | Guerlain" vs. Jade Eau Fine Eau de Parfum
I have tested both and find their scent impressions to be quite similar. Powdery, oriental, vanilla.
However, upon closer sniffing, there are clear differences.
Starting with the vanilla; Guerlain's is simply unbeatable and incomparable. In my opinion.
The Cuir Beluga is also overall softer and has this wonderful wild leather note.
The Jade Eau Fine comes across a bit rougher. It is not as soft, but rather spicier, perhaps a bit more balsamic, and definitely more sensual.
I find that on a superficial level, both fragrances definitely remain similar/comparable. But when you really make a direct comparison, the answer to the question posed above could indeed be that one could use both.
If you want to keep your collection small, you should rather look at which one appeals to you more or which one is easier on the wallet. They are both expensive, but the Cuir Beluga is significantly pricier.
I have tested both and find their scent impressions to be quite similar. Powdery, oriental, vanilla.
However, upon closer sniffing, there are clear differences.
Starting with the vanilla; Guerlain's is simply unbeatable and incomparable. In my opinion.
The Cuir Beluga is also overall softer and has this wonderful wild leather note.
The Jade Eau Fine comes across a bit rougher. It is not as soft, but rather spicier, perhaps a bit more balsamic, and definitely more sensual.
I find that on a superficial level, both fragrances definitely remain similar/comparable. But when you really make a direct comparison, the answer to the question posed above could indeed be that one could use both.
If you want to keep your collection small, you should rather look at which one appeals to you more or which one is easier on the wallet. They are both expensive, but the Cuir Beluga is significantly pricier.
Translated · Show original
2 Comments
Hyhnchen 2 years ago
What's your conclusion now? 🥺
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Annalena1411 2 years ago
1
Well, that's the dilemma. Do I want to keep my collection small or not? 😅 The Cuir Beluga is really nice, but since I already have the Jade eau fine, I'm not too keen on buying it right now. That doesn't mean I won't eventually fall for the charm of this scent and add the bottle to my collection. 😅
Translated · Show originalShow translation