Sultan Murad by Ensar Oud

Sultan Murad

Cfr
12/21/2024 - 08:33 AM
15
Helpful Review
7Scent 8Longevity 9Sillage

Japanese oaks carry sweet peach moss, chilled cuddly animals drink iced tea with mint and chamomile, amber whale weeps honey citrus tears

an elegant solid fougere
gourmand scent for me
rugged soft oak wood, green herbs (lots of rosemary) spiced with cumin honey, black mint tea with chamomile, and bitter grass with a hint of anise, green moss is the base
on which cedar and lavender frolic, honeybees everywhere and leathery thick peaches fall from the sky, a small island somewhere, musk animals meditate
in the last piece of oud forest sleeping in the background.
Henry Jacques sends his regards.
Beautiful start as always with Ensar and then after 30 minutes it becomes almost synthetic, everything fades away, a hint of oud can be felt with honey, I have a lot of oak moss and oak with cedar here. The scent is soft lavender and has a lot of tea with chamomile and honey, amber with a lot of looking closely yes but I don’t know
there are better whales.
Very perfumey and wearable and
is not my herbal candy.
for me too little oud, too little different, no dimensions, the scent moves from left to right and lingers so long that it doesn't grab me, no.
Thank you to the dear Floyd for the testing opportunity.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
30 Comments
ChizzaChizza 11 months ago
Well, sometimes the scents are good, sometimes not, but they're all overpriced.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
1
Yeah, way too expensive for that! :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TonyTonkaTonyTonka 11 months ago
The scent notes don’t sound bad at all, but it doesn’t seem to be convincing. I haven’t encountered anything that smells synthetic from Ensar so far, thankfully.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
It's everywhere, trust no one 😉
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchoeibksrSchoeibksr 11 months ago
1.
I mostly agree with you and also ended up with a decent 7.
It's a briefly minty-cool jungle, with typical Papuan earthy (incense) notes. However, that faded away extremely quickly within seconds, and aromatic-fresh herbs like mint, chamomile (you too!) & fennel took over, giving me the tea vibes you mentioned for most of the duration, with slight mossy-vetiver-earthy accents underneath. So far, quite pleasant and ordinary, but what I found really exhausting was the last third of the scent, which was dominated by sweet, creamy musk that made everything softer and even more trivial. I would never want to pay the typically inflated price from Ensar just because of the ouds, which only stood out clearly in the opening with the typical jungle scent (Agarospirol, probably a foreign term for many), as you can achieve identical scent profiles with cheaper raw materials (which I suspect are used here in much higher doses).
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
The scent isn't bad, but it has nothing to do with an Ensar. The opening is great, but after 15 minutes, the fixatives start to take over, making it feel cheap. Then it just struggles to survive. It doesn't resonate with me at all. Yeah, it seems like they stretched it as much as they could. I feel cheated. 😐
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchoeibksrSchoeibksr 11 months ago
2.
I'm thinking of Bravanariz, Pineward & Noam, for example. So aside from the jungle in the opening, it smells like nothing that other notes can't also provide. The combination of fresh herbs & moss-musk fixation can also be found in many classic Henry Jacques & Fougères, so I understand where you're coming from. I have lavender like you, both pure as oil or plant, and that herbal-minty-sweet facet was definitely noticeable here.
It's okay for me, but to call it a great, particularly complex & even “Kinamic“ OUD scent feels like an exaggeration when I consider much oudier & more complex oud fragrances from other houses. Connoisseurs know which ones I mean. For such a big name, it's just too flat and more suited for beginners, in my opinion. Furthermore, I find it very diluted in character. Too many Ensars with oud in the name seem to be overshadowed by other notes lately.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchoeibksrSchoeibksr 11 months ago
3.
…which raises doubts given the prices. I felt quite fooled, especially since I've tested so many ouds from these regions, and after the disappointing test, I treated myself to a couple of Agar Auras as a response :D
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Ropanski2020Ropanski2020 11 months ago
2
Oh wow. Impressions and perceptions can be quite fascinating; especially when they turn out to be so different ☺️. I've tested this three times now and I still can't come to a final judgment. What I did notice in all three tests was a whole lot of Oud 🪵 (in the scent progression)! I only picked up on the herbal note more intensely during the last round, but for a Fougère, I think it lacks the (fresh-green) lightness and transparency that this lavender-coumarin genre often offers. I didn't detect anything synthetic here, neither prominently nor subtly (hidden in the base). Everyone's nose works differently, though. Seems like this isn't really your thing.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
Yes, they do ☺️ maybe I'm just looking too far.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FloydFloyd 11 months ago
1
Wow, how different our perceptions are here..
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
Yes, and that's a good thing ☺️
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BosworthBosworth 11 months ago
You have to be careful not to get a peach falling on your head.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
😃 nothing will happen
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MelonenwelleMelonenwelle 11 months ago
Sounds like almost every new Ensar that you test and hear about. Just not what they used to be anymore...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
Yeah, they used to be more exciting, what a shame :(
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GandixGandix 11 months ago
It's just not your thing...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
2
I like it, but it's too weak for me, and I'm disappointed. 😔
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchatzSucherSchatzSucher 11 months ago
On one hand, there’s quite a bit in there that I like. On the other hand, there’s also some stuff I don’t like. I’ll stay a bit skeptical, especially considering the brand, which hasn’t really impressed me so far, and I’ll leave you with the honey citrus tears.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
Almost everyone likes it! ;=
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ElAttarineElAttarine 11 months ago
1
It sounded more interesting before... I guess it's still intriguing for me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
I think it's a simple scent :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 11 months ago
1
Port Moresby sounds very much like Papua, which makes it exciting for me too! 🧐
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
That's more for the new Ensar fans 😎
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 11 months ago
Peaches and oak moss. Is there a hint of Mitsouko in here?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
No, there are definitely no flowers and no smoke either, but you do like tea, right? :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeejungfrauSeejungfrau 11 months ago
2
I don't see any synthetic elements or a connection to Henry Jacques here. And definitely not a fougère. Port Moresby might not be everyone's cup of tea, but your text leaves me puzzled. Sorry, I don't have an award for you this time. Don't take it personally, Biber - but your description just doesn't fit.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
1
😃 you know that, don’t you? 🫢
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeejungfrauSeejungfrau 11 months ago
It's NEVER about the rating, dear @Cfr
Not liking something is totally fine.
This is just another "I smell lavender" thing like back with Black Afgano. 😅
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 11 months ago
1
I'm so sorry too, dear mermaid 😔
Translated · Show originalShow translation