Esterel by Harry Lehmann

Esterel

FvSpee
03/27/2020 - 06:06 PM
33
Top Review
8.5Scent 7Longevity 7Sillage 6Bottle

CoViD Comments, Ninth Piece: Summer Revisions

Do you know the feeling of having made it through a tough week to the safe shore of the weekend and then celebrating with a nice dinner? Of course. It's somehow an anthropological fundamental experience. That's my state right now. And that's why I actually wanted to skip episode 9 and mindlessly sit in front of the TV. But just at that moment, I received a PM from a (remarkably talented) fellow perfumer praising the simple act of writing despite various adversities. And with that, I was grabbed by the mantle collar of honor. So I changed my mind, and here comes another episode. The ratings aren't sinking yet either...

So, let's stay in Provence, where we were already yesterday in Lourmarin. Today we're heading to Esterel, which is a mountain range on the Cote d'Azur, and it gets really hot there in summer. Moreover, there's a lot of wilderness and landscape with plenty of plants and animals, and once upon a time, there were holy hermits in hermit caves and less holy robbers in robber caves, which the good Stanze, who is probably very busy with her job now, vividly described in her previous comment. About 2 years ago, Harry Lehmann had another French phase and gave a few new fragrances such names, this one being "Esterel." So it's a new Lehmann. By the way, I give 9.5 points for the name because it sounds nice, is short, thematically fits the fragrance, and somehow fits like a glove. It's not entirely unique, as there are a few other fragrances with the same name. Otherwise, I might have given it a 10.

Esterel is fundamentally similar to the "Dimanche à la Campagne" from Guerlain that was commented on yesterday: a citrus-green summer fragrance, initially more citrusy, then gently shifting into green, and overall very simply constructed yet with a great, striking effect in its simplicity. However, the two fragrances differ significantly. The Guerlain has a soft musk base that radiates essentially into the top note, creating a light veil over the fragrance, like a haze over the summer landscape. This makes it reminiscent of early summer, and the absolutely unisex fragrance has a slight tendency towards the feminine. Esterel, on the other hand, is much harder, edgier, almost a bit rough, and completely without softening. It comes across as more masculine and more summery. Clear contrasts. Blazing heat with sharp light, and perhaps an ice-cold, crystalline water against it. Additionally, in "Dimanche," the citrus and green notes (which also include herbs here) are roughly balanced, whereas Esterel is predominantly a citrus fragrance that is only lightly greened. And, not surprisingly for Lehmann: Esterel has much more body, heft, longevity, and sillage than the Guerlain. What both have in common is that the citrus is a bright, yellow one; I suspect here mainly lemons, around which other citrus fruits might gather. Because this is less strongly balanced by green notes and musky softening in Esterel, the citrus gains a certain sharpness at the beginning, which indeed sometimes brushes against the dreaded "Ata-scouring powder note," although I don't find that bad at all. They added those scent substances to the scouring powder because they smell good, not because they stink; otherwise, scouring powder would smell like old sweat.

Friends of Harry might now notice and say: Wait a minute, citrus-green bombers, we already have those in the lineup. Right! Springfield. And there it is again, the reference freshie from the Lehmann house. Hence, here's another comparison (I made sure to spray 2 sprays each of Springfield and Esterel on kitchen towels before starting this comment to compare directly): The citrus of Esterel is lemony, while that of Springfield is, and I only notice this so clearly in comparison now, much more bitter and also a bit sweeter, leaning more towards bitter orange and orange. Esterel is, as mentioned, predominantly citrusy, whereas Springfield is actually somewhat greener. And Springfield has this deeply hidden, barely perceptible animalistic subtext, making it even more masculine than Esterel and, above all, both a much more erotic and a much more refined fragrance. But Esterel doesn't want to be that; Esterel remains a cheerful, honest, strong, prime summer fragrance.

Yesterday, we also talked about Camus, and one of his main works, "l'homme revolté," is always translated into German as "Der Mensch in der Revolte," but I think it's not about revolt in the sense of street battles, but more about something like reversal (of course, it's a play with nuances of word meanings either way). In any case, it's an occasion for me to thoroughly revise myself here again, after revising my decision not to write a comment today. I just deleted my old statement about this fragrance without replacement. Back then, I gave it 5.5 points and rambled about fermented fruits. Either the fragrance I tried back then had gone off, or I picked the wrong glass balloon at Lehmann's store (yes, those are the kinds of places where, before the plague, people used to go in to buy things), or I had eaten too many fermented fruits. Nonsense. Stanze had written underneath: "I'm surprised, I was sure you would like it." She's right. I like it too. And I perceive the fragrance very similarly to how she described it in her comment.

Esterel is thus a bright citrus fragrance, slightly enhanced with some green, playing just a bit towards the masculine, a high-summer and good-mood scent. Rich, round, full, a bit loud, a bit edgy, but really very beautiful. I wore it a lot during my trip to Thailand in January, and in that heat, it came out very well and was praised both by the Farang (i.e., Westerners) and by the Thai side. But even in Germany, under office conditions, it's a fragrance that is always met with goodwill and lifts the mood of the surroundings. Fragrances like Esterel show that the times of the good Lehmanni are far from over and give hope that the shop will continue to thrive for a long time. Clear test or blind buy recommendation for all fans of citrus summer fragrances and all fans of the Lehmanniade!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
21 Comments
GoldGold 4 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
It's great... i did not even know that he is "new", have bought it and just read your comment about it, super!
MonsieurTestMonsieurTest 5 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
What a beautiful and precise comparison of two citrusy scents that I don't know yet, as I focused entirely on acquiring the fragrances at risk of reformulation during my visit there last summer. Adding to my wishlist, should I like it.
ChizzaChizza 5 years ago
1
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Tested today, really a strong scent. I like your comparison to Springfield!
FittleworthFittleworth 5 years ago
1
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Another wonderful comment about a very beautiful, interesting fragrance. Thank you for that!
StanzeStanze 5 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
I'm glad to hear that you like it now. The Esterel lemons are definitely not fermented. Since scents are often linked to memories, I have some unpleasant associations with Ata as the only cleaning product in the castle, which is why I struggle with Ata lemon. But you're right, lemons smell better than sweat. I have the same issue with "green apple." That was the dish soap in the castle.
TtfortwoTtfortwo 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Look at that, I don't know it either. I just restocked on Springfield - that amazing faux dwarf. I promise, I'll add a small bottle of this to my next order.
SiebenkäsSiebenkäs 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Absolutely intrigued - adding it to my wishlist!
MeggiMeggi 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
"Südweh" is great!
There was a girl in dance class back then named Esterelle, she was half French. Wow, that feels like ages ago...
SetaSeta 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Help, I'm now experiencing 'Südweh' (Italian 'mal d'africa')! I also like the sturdier version of 'mediterranean,' but I prefer it on men this time. I find the comparisons of citrus haters to 'cleaning products' or even 'toilet bowl cleaner' exhausting and try to ignore them as much as possible...
Melisse2Melisse2 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
I really feel the need for the weekend today, especially this Saturday. However, I have to work tomorrow; otherwise, I won't manage the appointments I have coming up next week. I hope it gets quieter after that. I do like straightforward citrus freshness.
TooSmell27TooSmell27 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Due to their bulkiness and angularity, I always get the impression with the Lehmänner that you need to spend some time in the fresh air first. I guess it would be the same with this one. I’d rather not think about it being super hot just yet.
ParmaParma 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
The comparison with Springfield and Dimanche, along with the detailed scent description, makes it easy to imagine. This could be something for me. Maybe it's a bit too loud though. Thank you! ;)
PollitaPollita 6 years ago
1
Translated · Show originalShow translation
I don't know the scent, but I have been to the Esterel Massif. If it smells like you described, that sounds great!
FloydFloyd 6 years ago
1
Translated · Show originalShow translation
I'll keep that in mind.
ExUserExUser 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
I'm an active supporter of Guerlain, although I lean more towards woody and fougère scents rather than citrus-fresh ones, and this brand has a great selection of very good citrus fragrances. I must admit that my knowledge of Guerlain lemons is limited to Eau de Cologne du Coq, Eau de Cologne Impériale, Aqua Allegoria Flora Nerolia, and not much else.
Unfortunately, I'm also unfamiliar with this perfume.
YataganYatagan 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Look at that! A Lehmann I don't know yet.
MörderbieneMörderbiene 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
You see, I really have to visit the Spätzle colony again ;)
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Even though this isn't my style, I enjoyed reading the comment.
AugustoAugusto 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
I really like Esterel with its lemony lemon. Period. Now I even know where the name comes from, and it fits well.
KonsalikKonsalik 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Ah, I'm glad you took the time to sit down after all! Even though I'll probably take a closer look at the other segments of the Lehmann fragrance universe first, before I bring home the next green citrus scent straight from Springfield: A truly helpful comment in every sense!
SchatzSucherSchatzSucher 6 years ago
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Thanks for sharing a piece of a wholesome and normal world. I really liked Springfield, and I think I would enjoy Esterel too. However, I don't want to be somewhere that's super hot; the humid summers in Germany are already more than enough for me ;-)