I've smelled both Miami and Topaz. Topaz is more floral, while Miami has more lime and tobacco. I’m not really into the controversy, but I prefer Miami because it’s cheaper per ml with the coupon ($105 after tax and shipping for 50ml of Topaz, and $180 for 100ml of Miami after tax and shipping). That said, I’m not really into either scent—Miami is too dark for summer, and Topaz has too many florals for that heavy tropical vibe.
