Dreckig bleiben Limited Edition by AtelierPMP - Perfume Mayr Plettenberg

Dreckig bleiben Limited Edition 2013

Aava
05/14/2013 - 08:13 PM
37
Top Review
7Scent 7.5Longevity 7.5Sillage 10Bottle

The Modern Punk

Stay Dirty - A name that is as unusual as it is strange for a perfume. More a stance than just a name, Stay Dirty proclaims individuality and authenticity. Staying true to oneself, not bending under the pressure of the masses. Staying different. "Stay Dirty" is against conventions and a counterpoint to the myriad of countless new perfume releases that are thrown onto the market each year in completely overwhelming numbers. PMP - Perfumes Mayr Plettenberg, now well-known here in the forum as the collaboration of Stefanie Mayr and Daniel Plettenberg, who created "Stay Dirty" in collaboration with perfumer Mark Buxton, do it differently. They produce only 999 bottles of their unusual outsider fragrance and call it completely anarchistically "Stay Dirty." PMP thus relies on anti. Anti-mainstream, anti-superficiality, anti-going with the flow. That is punk. That is Never-Mind-the-Bollocks-punk in modern form.

So anyone who has heard of "Stay Dirty" is surely curious. Wondering how this anti-fragrance, this "finely tuned rejection of superficiality," might smell and what will be so special about it. Its reputation precedes it, and I can't help but raise my eyebrows in admiration at the fact that a young niche label carries the rejection of superficiality like a grand banner and positions itself against the average as well as the big players in the industry, while on the other hand, it has unleashed a marketing wave that I find astonishing. "Stay Dirty" appeals and seduces. The concept is grand. Everyone wants to be individual, unique, and self-sufficient and smell that way too. The concept works, and I suspect that not only I have almost clicked the "Buy now" button on the lovingly designed "Stay Dirty" homepage time and again without having smelled the fragrance first. "Stay Dirty" promises individuality and exclusivity and has obviously done everything right with it.

According to the description from PMP for "Stay Dirty," the fragrance is supposed to transport a cozy-light campfire atmosphere. You sit carefree with your best friends around a campfire by some river, probably somewhere in the industrial area of a medium-sized city, drinking beer from bottles that you have popped open not with a bottle opener but with a lighter, and chatting, laughing, making noise. "Stay Dirty" is supposed to smell like campfire and smoke. Like relaxed nonchalance. Something for individualists and free thinkers.

"Stay Dirty" starts with a beautiful accord of various citrus notes: mandarin, ginger, neroli, bergamot. Notes that are meant to proclaim lightness and a certain zesty carefree spirit. A truly wonderful opening accord that I find brilliantly composed. The notes are finely interwoven and so resinously soft that the opening of "Stay Dirty" already surprises. It falls surprisingly soft where I had expected more of a headnote bomb that roars like a punk when he bellows "God save the Queen." But no, "Stay Dirty" does not roar; it is cozy. There is nothing sharp-edged or loud here, but rather a bit herbaceous yet very warm and soft. Embedded in the resins of the heart notes, the top note makes no noise but appears round and harmonious in my nose. At most, I can smell the ginger emerging from the connection of the individual notes, which is zesty but also has a slightly woody quality. Here, a ginger root is just being freed from its woody, fibrous shell and exudes a healing, spicy-ethereal scent. All of this is not cologne-like, not airy and bright as day. No, the top note is heavy, rather dim, cozy like a large armchair, and from the very beginning so embedded in the resins of the heart note that it is clear: "Stay Dirty" is resin, resinous, resinous to the utmost! Gurjum and labdanum flow in a distinctly ambered softness, while the elemi resin together with the woody notes from the base is supposed to create the advertised smoky campfire atmosphere. But I do not find "Stay Dirty" distinctly smoky. Nor particularly woody. Smoky and woody nuances can be recognized, but they never push themselves to the forefront. Only in the base does the resinous dominance ease a bit and give the woody notes more space. Both the rather soft sandalwood and the slightly fresher cedar can be detected if you look for them. A non-sweet vanilla rounds it off, making the whole thing friendly and giving the base a calm and settled undertone.

Overall, "Stay Dirty" does not present itself as extravagant or loud. I even find the base quite conventional. Some comparisons have already been made to the unfortunately discontinued Gucci pour Homme I, which I can somewhat understand. "Stay Dirty" and GPH I are most similar in their base, although I find GPH I significantly spicier, more incense-like, and more oriental. "Stay Dirty," on the other hand, seems a bit softer and more reserved, and thus, unfortunately, also more ordinary for me. With all the marketing talk about individuality and authenticity, the anti-attitude, and the rejection of superficiality, I expected a much more uncompromising and experimental fragrance. I expected a fragrance as uncompromising as Bois d’Ascèse, which is supposed to smell similarly to "Stay Dirty" with its notes of smoke and campfire. In comparison to "Stay Dirty," Bois d’Ascèse implements the smoky theme much more powerfully. While Bois d’Ascèse as a fragrance makes a clear statement, polarizes, and fascinates with its uniqueness, what appeals to me about "Stay Dirty" is primarily the uniqueness of the marketing concept. The fragrance itself, although very beautiful and well-made, does not strike me as particularly unusual or particularly different.

Stay Dirty - stay different. Here, one stays different in coziness. No punk is occupying a house or scraping a few odd chords on the guitar anymore. The modern punk sits with a beer with his friends, listens to electronic music, and quietly discusses clever topics by a slowly smoldering campfire by the river, somewhere in the industrial area of a medium-sized city. The modern punk stays dirty, but not too loud!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
33 Comments
SetaSeta 3 years ago
Yes, the 'mainstream of minorities'... Beautiful deconstruction of a marketing hype! I'd love to read more of this kind of thing... But it seems that many prefer to submit uncritically to the 'influencer' now.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 12 years ago
I am deeply envious of every individual whose skin is suited to that old punk! How I wish I could have loved it *justreaditsobeautifulcry* Great comment, Aava!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SisyphosSisyphos 12 years ago
An epic comment, a strong engagement with the fragrance!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TaurusTaurus 12 years ago
Beautiful effort - you know exactly what you're getting into :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AavaAava 13 years ago
Absolutely, GPH I rocks ;))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MonsieurMonsieur 13 years ago
So more of a Cyber Punk vibe, but the cozier version...
Stay clean, Ms. Aava! ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AavaAava 13 years ago
Thanks, Baux! I'll take a screenshot of your praise then ;))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BauxBaux 13 years ago
I already suspected that the perfume has as much to do with punk as a savings plan. But at least we got such a great comment out of it.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AavaAava 13 years ago
Oh, Mrs. Gris, thank you :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AavaAava 13 years ago
... contributes to the resinous softness of the scent.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AavaAava 13 years ago
I'm glad to hear that :) Gurjum is a balm, sometimes also an oil, that is often used as a fixative in perfumery. It has a sweet, slightly spicy scent. In "Dreckig bleiben," I don't specifically pick it out, but I believe it contributes to...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeeroseSeerose 13 years ago
It's great to read one of your detailed comments! I always enjoy them! But please don't let me sound clueless: What is Gurjum? I've never read or heard of it before.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PaloneraPalonera 13 years ago
Sigh. I really wanted to stay clean for once. But you leave me no choice: now even the little dove is getting dirty. Great analysis and dissection - finally, a real Aava again!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 13 years ago
I'll stop by Lubner on Saturday and give it a test. Since I still have a well-filled bottle of Gucci, I can probably skip this one. Great, informative comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
UnterholzUnterholz 13 years ago
Very interesting comment, thanks! But punk and perfume just don’t go together at all. That’s why I’m not interested in the scent at all... it’s just another marketing gimmick by hipsters in my opinion...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DannyboyDannyboy 13 years ago
Well, I always found the whole fuss suspicious, and I've never really connected with "punk." That could mean I like the scent itself, but if you say it's "super resinous," I’d better steer clear. ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 13 years ago
So the Sex Pistols in a row house? Why not! Trophy with a bottle of beer!!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Mustang69Mustang69 13 years ago
A trophy for you and - zzzzisch! - a half beer to go with it. The true punk opens the bottle with their molars, but I’d rather use a lighter ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AavaAava 13 years ago
:))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0815abc0815abc 13 years ago
Also nice :) :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AavaAava 13 years ago
... didn't work for me with "stay dirty." Still, a great scent and also great marketing for it ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AavaAava 13 years ago
Thank you for the nice feedback :) @Jella: Our conversation about "staying dirty" really came through in the writing - thanks! @Lu: No one can market it differently for us, only we can. I wear a scent and make it my own. Exactly that...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TivellonTivellon 13 years ago
As always, a pleasure to read, and your scent impression was not overlooked either. Top-notch comment. Thanks and vase - Ti
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 13 years ago
Well, Louce, that's the dilemma. The only thing that could compete with it would be a personal scent. But do we really want that?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
LouceLouce 13 years ago
(...) it’s the same thing? This knot in my brain isn’t really untangled, but at least it’s loosened by your wonderful review. Thank you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
LouceLouce 13 years ago
How do you sell the same "individuality" to many, which is paradoxical? That's exactly the contradictory yet somehow brilliantly working concept of both mainstream and niche marketing. Can you really still be "different" (...)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
LilienfeldLilienfeld 13 years ago
They're getting on in years, the punks :)! What a fantastic comment!! I can smell the fragrance now, dear Mrs. Aava, the progression and ingredients are described so wonderfully :D.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
JifatJifat 13 years ago
Interesting to read. If the (supposed) individuality, the "being different," is limited to the label - and the content, hmm, is just a tired imitation of what the facade promises, then the project won't be successful.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KirthiKirthi 13 years ago
A really great comment, dear Aava!
Yes.. real punk is dying out..
This marketing stuff is getting on my nerves more and more.. but as Callas says, curiosity remains!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 13 years ago
I bow to your authentic statement, Ms. Aava!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
LabormausLabormaus 13 years ago
Very well written! Trophy :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AuraAura 13 years ago
Wow, thanks for this amazing, detailed, and super interesting comment! It was really great to read. I also think that if you're making a big deal out of something (especially when it's particularly cool and wild), there has to be something to back it up.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CallasCallas 13 years ago
The curiosity remains ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation