Log in

Mint & Tonic by Atkinsons

Mint & Tonic 2018

April22Bee
02/14/2021 - 03:58 AM
20
Top Review
7Scent 5Longevity 5Sillage 7Bottle 4Pricing

Divided...

I want to start by saying that I had high expectations for the fragrance and I come out of the test feeling divided after having a sample.

For me, this is absolutely not a unisex fragrance, but a pure men's scent.
If I classify it as a pure men's fragrance, I find it top-notch.
As a unisex scent, mint&tonic is, in my eyes, an absolute flop.

About the fragrance:
It is a very pulsating and invigorating scent, that much can be said, which at first spray, however, smells directly of aftershave and therefore is absolutely masculine.....

Once the initial alcohol has evaporated, fortunately, the notes of lime, mint, and citrus notes as well as mandarin come through, but they do not completely overshadow the first impression of the aftershave.

The problem: my nose, which clearly perceives aftershave, cannot quite reconcile the images in my head - namely, a glass of refreshing tonic water with a mint leaf does not quite match with the aftershave.

My expectations for "mint and tonic" were actually that I would get a nice unisex fragrance that smells like a popular long drink like gin&tonic or a mojito, radiating lightness, fun, sun, and beach, and that is completely gender-neutral in scent.

I also hoped for a somewhat more exciting aromatic profile from the fragrance notes.

The scent starts and remains rather masculine, which is why it is personally out for me, although the aftershave note disappears more and more over time, making the fragrance generally wearable for women if one has a bit of patience and likes it a bit more robust.
I do have some robust fragrances in my collection, like the yulong from Armani privee, but that one is truly unisex and delivers what it promises: tea.

Mint&tonic does deliver mint, but not in the way I had hoped.
It is suitable for really warm summer days, as the fragrance is very invigorating and refreshing.

I can definitely imagine the scent on a modern man; it is not intrusive but rather delicious, elegant, pulsating, attractive, interesting, and somehow also mysterious. If I smelled this fragrance on a man, I would say he has done everything right.

But on me as a woman, it is really disappointing. It fits zero. I really feel like I have picked the wrong perfume from the shelf.

I was also disappointed with the longevity. After 4 hours, I can't smell anything anymore.

For a fragrance in this price segment, that is a very weak performance, which does not justify the price.

For fans of long drinks, it might still be worth a sniff, but I strongly advise against a blind purchase.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
12 Comments
DasCroeDasCroe 5 months ago
I totally agree - I just thought "huh? unisex?" too!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
JackoJacko 3 years ago
Well described, I also remember the scent as rather masculine, but also a bit boringly fresh. A 7 is spot on.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CremanieCremanie 3 years ago
1
I tested the scent, and for me, only the top note smells bitter and fresh. After 30-60 minutes, everything fades away, and I only smell soft, sweet musk. I find it very soft and delicate on me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TradescantiaTradescantia 4 years ago
2
An informative comment. Enjoyed reading it.
Eau de Minthé by Diptyque might be worth a try. For me, it’s more of a mint candy scent, while for some, it has a tea aroma.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Brelles530Brelles530 4 years ago
Great comment, enjoyed reading it. Cheers to you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KnopfnaseKnopfnase 4 years ago
2
I bought it at the beginning of my time here. I like it already, but as you wrote, it’s more of a masculine scent for me too.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Medianus76Medianus76 4 years ago
It's always a shame when a fragrance doesn't meet the expectations you had for it. Still, your description and portrayal of the scent sound interesting... I'll keep it in mind... for the summer :))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MonsieurTestMonsieurTest 4 years ago
1
Well commented; I'm also in favor of unisex crossover uses!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldGold 4 years ago
3
As a woman, I really enjoy having a sip of this drink... - I know what you mean... - but for me, scents are neither specifically male nor female. It depends on socialization and what your brain associates. And I actually love wearing good "aftershave" myself, as it makes me feel comfortable... very much so!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FloydFloyd 4 years ago
4
That sounds wonderfully summery... and aren't gender assignments just smoke and mirrors?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SalvaSalva 4 years ago
Very well-written and informative comment that I enjoyed reading. The scent itself sounds nice, but I've also found that the fragrances from this brand usually perform poorly in longevity and sillage. I'll gladly leave a trophy there though ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ShakingShaking 4 years ago
2
I actually like the scent, especially because it has a shaving lotion note, not.
I would also say that it’s more for men than for women.
You described the scent very well, and if I didn’t know it, I’d get a pretty accurate impression.
Musk trophy :-D
Translated · Show originalShow translation