Iris Tubéreuse by Creed

Iris Tubéreuse 2014

Leimbacher
08/07/2014 - 03:09 AM
5
Helpful Review
5Scent 5Longevity 5Sillage 5Bottle

Good vs Evil

A disappointment with Asian Green Tea, a revelation with Geranium Vetiver - I was curious where the definitely most feminine fragrance of the new Acqua Originales, Iris Tuberose, would fit in.

But first, I was surprised that this is supposed to be the only fragrance in the world with these 2 flowers in the name - I could have sworn I had read about this combination in fragrance pyramids and smelled it in perfumes so many times that it couldn't be true - but our now almost omniscient database does not lie ;-) Moreover, there was excitement because I love Iris, but I mildly detest Tuberose, so a combination of both is like the battle of my fragrance titans, Good vs Evil. Unfortunately, in this case, the little devil Tuberose wins and makes the fragrance unbearable for me, let alone wearable, leaving the little angel Iris with no chance. Grrr how I hate you Tuberose...

Since the fragrance is not only super simple but also shockingly linear, I will keep my description brief. For 85% of the time, a airy Tuberose note dominates, which feels like anti-aspirin to me. Like a Bond No.9 Fire Island in a bad, simple, loud, annoying version. White flowers everywhere you look, and perhaps even a brighter ozone note that almost overshadows the fragrance with light and strength. And for a beach scent, it lacks that final kick - whether it would have been sand, salt, or sunscreen. So it is just a floral power and, if anything, more green than summery-sandy. Here, ladies first without exception - but I warned you!

Bottle: simple and pure, I suppose that was the intention.
Sillage: to me, Tuberose always seems more forced and annoying than it actually is.
Longevity: my fragrance nerves were strained for 5-6 hours.

I even briefly considered not commenting on this despite the test, as my initial test would not be very meaningful and rather off-putting - or if at all, only for perfume lovers like me who do not like Tuberose and other light flowers. Fans of the mentioned direction can surely raise the rating by 20-30%. Although I believe that even those, or especially those who know many Tuberoses, will find this a bit too dull and lacking... but I am curious about further opinions. For me, however, definitely the weakest Acqua Originale, though here it is with a warning and not with disappointment like with the Asian Green Tea.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
5 Comments
MarusyaMarusya 8 years ago
If you were a woman, you might have liked it better :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GoldieGoldie 10 years ago
I really like this scent: Especially from minute 20 to 60. After that, I unfortunately can't smell it at all. Such a shame. It could have been a candidate for purchase.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SuniSuni 10 years ago
I tested it today at 33 degrees - the top note is a green blast, and then a bright tuberose quickly makes an appearance, becoming soft and close to the skin. It strongly reminds me of "La Chasse aux Papillon Extreme." I really like the scent!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
HyazintheHyazinthe 10 years ago
I love iris, but unfortunately, I can't pick it up at all; everything is overwhelmed by the tuberose. You have to like that. For me, it feels more suited for a retirement home. Too bad, tuberose needs to be used sparingly; it ruins a lot.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Yuki68Yuki68 11 years ago
For me, the longevity would probably be off-putting. I love tuberose, but not necessarily iris... I can only tolerate Insolence very rarely and then only in homeopathic doses.
Translated · Show originalShow translation