Of course, I already know from the notes that I am not at home here at all, but that doesn't stop me from trying such fragrances, experiencing them, and being able to say something about them.
But let's start with the positives.
We have a very potent EDT here with considerable radiance and longevity, especially for the very prominent citrus ingredients.
At the same time, I see no character in this fragrance. It feels interchangeable, ubiquitous, and faceless. I can't imagine that if various citrus-vetiver fragrances were presented to me blind, I would be able to distinguish them specifically. Here it also shows that I have little to do with the subject of citrus shower gel scent.
About the scent:
There are bitter citrus notes that take on a fresh herbal undertone; spicy or resinous notes do not take the stage, only towards the end are they perceptible close to the skin.
Otherwise, a linear progression and no surprises.
Overall quite nice and pleasant, but for my nose, rather annoying.
To me, the scent feels like some kind of citrus grapefruit mix, with something that reminds me of algae. I hardly notice any wood, cinnamon, or tobacco here.
I also have the Wood Wood from I.M., which starts off terribly too, but at least the woody notes come in at the end... unfortunately, it’s very brief.
So I really can’t understand the praise for the designer in the comments here.
I also recently tried the new lavender scent from I.M.... it wasn’t any better either.
Just a little info that might be worth knowing: these very classic and, in my understanding, simple citrus or fresh scents are what kept me away from the art of fragrance for years because I find them exhausting. No matter how groundbreaking something might be, it’s just not for me, and that’s why I missed out on this art for so long.
Many of us can easily distinguish between the various citrus scents, and if you're a bit familiar with the subject, you appreciate l'Eau d'Issey as one of the finest yet most long-lasting freshies. It's no wonder it's been an enduring classic for decades.
I think your review could be written one-to-one for CK One by Calvin Klein; it's really bland and interchangeable.
You really hit the nail on the head, and I completely agree with you. The scent is truly special, and I look forward to wearing/smelling it every time.
Reviews should and can be subjective; that's what makes a place like this so vibrant. I think the headline is quite sensational and might deter someone who could unexpectedly discover a gem. Just a thought with a hint of concern.
I agree with you, and as I said, if you like the subject, you definitely perceive these scents differently. But to me, citrus-fresh or even aquatic-fresh just feels boring and monotonous.
It's clear that our tastes differ, which is why I added a corresponding introduction.
I also have the Wood Wood from I.M., which starts off terribly too, but at least the woody notes come in at the end... unfortunately, it’s very brief.
So I really can’t understand the praise for the designer in the comments here.
I also recently tried the new lavender scent from I.M.... it wasn’t any better either.
I think your review could be written one-to-one for CK One by Calvin Klein; it's really bland and interchangeable.
It's clear that our tastes differ, which is why I added a corresponding introduction.