Suddenly Woman I by Lidl

Suddenly Woman I

Morgaine
01/14/2015 - 08:22 AM
15
Top Review
4Scent

Half-Fat Margarine

After reading all the enthusiastic comments about Suddenly Woman and being a big fan of Chanel No 5 myself, I immediately rushed to Lidl to acquire this masterpiece of perfumery. I ended up putting two bottles in my shopping cart, because at this unbeatable price, you can't go wrong - or so I thought...

At home, I tore open the packaging with eager hands, pulled out the quite decent bottle, and sprayed it on with joyful anticipation. And then the disappointment! The top note vaguely reminds me of Chanel No 5, but what follows has only the faintest connection to it. The scent develops an unpleasant note on my skin, which comes off a bit stale and musty - I also miss the elegance of the original.
Sprayed both on my skin - Suddenly on the left, Chanel on the right, I can hardly recognize any similarities apart from a certain olfactory overlay.

For me, Suddenly Woman has as much in common with Chanel No 5 as half-fat margarine does with sweet cream butter - it is by no means a satisfactory substitute.
Maybe the creators of Suddenly ran out of supplies from the hijacked Chanel container and I had to settle for a homemade version ;-)

All of this is, however, my personal feeling and can, regardless of subjective perception, also be due to body chemistry, which has a significant influence on scent development. Unfortunately, it didn't work for me.

Those who find the scent to be a worthy Chanel substitute are lucky, because you can't get such a precious perfume any cheaper!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
10 Comments
CQuatermainCQuatermain 2 years ago
I had to laugh, well described, thank you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MorgaineMorgaine 2 years ago
It's nice that I made you laugh. :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Medusa00Medusa00 5 years ago
Well, at least you won't go broke from it, haha.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PaloneraPalonera 9 years ago
That's how it goes - we can never avoid a self-test, no matter how consistent the comments from the "pre-noses" may be. And it always comes down to our own perception. I couldn't connect with "Number 5" for many years, but who knows, maybe I've matured enough to appreciate the Grande Dame now and should give it another chance...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TooSmell27TooSmell27 11 years ago
But of course there's a difference. However, the Lidl dupe is really well done. The price-to-performance ratio is impressively good. I want to point that out as someone who openly doesn't love Chanel.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MorgaineMorgaine 11 years ago
Dear Snow Fairy, it must be due to body chemistry. There are worlds between Chanel and Lidl for me, but the Lidl scent lasts while my Chanel has already faded. What a strange world! :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchneeseefeeSchneeseefee 11 years ago
Oh, what a shame! The Lidl and Chanel scents develop differently for me too. But in the opposite way: Suddenly develops beautifully on me, while No 5 just doesn't work for me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MorgaineMorgaine 11 years ago
Dear ChaiTee, oh no, I'm not returning the scent - it's not that bad, especially considering the many expensive mistakes I've made that are now just sitting unused in my closet ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChaiTeeChaiTee 11 years ago
And you're right, this scent has something 'grand' or 'precious'. I don't know Chanel No. 5, but I also feel that the Lidl fragrance is a true 'ladies' scent. It's just silly that I'm not a lady - but sometimes I really like it too.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChaiTeeChaiTee 11 years ago
If it doesn't suit you at all, you can return it. Lidl is pretty flexible about that.
Translated · Show originalShow translation