Log in

Eleganza Luminosa by Linari

Eleganza Luminosa 2008

Meggi
05/15/2018 - 02:47 PM
23
Top Review
6.5Scent 8Longevity 7Sillage 10Bottle

Just an Evening Pareto Optimum

Orange with a nimm2 twist and a hint of cheesy bergamot. Along with a slightly musty canned fruit rustle. Apricot perhaps. Another trace could be the "peaches" from Haribo. In both cases, I find it hard to spontaneously connect to "elegance" or "radiant".

Furthermore, I cannot distinctly follow the promised botanical notes; I would have to somewhat cobble them together, so to speak, by considering the fruit as extracted from fruity rose, interpreting the sweetness as a hint of lily-of-the-valley heaviness, and ticking off jasmine. Not that I am particularly keen on wavering Blymeranz, but I would have expected a bit more than (for me) almost undetectable floral-fruity generalities. It reminds me of the lackluster generic fruit mush from 'Modern Classic for Women' by Brocard and 'The Collector - Morning Muscs' by Alexandre J - two unfortunately uninspiring references. I even find their hint of more or less cheap chocolate again today.

Over the course of several hours, it slowly becomes creamier; I initially smell primarily pasty sandalwood on the verge of H-cream, which is also not delightful. By noon, I gradually recognize a quiet duet of orange and amber that reminds me from afar of L'Artisan's 'Séville à l'Aube'. At least, as it carries me solidly through the afternoon, and by evening the fragrance manages to climb to a kind of "Pareto Optimum," as a musky creamy orange-jasmine-amber note develops downright sexy ambitions.

Pareto Optimum. A state in which, broadly speaking, it is no longer possible to improve something in a matter without simultaneously having to worsen something else. One of those thoughts and terms that typically arise in the realm of so-called economics and can often be sorted somewhere on a direct line between "practically useless" and "self-evident." Here, I just want to say: I believe the fragrance has reached its individual best; there's no more to be done.

The catch with the Pareto Optimum: This is often illustrated by the image of a hiker who has painstakingly climbed a mountain peak and now stands proudly at the top. Suddenly, the clouds part, the fog lifts, and before the eyes of the brave climber, the magnificent panorama of the Alps rises up. In relation to the more successful latter part of 'Eleganza Luminosa', the majestic peaks are concretely represented for me by the already mentioned 'Séville à l'Aube' as well as Pierre Guillaume's 'Parfumerie Générale - 19 Louanges Profanes'.

I thank MisterE for the sample.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
14 Comments
JumiJumi 7 years ago
I don't need to climb the summit. How does it even get a 6.5? o.O
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KleopatraKleopatra 7 years ago
Okay, I’d like just the Haribo peaches then (if RobGordon leaves some for me ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PlutoPluto 7 years ago
Thanks for the warning.....
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PaloneraPalonera 7 years ago
Look at that - a real Meggi bashing! You don't see those very often, ;-)!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777Can777 7 years ago
I don't think I could improve anything about the scent!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SeeroseSeerose 7 years ago
I found it boring and unfortunately too fruity for my perfume taste. And then to spend so much money on it. I didn't smell any flowers at all.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
RobGordonRobGordon 7 years ago
For me, just the Haribo peaches *nom nom* I only know one scent from Oelkers, but the jasmine shock is still fresh in my memory.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GelisGelis 7 years ago
Oh no! But definitely an elegant glowing trophy for your effort!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 7 years ago
What you always mean with bergamot and stinky feet, you'll have to explain to me sometime. I've never had that association. But it was really **lame** anyway!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AventurinAventurin 7 years ago
So for you as a tester, more pareto-inferior then? The "so-called," hehe. Pareto trophy.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GschpusiGschpusi 7 years ago
Hmm... I have stinky feet myself, haha.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SerenissimaSerenissima 7 years ago
It's still a shame that it's gone.
I remember that in a lecture, this Pareto optimum was represented as a column: 20% was the average performance; any shift upwards would have been considered a success by the boring lecturer.
I would have liked to test where the limit would be for this Linari fragrance.
Of course, there's a trophy for you again.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 7 years ago
I don't know that one yet, but it seems I haven't missed much. Although, H-Cream sounds tempting. ;))))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MisterEMisterE 7 years ago
That’s pretty much spot on. You can basically forget about the first 6 hours...
Translated · Show originalShow translation