Tabac Original Black Edition by Mäurer & Wirtz

Tabac Original Black Edition 2024

Axiomatic
10/05/2024 - 01:10 PM
53
Top Review
8.5Scent 8Longevity 6Sillage 10Bottle 10Pricing

A Right Turn!

Unexpected and all the more delightful is what Mäurer & Wirtz has now brought to the market.
Will the autumn of 2024 bring the required change in terms of fragrance composition?

Yes, here the house shows foresight and courage, offering something reconciliatory for all those who have not been able to stand sweet scents in recent years.

Bold, honest, and commendable, it is refreshing to name the components of this fragrance version outright.

And leaving nothing to chance regarding the design of the legendary bottle.

I must admit that my anticipation over the announcement of a dark version of the classic Tabac Original After Shave Lotion was dampened when our highly esteemed Parfumo Yatagan was disappointed by the high concentration of Iso-E-Super.

Well, this molecule can react differently on various skin types and thus alter the scent progression.
It may be that some have a diffuse, almost soft-focus-like association when smelling it.
Others, including myself, experience the scent more clearly, almost crystal clear in the woody area.

Out of curiosity, I opened both the bottle of Tabac Original After Shave Lotion and the Tabac Original Black Edition and first sniffed both dosing caps.

While the original smells as usual of aldehydes, woods, and warm amber, I do get a hint of the original scent in this version, but it is significantly lighter and darker-toned, more modern.

For mechanical reasons, there is this time a…

Shake and clap!

The beginning of the scent progression is surprisingly quiet; I can hardly perceive a scent at first, which is probably due to the synthetic nature.

But then the citrus opening slowly reveals itself, very gentle and also with green, herbaceous impressions. I assume that the declared cedar leaf is supposed to smell like this.
What is very pleasant is the initially sparse dosage of pepper, just barely noticeable.

It will take a while before the next stage of the fragrance becomes recognizable.
In general, the scent progression takes its time with all its facets.
More on that later.

The lavender is fresh and again greenish modulated; the molecule Clearwood works excellently here.
No sting, no overpowering, just a soft feeling.

Perhaps it is also this soft feeling of Iso-E-Super that Parfumo Yatagan criticizes.
Understandable if one expects a fragrance with clear contours.
But here I would like to point out that Tabac Original has always been soft. The softness and roundness are among its characteristics.
Therefore, it is only consistent to reach for Iso-E-Super to enable a rounded fragrance experience once again.

And before I know it, the heart of the original scent peeks out.
Yes, the house has meticulously ensured that tradition is incorporated within a contemporary context.
Warm woody, wonderfully ambried, and sprinkled with bright herbal notes, the old, now rejuvenated heart of the classic beats.

More than an hour will pass before the distinctive base takes over.
I call that molecular mastery!
Because suddenly everything becomes crystal clear.
Yes, the positive side of Iso-E-Super.
A strange freshness leads to the final stage.
Peppered, a comfortably dark lounge makes its presence known.
Aspects of leather, dark woods, and a grayish smoke define the zeitgeist of this version.

It is astonishing that everything remains light and airy here.
The successful contrasts of freshness and cozy wood feel invigorating.
I, at least, could smell it for hours and feel comfortable.
Because the impressions of the original merge with the new.

And as Profumo Ergoproxy says?
It comes down to the skillful use of new molecules.
Here I was taught otherwise.
Hats off!

Now to the bottle.
Certainly a milestone.
While the glass initially appears matte black, its optical property changes in backlight. Transparent, gray smoky, and elegant, the material now allows a glimpse inside the amphora.
If that isn't the most successful trick of the house.
An absolute eye-catcher and worthy of a beautiful place at home.

As for the longevity, I can confidently praise the continuous quality of the line. Just as the original aftershave provided long hours of scent, the dark version fits in perfectly here.
The scent will remain detectable for hours.
Although the projection is initially weak, sometimes close to the skin, unexpected scent clouds are generated that can certainly be perceived by those around.
Applied in the early evening, I could still smell the fragrance the next morning.
Subdued, yes, but still present.

And so I would like to summarize the character of the fragrance as follows.
Warm woody, ambried, peppery leathery, and cool smoky.

Coolness, minimalist elegance, passing the baton to the next generation.

Yes, I am convinced that the house has taken the right path.
Should Tabac Original Black Edition be limited, then hopefully as an attempt to adjust something traditional and thereby gain new followers. Perhaps to compose future works accordingly.

And I am optimistic that the experiment will succeed.

Thank you, Mäurer & Wirtz, this time you got it right!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
42 Comments
RumSkullyRumSkully 1 year ago
Once again, outstandingly written! I tested the masterpiece briefly and immediately bagged it. I also picked up the classic EDT while I was at it. With curiosity and a pioneering spirit, I’m stepping into the "Tabac" club... there’s a first time for everything.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Babylon84Babylon84 1 year ago
I'm really excited! Thanks for the great review..
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PlutoPluto 1 year ago
1
Now I'm curious. But not for the aftershave, 🫠 then please EDT.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ExUserExUser 1 year ago
1
Again wonderfully described, it really makes me curious!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
StulleStulle 1 year ago
The bottle is absolutely sensational! I love the scent right away because it doesn't stray too far from the original. I'll give another verdict after some thorough testing.
So, now I'm off to shave :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchoeibksrSchoeibksr 1 year ago
Sorry for the delay, my dear!
I've always meant to read your review thoroughly but never got around to it. I'm a bit less active here.
Yes, I wasn't really impressed by Yatagan, so your positive review surprised me even more!
It's true, Tabac O. has always been a soft, warm-spicy classic.
Iso-E-Super is well used; it's not a bad ingredient, for sure!!
Great, detailed as always, and nice to see you have another good M&W with you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PurpurherzPurpurherz 1 year ago
If I had a beard, I would try the aftershave right now. But without a beard (thankfully 🤭), I have to pass, because my husband is a dedicated sprayer 🤷🏻‍♀️
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IntensoIntenso 1 year ago
Sounds quite exciting, will give it a try.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TradescantiaTradescantia 1 year ago
I'm glad the scent provided you with a pleasant experience. I usually perceive ISO-E as an enhancer of the other notes, and as long as the original perfume is still recognizable, the variation is just a nice addition.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Medianus76Medianus76 1 year ago
Your description and helpful words sound really promising, so I’ll definitely take a closer look at it now! Enjoyed reading...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DuftmolekülDuftmolekül 1 year ago
I thought I could skip this one. Based on your positive description, I hope I can still get this edition to test in Austria.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KovexKovex 1 year ago
Alright, alright, I’ll give it a try after all. I can't resist your enthusiasm.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChrisG86ChrisG86 1 year ago
I enjoyed reading this very much and with enthusiasm. Tabac is also a loyal companion of mine. I'm looking forward to the black version. Where can I buy it? I haven't seen it at Rossmann yet.
Your review definitely made me want to try the scent. 👌 Best regards!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Aramis007Aramis007 1 year ago
The Black Edition is only available exclusively at DM, while "Extra Strong" is only available exclusively at Rossmann!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Helena1411Helena1411 1 year ago
Exciting, your scent journey into the dark realms of the tobacco trade. Unfortunately, I’m one of those who can’t perceive ISO E Super at all. So, the scent progression will probably be quite different for me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
CfrCfr 1 year ago
The grandpa must have stayed ☺️
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChrisCacaoChrisCacao 1 year ago
Like a phoenix from the ashes! This one is definitely going on my "sniff list."
Translated · Show originalShow translation
NeonNoirNeonNoir 1 year ago
That's why I stick to my motto: it's the dose that makes the poison, and I've never been particularly bothered by synthetic notes when they're well blended. No matter what the helper molecule is called in the end. Enjoyed reading this, and thanks for the detailed analysis. I'll think of you the next time I catch a whiff and give it a sniff. ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
NuiWhakakoreNuiWhakakore 1 year ago
I haven't found the positive side of Iso-E yet, but maybe I'll find it here? Let's see, it sounds at least promising, although I do have a note: Spill and gossip! Really, next time please keep it quiet...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KreisquadratKreisquadrat 1 year ago
Your words create excitement for me. So many details and thoroughly precise. I'm curious and really looking forward to testing this one.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 1 year ago
Well, that sounds reconciliatory. As you know, I use a safety razor, but I don't use aftershave. I just can't handle it and don't like the burning sensation on my skin. I'm curious about a test, though. Since I can't perceive ISO-E Super, I won't be bothered by it. 😁
Translated · Show originalShow translation
BosworthBosworth 1 year ago
This sounds really worth trying.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Flakon11eFlakon11e 1 year ago
1
Wonderful, heartwarming review!
Sometimes it's a blessing that fragrances can develop differently on each skin...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PonticusPonticus 1 year ago
We were promised an autumn of decisions, and this new release fits right in! I'm convinced about the quality, the bottle, and the brand, but the original perfume just isn't for me, and I don't use aftershave! I'll definitely give it a sniff and I'm sure I won't be disappointed! A very nice endorsement for the product! Great!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ParmaParma 1 year ago
1
Now you've made me curious about it! With two such different reviews (Yatagans and yours), I'm excited to see how I perceive it. Thank you for the detailed scent description and your assessment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SpatzlSpatzl 1 year ago
Alright, you’ve convinced me. I’ll give it a try next chance I get.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MarieposaMarieposa 1 year ago
1
It seems to me that someone has found the perfect gossip-and-chit-chat for this fall 😊
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Tony1106Tony1106 1 year ago
Back in Black......!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GandixGandix 1 year ago
There's something for everyone... Mine isn't ISO either... I don't really smell it at first, but eventually I find the scent annoying. But it's nice that you like it.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MuckiMangoMuckiMango 1 year ago
Wow, that sounds really exciting! I have to try it out on my next trip to the drugstore!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ScentwolfScentwolf 1 year ago
I'm approaching this completely open-minded.
Possibly a nice addition to the original.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DuftJunkieDuftJunkie 1 year ago
Oh dear 🤔. I guess I'll have to take another look at it 🙂.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 1 year ago
2
I really can't follow you here; I feel quite generous giving this rather synthetic scent my 6 points. 🧐 It's due to my old love for Tabac. 😅
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KäseKäse 1 year ago
@Yatagan @Axiomatic
I want to see you fight
I want to see you fight
I want, I want, I want
to see you fight
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DuftgroupieDuftgroupie 1 year ago
1
I hope it's not "too limited" and that I can get my hands on it 🙏
So far, I've had positive experiences with Iso-E-Super: usually transparent & woody.
🏆
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Paloma58Paloma58 1 year ago
1
Very enticing description. Hats off!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 1 year ago
1
I've also come to love ISO, but it took a little while. And when perfumers use the ingredient skillfully, the result can be very beautiful.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchatzSucherSchatzSucher 1 year ago
Alright, I'll test it if I come across it.
But since I don't use aftershave, it probably won't be a candidate for purchase. I wonder why they didn't release an EdC or EdT as well 🤔
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KokusaiKokusai 1 year ago
1
Ohhh now I'm even more curious than before.
I guess I'll be shaving daily so I don't miss out on the enjoyment 😅
Really enjoyed reading this!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PETPET 1 year ago
Now I'm also veering back to the big shelf to test this one. Thanks for the introduction! It seems there’s still hope!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ElAttarineElAttarine 1 year ago
Not my area, but still enjoyed reading it!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777Can777 1 year ago
1
I'll trust you and will... shake and gossip! ...give it a try! 🤭😂
Translated · Show originalShow translation