ParfumAholic
11/12/2015 - 08:43 AM
48
Top Review
8Scent 8Longevity 7Sillage 8Bottle

Just another powdery iris lipstick accord fragrance?

During my vacation, I also spent a few days with my parents. Whenever we have the chance, my mother and I take these opportunities to simply go on a shopping spree. So, we did this time as well. Of course, our path led us to "Douglas," as my mother urgently needed a new lipstick. It should be "something between pink (not too pink) and definitely not bright red." All clear? Not for me, at least. Well, lipsticks are just not my domain ;-)
Anyway, there was an older couple standing next to us, both around 60, very well-groomed and with an absolutely positive aura. The lady was also looking for a new lipstick (is it contagious?), and the saleswoman was eager to sell her a bright red one from Dior, claiming it would be a great contrast to her white hair. The lady didn't seem very satisfied, and her husband also appeared less than enthusiastic. And then he said a sentence that I probably won't forget anytime soon because it came straight from the heart: "Erika, please take a pink lipstick again, because that's how I got to know you, and that was the moment I knew you would be the woman of my life." Needless to say, she then chose a rose-colored lipstick (my mom did too, by the way).

What does this have to do with "Replica - Lipstick On" by Maison Martin Margiela? At first glance, nothing, but what ultimately connects them, I will reveal later.

"Replica - Lipstick On" by Maison Martin Margiela had been on my wishlist for a long time (the terms "Lipstick" and "Iris-Concrete" had done their job), before my curiosity could be satisfied through a sharing.

"Replica - Lipstick On" starts pleasantly and subtly vanilla (Heliotrope) fresh (Neroli), but one should not expect a freshness kick here. It is more of a hint of fresh and slightly citrusy vanilla. However, even in this early phase of the fragrance, the first but clear signs of iris and the infamous lipstick accord appear. I like it, that much is already clear.

The iris impression now increasingly intensifies, becoming more tangible without acting like a fragrance bulldozer. Fine vanilla wafts (bright and sensual) embrace the iris, which completely avoids any metallic or androgynous attitudes, and together they form a powdery scent veil of the highest class. Tonka bean and patchouli subtly blend into this mélange without making it sticky or overly sweet. I would describe this as a mature sweetness.
A slight (minimal!) "bitterness" that is permanently present from the heart note (which I don't know who or what contributes to) also prevents the fragrance from becoming too sweet and cloying.

From here on, "Replica - Lipstick On" does not change significantly (for me). The powdery lipstick accord lies softly on my skin and rekindles anew through body warmth.

"Replica - Lipstick On" is undoubtedly a powdery iris fragrance, yet it is not or only conditionally comparable to Dior's "Homme Intense" or "1889 - Moulin Rouge" by Histoires de Parfums, as "Replica - Lipstick On" presents itself much more restrained and introverted.
The most fitting comparison in terms of scent character would be Chanel's "Misia," only that "Replica - Lipstick On" proves to have significantly more staying power (for me). Therefore, I wouldn't simply dismiss it as just another powder fragrance, but rather grant it its own place in this segment.

"Replica - Lipstick On" is, in my view, a mature, timeless, and unpretentious fragrance that, despite its "sweetness" and powderiness, displays a charming seriousness. A fragrance that does not disguise but rather dresses, a fragrance that flatters its wearer, a fragrance that appears natural rather than forced, a fragrance that provides a sense of well-being.
The simple shape of the bottle, the rather sober label, and the color of the fragrance (not girlie pink, but a mature rose between pink and red) further emphasize these impressions.

"Replica - Lipstick On" is therefore, in my view, an absolute test recommendation for all (female and male) iris and lipstick accord fans who like it powdery, but not overly so.

And to return to my introduction, the riddle is now solved: "Replica - Lipstick On" feels mature, confident, and loving, just like the touching couple who were looking for a lipstick but seemed to have already found the most important thing in life.....
Translated · Show originalShow translation
22 Comments
SetaSeta 6 years ago
1
What a lovely comment! I perceive the scent in the top notes just like you do. The absence of metallic notes sets it apart from other 'lipstick' fragrances. Unfortunately, I find the subsequent sweet coumarin note too dominant, which is a shame!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Escada1970Escada1970 10 years ago
I also love that mature rosé... and you wrote that beautifully again!!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TivellonTivellon 10 years ago
That's a lovely story, Mario!
And on top of that, it's described appreciatively and aptly. (O:
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ChypienneChypienne 10 years ago
Just read this today :-( How could that happen?? This seems like an interesting scent for me as an iris-lipstick lover. A lovely, intriguing comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MargamotteMargamotte 10 years ago
Very nice comment about a fragrance that has now made it onto my already packed wishlist. Finding the right lipstick is really not easy!! ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DobbsDobbs 10 years ago
Even though you've written another masterful teaser comment here, my wishlist remains unchanged - I'm out when it comes to lipstick in fragrance.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PaloneraPalonera 10 years ago
*kisskisskisskisskiss*-trophy - and it lasts and lasts and lasts, ;-). I'm also a lipstick fetishist, not just in fragrance - everything from nude shades to the rose palette to Paloma Picasso red and even darker is included, ;-).
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GerdiGerdi 10 years ago
Oh, I still don't understand what a lipstick scent is supposed to be... Every cosmetics company has its own fragrances. Some smell terrible, others are just okay, but only a few skip the scent altogether-those are my favorites!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ShamisShamis 10 years ago
Beautiful comment with a truly fabulous closing word! :-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ErgoproxyErgoproxy 10 years ago
Yes, pink lipstick, my mom wears that too. :))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
AmandanAmandan 10 years ago
Another wonderful comment from you! Even though I didn't really want to add anything to my wishlist anymore, I'm weak here ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FlirtyFlowerFlirtyFlower 10 years ago
That's beautifully written! I think I'll buy some pink lipstick ;) Sounds like a great scent with neroli - completely free of musk and amber... Trophy+ and wishlist
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KleopatraKleopatra 10 years ago
This scent was already on my wishlist, and thanks to your great comment, I'm even more eager to try it! I just have to like it. And I love lipsticks! It's not easy at all to find the perfect shade.. ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SonnenfeeSonnenfee 10 years ago
I've always felt comfortable with pink lipstick, and I'll definitely test this fragrance when I get the chance! :))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
IngerInger 10 years ago
I enjoyed reading this very much - and as a lipstick lover, I'm quite susceptible to such fragrances - so I'll definitely add it to my wishlist! Best regards!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
HasiHasi 10 years ago
Great comment on a fragrance that I now want to test, because Malle's lipstick was just toooo powdery for me. :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ZoraZora 10 years ago
What a wonderful comment. But just like with fragrances, I love lipsticks that are bold and kiss-proof :).

This one might be a bit too weak for me.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GaukeleyaGaukeleya 10 years ago
Delicious anecdote! :-D I admit I'm a lipstick fan (not too dark or bluish, but also not nude, and pink isn't my thing either-more like rosewood or coral). And the scent: definitely going on my wishlist, pronto! ;-)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PlutoPluto 10 years ago
Very nice comment. So far, I’m not quite sure what a lipstick accord is, but when I tested Paris recently, I thought that might be the lipstick note. And this fragrance is going on my wishlist.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
KatnissKatniss 10 years ago
1. Comment from you!!! Thanks. I'll order it blindly. I can rely on you. I knew it would be like this..
Thanks a lot!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
DaveGahan101DaveGahan101 10 years ago
I think the Replica series is really good, including Lazy Sunday!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GschpusiGschpusi 10 years ago
Nice comment and a rosé trophy!
Translated · Show originalShow translation