Iris Bleu Gris Maître Parfumeur et Gantier 1988
27
Top Review
Not powdery and very masculine: the anti-"Dior Homme"
Rarely, but more often than one might think, a fragrance gains from a reformulation made for whatever reason.
This is the case with “Iris Bleu Gris.”
Sure, the scent was already quite successful before (in the 90ml bottles): earthy, buttery, and floral at its heart, firmly standing in the tradition of Iris Pallida, with a strong, masculine base that reminded one of the great leather chypres of the late 70s and early 80s - Jean François Laporte knew his craft. But “Iris Bleu Gris” was also rather large in scale, quite voluminous, and comparatively loud.
The current version, on the other hand, is much more moderate, as if the mixing console had been adjusted to set all the tracks, both bass and treble, into new, more palatable relations for today’s needs.
The result is astonishing: The same song clearly plays, only quieter, less booming, with subdued basses and brighter highs. But anyone thinking that the result is likely to be shorter-lived is mistaken. “Iris Bleu Gris” is still a marathon runner in terms of longevity, just more discreet in its presence, revealing a sophistication that I hadn’t perceived before.
The current edition of the fragrance begins with a much fresher opening, characterized by citrus and grassy notes. However, beneath this, the powerful iris root accord soon unfolds with its buttery-earthy (the root: “Gris”), but also floral (the flower: “Bleu”) nuances, which bear certain similarities to the scent of violets, combined with the grassy-green moments of the violet leaf. The typical powderiness found in many iris fragrances is hardly detectable, which may certainly irritate some who appreciate these scents for that very reason.
But the concept of this work was likely to create a fragrance around the dark, sometimes almost woody aspects of the iris root to highlight its masculine side. If one had wanted to emphasize the powderiness, surely heliotropin, reminiscent of vanilla and almonds, would have been used, which would have quickly brought the fragrance closer to classics like Guerlain’s “Après l´ondée” or “Mouchoir de Monsieur” - scents that are over 80 years old and were anything but modern at the time of “Iris Bleu Gris” (twenty years later, “Dior Homme” revisited the powdery iris theme and was able to position it as a supposedly “brand new” novelty, which it really wasn’t).
“Iris Bleu Gris” is now a child of its time, and back then, they liked to experiment with leathery chypre bases, which often contained a bit of castoreum - an animalistic twist was a must back then, in the exceedingly hedonistic 80s.
Today, of course, all of this seems terribly outdated and old-fashioned, but somehow I feel about “Iris Bleu Gris” like an old acquaintance whom I haven’t seen in a long time and, deep down, didn’t really want to see - familiar faces can sometimes remind one too much of repressed excesses... But now, standing before him, I am unexpectedly joyfully surprised and amazed at how well he has held up, this acquaintance. How familiar he still is, and - in the case of “Iris Bleu Gris” - how delicately he presents himself: No shoulder pads, no overly loud behavior, instead a somewhat aged, elegant contemporary, whose age is quite apparent, yet still appears rejuvenated, slimmer, fitter, somehow more refined than in my own memory.
I feel similarly about today’s “Iris Bleu Gris” (now in 100ml bottles): it still convinces me, and I am indeed unusually glad for the careful reformulation, which was evidently made in respect for the quality of the old Laporte work.
For those seeking a dry, non-powdery iris scent, and who find, for example, “L´Homme de Coeur” too austere, this old Laporte fragrance is recommended. However, one should also be able to tolerate the leathery chypre base of, let’s say, “Van Cleef & Arpels pour Homme,” as it is certainly present, albeit much softer and tamer.
A great fragrance!
This is the case with “Iris Bleu Gris.”
Sure, the scent was already quite successful before (in the 90ml bottles): earthy, buttery, and floral at its heart, firmly standing in the tradition of Iris Pallida, with a strong, masculine base that reminded one of the great leather chypres of the late 70s and early 80s - Jean François Laporte knew his craft. But “Iris Bleu Gris” was also rather large in scale, quite voluminous, and comparatively loud.
The current version, on the other hand, is much more moderate, as if the mixing console had been adjusted to set all the tracks, both bass and treble, into new, more palatable relations for today’s needs.
The result is astonishing: The same song clearly plays, only quieter, less booming, with subdued basses and brighter highs. But anyone thinking that the result is likely to be shorter-lived is mistaken. “Iris Bleu Gris” is still a marathon runner in terms of longevity, just more discreet in its presence, revealing a sophistication that I hadn’t perceived before.
The current edition of the fragrance begins with a much fresher opening, characterized by citrus and grassy notes. However, beneath this, the powerful iris root accord soon unfolds with its buttery-earthy (the root: “Gris”), but also floral (the flower: “Bleu”) nuances, which bear certain similarities to the scent of violets, combined with the grassy-green moments of the violet leaf. The typical powderiness found in many iris fragrances is hardly detectable, which may certainly irritate some who appreciate these scents for that very reason.
But the concept of this work was likely to create a fragrance around the dark, sometimes almost woody aspects of the iris root to highlight its masculine side. If one had wanted to emphasize the powderiness, surely heliotropin, reminiscent of vanilla and almonds, would have been used, which would have quickly brought the fragrance closer to classics like Guerlain’s “Après l´ondée” or “Mouchoir de Monsieur” - scents that are over 80 years old and were anything but modern at the time of “Iris Bleu Gris” (twenty years later, “Dior Homme” revisited the powdery iris theme and was able to position it as a supposedly “brand new” novelty, which it really wasn’t).
“Iris Bleu Gris” is now a child of its time, and back then, they liked to experiment with leathery chypre bases, which often contained a bit of castoreum - an animalistic twist was a must back then, in the exceedingly hedonistic 80s.
Today, of course, all of this seems terribly outdated and old-fashioned, but somehow I feel about “Iris Bleu Gris” like an old acquaintance whom I haven’t seen in a long time and, deep down, didn’t really want to see - familiar faces can sometimes remind one too much of repressed excesses... But now, standing before him, I am unexpectedly joyfully surprised and amazed at how well he has held up, this acquaintance. How familiar he still is, and - in the case of “Iris Bleu Gris” - how delicately he presents himself: No shoulder pads, no overly loud behavior, instead a somewhat aged, elegant contemporary, whose age is quite apparent, yet still appears rejuvenated, slimmer, fitter, somehow more refined than in my own memory.
I feel similarly about today’s “Iris Bleu Gris” (now in 100ml bottles): it still convinces me, and I am indeed unusually glad for the careful reformulation, which was evidently made in respect for the quality of the old Laporte work.
For those seeking a dry, non-powdery iris scent, and who find, for example, “L´Homme de Coeur” too austere, this old Laporte fragrance is recommended. However, one should also be able to tolerate the leathery chypre base of, let’s say, “Van Cleef & Arpels pour Homme,” as it is certainly present, albeit much softer and tamer.
A great fragrance!
Translated · Show original
12 Comments
Gandix 13 days ago
I was really glad to find your review because I recognized the scent in it.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Intersport 3 years ago
2
With the Maitre versions and reformulations, opinions really differ for me, and I feel similarly about yours. The old 100ml version is fantastic!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Hirondelle 7 years ago
1
Very good description, thank you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Unterholz 11 years ago
1
I have to test it again after your great comment. I think I was biased on my first try. But I've really come to appreciate these "old houses" in the meantime. And: Such classics often get old much less quickly than a lot of new stuff.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Yatagan 12 years ago
1
After getting a sample, I have to completely agree with you. Very good description of a highly interesting fragrance.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Profumo 12 years ago
1
@Rivegauche - There is indeed a certain similarity to Bois d'Iris (the central Iris Pallida), but the scent of TDC is brighter and more concentrated. IBG, on the other hand, is darker, broader, and evolves more.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Profumo 12 years ago
@Yatagan - Yes, IBG is really quite different from DH: there's no, or hardly any, powder, and the famous lipstick accord from DH is completely missing. IBG is more classic, less trendy.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Rivegauche 12 years ago
Oh great, I don't know that one yet. If you keep writing excellent comments as always, others' wish lists will get longer. Buttery iris makes me think of TDC Bois d'Iris, with a hint of Van Cleef & Arpels p.H?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Yatagan 12 years ago
Convincing argument. I should definitely give it a try. I was worried it would fall into the Dior Homme category, which I really don't like. But an anti-Dior Homme...?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
NightFighter 12 years ago
Could miracles still happen, in the form of a successful reformulation?! :-) Thanks!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Profumo 12 years ago
Yeah, yeah... :) I just find the Divine a bit harsh, but it's still good, really good even!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Dannyboy 12 years ago
So so... :D A few years ago, I found it strangely fascinating but absolutely unbearable. Time for a reunion, it seems. But the Divine isn't that harsh! Tsk tsk... ;)
Translated · Show originalShow translation

