9
Top Review
The Little Brother of Tuscan Leather - No 2
After the shock of testing Black Aoud, I dared to try a Montale fragrance again, and from the very first second, I thought, wow, this is Tom Ford's Tuscan Leather, perhaps not quite as brutally smoky, but the opening and the further development are so similar that I have to call this a fragrance twin. The longevity may not be quite as high as TF Tuscan Leather, which often blooms again after a shower, but the price is also not that far above the pain threshold like with Tuscan Leather. The fact that it comes across a bit softer than TFTL is not so bad; not everyone needs the black knight's glove full on their olfactory organ. Compared to TFTL, it's almost a bargain price-wise, and I find the leather theme perfectly implemented and wonder about the rather modest rating so far. There is still room for improvement. By far not as overdone and artificial as Black Aoud. I was already afraid that Montale only offers those oriental chemical sledgehammers.
Tom Ford's Tuscan Leather is still a bit better, but Aoud Leather is very close.
So test it and see for yourself.
Tom Ford's Tuscan Leather is still a bit better, but Aoud Leather is very close.
So test it and see for yourself.
Translated · Show original
3 Comments
ILTIS 12 years ago
I find the very smoky leather note of TFTL quite unusual; for me, it's not just a simple leather note. The leather note is interpreted very differently in many perfumes, like in Knize Ten or Antaeus. There isn't just ONE leather oil.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
ILTIS 12 years ago
Too bad, but not every nose works the same way. I still find the two perfumes very similar; I tested them side by side again right after your "nice" critical comment, and I stand by it-these two are scent twins!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
TrollMan 12 years ago
Nice comment, but I really can't see the comparison to Tuscan Leather, sorry. To my nose, those are two completely different scents that only share the leather theme.
Translated · Show originalShow translation

