Log in

Create Account Forgot your Password?
Von Sierstorpff - The Scent of a Gentleman by Von Sierstorpff

Von Sierstorpff - The Scent of a Gentleman 2008

Mörderbiene
06/04/2020 - 06:57 AM
18
Top Review
9Scent 7Longevity 6Sillage 8Bottle

A Question of Style? / The End of the Good Patriarch

In 1991, a traditional company presented what it considered the best automobile in the world. A product of nearly a decade of German engineering. Its creators accounted for everything, but surely not for mockery. Every little detail was meticulously examined for improvement possibilities and implemented without regard for anything other than technical feasibility. Everything was meant to be perfect, reliable, comfortable. Perhaps they were too preoccupied with themselves back then and lost sight of what was happening in the world outside. That Kohl and his associates could no longer travel to Sylt by car train was merely a noted shortcoming. Too big, too much, too elitist. An automotive stronghold against the spirit of the times, a product of obsession with detail and the loss of the sense of the big picture.
The Sifftopf and its marketing reveal similar tendencies. They wanted too much.
A fragrance whose perfection in detail has an almost meticulous, technical quality. The classic Cologne opening improved with a juicy mandarin that softens the lemon and gives fullness to the neroli and bergamot. Eucalyptus and cardamom deepen the cooling mintiness of the geranium and soften the dustiness and sharpness of nutmeg and allspice. Dark wood for more weight, silvery smoke for ethereal volume, and tobacco for a warm counterpoint and a touch of sweetness. Perfect in detail, perhaps just an overly thick Cologne from the outside. An olfactory interpretation of engineering?
The intention: They wanted to create a fragrance for the elite. And they accounted for everything, but surely not for mockery. Too aloof, too elitist, too contrived, an olfactory stronghold against the spirit of the times, a product of megalomania.
The thick star has not existed for over 20 years now; the trade press wrote back then upon its discontinuation: "[It] was always better than its reputation. We already miss the thick one."
Whispering, the giant glides over the asphalt, so gentle, so secure, so self-assured, so sovereign, as if it has decoupled itself from this world. Silly decadence? Today, it is a cult, albeit with a significant time lag compared to the contemporary, charmingly imperfect equivalents from the south and the island. Quirky, one would now say, with a smile on their lips. It has found its way into the hearts of the people.
The Sifftopf has now also disappeared. Both were misunderstood, yet of the best quality. Perhaps one day, looking back through rose-colored glasses, people will speak similarly of it. And respect its demeanor as charming quirks. Just as is common with the equivalents from the south and the island.

I appreciate both - the thick one and the Sifftopf. And I don’t care about the image conveyed. The marketing folks should have done the same.
Updated on 06/04/2020
Translated · Show originalShow translation
15 Comments
KonsalikKonsalik 6 years ago
1
Interesting. Spee's destruction had already set me somewhat in the right direction. But most people only really shine retrospectively from the grave anyway. I wouldn't ignore a sample in the future if it crossed my path. ^^
Translated · Show originalShow translation
StanzeStanze 6 years ago
2
That's a matter of opinion. I'm not familiar with the scent. I don't know which Mercedes it is. My father was from Wolfsburg. My French quasi-father worked at Citroen. I've also had Ducks and Polos. ;) Is the scent still available for purchase?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PaloneraPalonera 6 years ago
Unfortunately, I missed out on the scent when it was still available - the last I "heard" about it was that a friend found it at a bargain price in some niche perfumery. It seemed to me that it didn't really deserve that.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
UnterholzUnterholz 6 years ago
5 BIG stars for this comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Melisse2Melisse2 6 years ago
1
Perfection makes me curious; I don't care about the image or the megalomania.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Helena1411Helena1411 6 years ago
Scented trophy for a top-notch, interesting, and highly entertaining comparative comment.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FloydFloyd 6 years ago
1
The ingredients sound pretty good. Nice comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
YataganYatagan 6 years ago
I'll give it another chance. It didn't convince me before, but there should still be a sample of it lying around. So, here we go again!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
NightFighterNightFighter 6 years ago
1
I gladly agree with that. I think time will prove it.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FvSpeeFvSpee 6 years ago
Well, let's raise a stinky pot to our complementary viewpoints! But enlighten me, almost clueless about cars, who is the big guy (besides the chancellor) and what are the southern and insular equivalents?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
SchatzSucherSchatzSucher 6 years ago
Highfalutin marketing and bravado make me a bit stubborn. What I've read so far in reviews about the scent and the brand confirms my stubbornness ;-) If they don't want everyone as a customer, then so be it. Great and well-done discussion from you!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
FittleworthFittleworth 6 years ago
2
Interesting comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
GschpusiGschpusi 6 years ago
I'm with you on that. Great comment!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
PollitaPollita 6 years ago
The scent seems to be liked according to your review. And yet a harsh critique? Enlighten me, I don't know the fragrance.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MonsieurTestMonsieurTest 6 years ago
Extremely original and insightful comparison slide. I'm unsure whether to call my trophy an S-Class trophy or just a **Sifftopf**...
**Sifftopf** is quite a biting typo, isn't it? Were those strangers so decadent that they deserve it?
Translated · Show originalShow translation