I'll share my personal opinion, even if some might disagree. For me, Sweet Tobacco is the worst Naxos copy I've come across so far.
Disclaimer: I'm not one of the Naxos worshippers, just so that's clear.
The question is whether it should be a copy.
I haven't made a comparison myself. But it's good that you mentioned it!
If someone is looking for a "cheaper" alternative to "Naxos," they should (after some research) try the Sweet Tobacco first to avoid disappointment.
I let this one speak for itself, independent of any comparisons. But I can understand your opinion. If I had something comparable on my shelf, this one would probably have failed too. It's not bad, but for me, it's really just a bit too sweet...
*** beautifully rounded composition. But it's too sweet for me. A bit more bitterness would have suited me better personally. Here, "Naxos" is mentioned for comparison. I could compare it thanks to @StenLaurel, but I won’t because I wanted to evaluate it independently. I was just curious about what my nose had to say.
However, Naxos was a bit too much for me.
Disclaimer: I'm not one of the Naxos worshippers, just so that's clear.
I haven't made a comparison myself. But it's good that you mentioned it!
If someone is looking for a "cheaper" alternative to "Naxos," they should (after some research) try the Sweet Tobacco first to avoid disappointment.
I'm sure you'll break it down ☺️
A really lovely scent, just a tiny bit too sweet for "my personal" taste...
Here, "Naxos" is mentioned for comparison. I could compare it thanks to @StenLaurel, but I won’t because I wanted to evaluate it independently. I was just curious about what my nose had to say.