I tested the fragrance extensively for 2 days. The title sounds significantly more derogatory than my conclusion actually is, but the only thing that bothers me about an otherwise really successful replica is a rather penetrating alcohol note, at least for my nose. I have the original to compare it with. A comparison:
The CC BA feels like a warm embrace that wraps around you, gently laying itself on your skin like cashmere, and whenever you catch a little whiff of it, it speaks to you and says: “I cost a sinful amount, can you smell that? Yes, you can smell that! But you still love me because I simply smell fantastic!”… It’s right!
Now the same scenario with the Art of Arabia 3:
The AoA3, in comparison, does not feel like a warm embrace, but rather like a friendly elbow from a buddy who just embarrassed you in front of a crowd 5 seconds ago. It’s not cashmere, but rather somewhat worn-out cotton, WITHOUT fabric softener. The noticeable breeze whispers: “Look, I’m at least as intense as the expensive stuff! What? A bit boozy? Yeah, I spilled the grain earlier. Not a big deal, don’t be so dramatic, it will fade.”… and that in the gruff tone of a Berlin ticket inspector.
For almost €400 price difference, it’s completely okay; the price of BA doesn’t come from nowhere. But for those with a not-so-bulging wallet, the AoA3 is a totally legitimate alternative.
It lasts long enough, is nearly indistinguishable for 98% of noses, and will still earn a compliment or two. Clear recommendation to buy!
Great review! However, I have to disagree: I don't really get "alcohol" here, unlike many other cheapies and also with many Lattafas. I actually find it quite rounded; I agree that especially in the first 1-2 hours, you hardly notice a difference as an outsider, but it definitely lacks the complexity and just the quality of naturals towards the end :)
That's where the wheat separates from the chaff. Whether these differences justify a €400 price difference is another story. But 99% of testers would choose the original in a blind test. And that's where the magic lies.
If you didn't shorten the names of the fragrances, your thoughts would be easier to read. Not every reader here knows every scent, so it turns reading into a guessing game and makes it quite tedious.
CC BA = Clive Christian "Blonde Amber"
AoA3 = Art of Arabia 3