19
Top Review
Hansel and Gretel…
…got lost in the woods. But when it comes to Tellus, there’s really no talk of "getting lost." Rather, a few other things slowly pass by a rather stationary center, and it only has to do with trees at the lower edge.
It opens with an earthy-sweet start, immediately accompanied by a stinky bite. The patchouli note seems to glow quickly. I detect a hint of cinnamon sweetness, perhaps a pinch of cumin, as something sweaty is involved.
Unfortunately, I am not familiar with costus. The unflattering description in the previous comment suggests that this ingredient is responsible for the undeniable mustiness that brushes against the old-fecal or universal-compost-like scent nearby, which complements and supports the patchouli and holds together throughout the day - a kind of center, indeed. So: nose a few centimeters away from the skin.
And then it becomes clear that the unpleasant part is solely due to the consistently uneven-earthy use of the extended patchouli. It simply has nothing approachable about it. But that is certainly intended, as ultimately the scent impression thrives on the contrast between the musty-earthy patchouli (along with its supporter) and the other elements.
In the afternoon, it becomes just a bit more balsamic and sweet. The patchouli with its attachments remains an unappetizing constant. However, if the molecular emission could be measured, perhaps more change would emerge than I actually perceive, so the center is indeed successful. The idea might be a little overextended by evening when not even an increasing musk addition can seriously dampen the stinky part. A particularly bizarre combination.
I will conclude with a comparison to film music: Even those for films I know well (which applies to only a handful of rather older movies), often leave me with a stale feeling when listened to detached from the screen. They are usually sharply distinguishable from "real classics." Of course, they are meant to accompany and never overshadow the images. That doesn’t change the fact that I find them, so to speak, castrated and, for example, do not want to hear them on the radio.
I feel similarly here. Tellus seems conceptually halved to me, like the olfactory accompaniment to a story that I do not know or recognize. It does not inspire me to come up with one. What a shame. And strangely - the ingredients were actually there.
I thank 0815abc for the sample.
It opens with an earthy-sweet start, immediately accompanied by a stinky bite. The patchouli note seems to glow quickly. I detect a hint of cinnamon sweetness, perhaps a pinch of cumin, as something sweaty is involved.
Unfortunately, I am not familiar with costus. The unflattering description in the previous comment suggests that this ingredient is responsible for the undeniable mustiness that brushes against the old-fecal or universal-compost-like scent nearby, which complements and supports the patchouli and holds together throughout the day - a kind of center, indeed. So: nose a few centimeters away from the skin.
And then it becomes clear that the unpleasant part is solely due to the consistently uneven-earthy use of the extended patchouli. It simply has nothing approachable about it. But that is certainly intended, as ultimately the scent impression thrives on the contrast between the musty-earthy patchouli (along with its supporter) and the other elements.
In the afternoon, it becomes just a bit more balsamic and sweet. The patchouli with its attachments remains an unappetizing constant. However, if the molecular emission could be measured, perhaps more change would emerge than I actually perceive, so the center is indeed successful. The idea might be a little overextended by evening when not even an increasing musk addition can seriously dampen the stinky part. A particularly bizarre combination.
I will conclude with a comparison to film music: Even those for films I know well (which applies to only a handful of rather older movies), often leave me with a stale feeling when listened to detached from the screen. They are usually sharply distinguishable from "real classics." Of course, they are meant to accompany and never overshadow the images. That doesn’t change the fact that I find them, so to speak, castrated and, for example, do not want to hear them on the radio.
I feel similarly here. Tellus seems conceptually halved to me, like the olfactory accompaniment to a story that I do not know or recognize. It does not inspire me to come up with one. What a shame. And strangely - the ingredients were actually there.
I thank 0815abc for the sample.
Translated · Show original
15 Comments
Sweetsmell75 8 years ago
and may it never come near my nose :)))
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MarWic 8 years ago
Who buys this and why - instead of pepper spray?
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Jumi 8 years ago
Tell us about Tellus, Meggi :) What are you sniffing this time? :)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Yatagan 8 years ago
You can see from my statement and my review that I viewed the scent much more positively than you did, but I have to admit it’s probably a matter of mood. I was in the right frame of mind to appreciate it and found it very innovative. In a different context, I might have rated it less positively. Definitely a controversial scent, for sure.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
MisterE 8 years ago
Then I'd rather go all out in style with a Louis or MKK from Lutens...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Pluto 8 years ago
Oh, I like patchouli, but not in a composty way :o)
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Palonera 8 years ago
Oh. My nemesis Patchouli at its peak, and then there are fecal notes too. It takes a lot of courage for that - which I currently don't have *trophy on the shelf and holding my nose to get away*.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Taurus 8 years ago
Sounds a bit exhausting...
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Mokka 8 years ago
Mutpokal..............!
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Seerose 8 years ago
Costus? Moss? Yikes. I read somewhere - not on Wiki - that it should smell "sandalwood-animalic-powdery." But every time I've encountered it, it smells awful, like baby vomit or something.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
0815abc 8 years ago
You're right. I can't stand the stinky trophy anymore.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Can777 8 years ago
I’m really into quirky stuff, so I have to give this a try. I’m sure I’ll think of a movie that fits.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Gelis 8 years ago
Not for me. Little trophy.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Gschpusi 8 years ago
It's not for me. But I'll pick up the crumbs.
Translated · Show originalShow translation
Ergoproxy 8 years ago
I liked it. When it comes to film music, I feel the same way as you do, but there are exceptions. I love the score for Interstellar by Hans Zimmer.
Translated · Show originalShow translation

