Fovere by Phil Julian (2025) - Statement by Ergoproxy

Helena1411 5 months ago

That's too exhausting for me.

Translated · Show original

CharlAmbre 5 months ago

Top notes are a tease. It was great for half an hour, but then.................

Translated · Show original

Rupansai 5 months ago

1

Ambrocenide clubs are already a nightmare for me with others. You can feel them coming from 100 meters away. 😷

Translated · Show original

Seta 13 hours ago

Yes! I suffer every day on the subway!

Translated · Show original

Rupansai 5 months ago

I see it that way too; everything else gets left behind.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 5 months ago

1

Somehow, they all smell the same to me, and the intensity is overwhelming.

Translated · Show original

carrioncrow 5 months ago

I found it rather terrible too...

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 5 months ago

I just didn't like it at all. But if someone enjoys it, they should wear it.

Translated · Show original

Seejungfrau 5 months ago

1

I felt the same way!
If you like Naxos, you'll be happy with this one.
It's not for me.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 5 months ago

1

Not for me either. If you like it, go ahead. 🤷‍♂️

Translated · Show original

Ropanski2020 6 months ago

4

Sounds pretty bad for you too. Artificial wood and carbon - usually there's no (natural) piece of paper in between. I can't stand the use of overwhelming synthetic compounds that flatten everything out. At some point, people will forget how to smell natural aromas. It's one thing for fragrances to be pushed, but it's another to directly attack users here just because you don't like their writing or rating. What experienced members have had to endure here... in the end, it shouldn't matter. Either the scent convinces you or it doesn't - newly established brands, supposed friendships, and supporters aside.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 5 months ago

5

I've never understood why people get upset about bad reviews or harsh critiques. As long as it's just the scent being criticized and not the people wearing it, I'm fine with it. Personal taste and feelings should be tolerated. Discussing it is pointless and unnecessary. If I got upset every time one of my favorite fragrances got a bad review here, I wouldn't have any peace. As long as I follow the rules here, I rate and comment as I see fit. So far, I've been left alone.

Translated · Show original

Cfr 6 months ago

Yeah, it's all a joke.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 5 months ago

I wouldn't make such a judgment. 🤷‍♂️

Translated · Show original

Rosalie234 6 months ago

It was almost the same for me; I'm sure it will find its fans.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

That's good. I'll stay away from it.

Translated · Show original

Mrtangiers 6 months ago

Once again, typical Carbonnel, I'm out.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

The style of the perfumer hasn't been my thing so far either.

Translated · Show original

Rogaux 6 months ago

This!
I found it just extremely harsh.

Translated · Show original

Rogaux 5 months ago

🤔 something like that... probably, yes. 😄

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 5 months ago

1

Are you saying you have to apply the scent before showering? 🤔

Translated · Show original

Rogaux 6 months ago

What’s left after two or three washes, I found quite okay. 😉

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

2

For me, the omnipresent synthetic notes overshadowed everything else. I can still smell it on my skin. 😩

Translated · Show original

Sweetsmell75 6 months ago

1

Is this that nasty fake wood?

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

1

The scent is sharp, sweet, and oddly spicy.

Translated · Show original

Ponticus 6 months ago

1

What a shame about the tobacco!

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

I didn't notice any. 🤷‍♂️

Translated · Show original

Spatzl 6 months ago

3

I'm afraid the synthetic notes would overwhelm me too much. But you can't really say anything negative about this fragrance.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

1

In the end, it's all a matter of taste. It's not for me. 🤷‍♂️

Translated · Show original

Gandix 6 months ago

5

I’d rather stay silent here. My statement was already deleted. Yeah. It was a bit inappropriate 🫣

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

2

I'm completely sober about this. It's just not a pleasant scent for me. 🤷‍♂️

Translated · Show original

Floyd 6 months ago

2

I'll save it for myself.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

I'm trying to forget it quickly, if it ever leaves my skin.

Translated · Show original

Heikeso 6 months ago

I'll steer clear of it.

Translated · Show original

Heikeso 6 months ago

How terrible 😭

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

2

I guess I’ll have to go to bed with this today. 😱

Translated · Show original

JonasP1 6 months ago

Yeah, I figured as much... Not really my thing either.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

2

To me, it all smells the same.

Translated · Show original

ElAttarine 6 months ago

1

I didn't like it either...

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

2

I can handle synthetic scents, but the way they're being used right now is just completely exhausting.

Translated · Show original

Skydiver19 6 months ago

I wave through -----------

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

1

I'm aimless and trying everything out.

Translated · Show original

Pollita 6 months ago

1

Stay away from that stuff.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

1

It's already clear who will get it. 🤭

Translated · Show original

Axiomatic 6 months ago

5

I would probably have given it a generous 2 as well.
It's amazing how it's being boosted to the highest rating here.
One might think there's something fishy going on...
Cheers to @Yatagan too!

Translated · Show original

Yatagan 6 months ago

1

Greetings back to both of you @Ergoproxy and @Axiomatic! 😁

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

2

I'm not really interested in the reviews and opinions of others, as always. It has to work for me, and that's not the case here. 🤷

Translated · Show original

Yatagan 6 months ago

3

I suspect I might feel the same way, but I'm amazed at the notes this one is getting. Image is everything, after all.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

2

You know I tend to ignore other people's reviews.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

2

You just have to go through it. 🤷

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

5

Overall, it's exhausting, overwhelming, and anything but a pleasant scent.

Translated · Show original

Ergoproxy 6 months ago

4

My thanks go to the Maschsee.

Translated · Show original

Fovere Phil Julian 2025